An essay thing
Post Reply
Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Fri Feb 13th at 4:08pm 2004


-Orph, the problems you have are with the church as far as I can tell, not with god. I myself do not belong to any particular church. any organization of people christian or otherwise becomes twisted from its purpose in time, most particularly in a capitalist society. the largest of churches have generaly lost sight of their faith in a flood of material gain. it also sounds as though most of your experience is with what i call "rapid christians". these people are always throwing religion in your face and behaving in the most ignorant boorish evangalistic manner possible. people like this are what gives faith a bad name. I believe that everyones path to god and eternity is different. there is no one "way". if you want a jesus quote for that try this on for size. "in my fathers house there are many rooms"

Lep- I was raised christian, but fortunatly for me my father is also a scientist who raised me as such. It might be correct to say that I have rejected the church, but not christianity. my faith is highly personal because I have thought about it and devloped many of my own ideas rather than accepting some standard line form whatever church.

Oh and in responce to the thing about the taxes, I believe that churches are subject to the same rules as any non-profit corporation, which makes perfect sense. after all, even if they build huge buildings, nobody becomes a millionair through the church, except maybe TV evangelists.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Gav on Fri Feb 13th at 4:16pm 2004


I would say, 95% of "churches" suck. [addsig]



Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by scary_jeff on Fri Feb 13th at 5:51pm 2004


The following is a way of showing the value of religion without a beliefe in a god of any kind - it is not meant to be an attack on religous people.

Imagine there was a society where there is no religion, but people are paid money if they are honest and well behaved - do you think this would result in a society that was overall better behaved and more honest/moral? Well pretty obviously yes.

Now obviously no society could ever afford this - but what they can do quite easily in a pre-science era is 'invent' a god who will reward them after death (something people are either affraid of, or can be easily convinced to be affraid of with ideas like 'hell') if they behave well in life. Perhaps the god will favour them in life as well (it's not hard to make people think that totally random events are down to something they did). Again, in a pre-science era, the god can be used to explain a great deal of otherwise unexplainable occurances, making it easier for people to believe, and therefore more likely to conform to the idea that good behavoir = reward.

Like this, the society will become more honest at almost no cost to itself, i.e. religion is a valuable aspect of society. To me, that seems like a feasable way that the concept of religion could have come about. The way I see it, this makes religion a good thing without there needing to actually be a real god - it's simply a beliefe in the concept that can encourage people to do good things when they otherwise might not have.

If people don't believe, well nothing is lost, and they live their life as they would have done. For people who do believe, it may make them into 'better' society members, and that can only be a good thing. It's win-win. People often say 'but there are so many wars caused by religion' - who's to say that if there was no such thing as religion, the less moral members of society would be starting wars about things they don't now, because they wouldn't attatch so much value to 'being nice' and 'trying to get along'.

I'm not saying there are no downsides to having religion, and I don't believe in some kind of higher being, but I am able to see the good that religion can bring about. I do not think that it is anybodies place to tell somebody else that they shouldn't believe in god or become a christian/muslim/whatever - if they want to believe in something now that most of societies values are based upon, fair enough.

But I still maintain that it is better to do good things because you personally want to, not because a 'higher being' does




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Bewbies on Fri Feb 13th at 6:01pm 2004


this thread is like... setting a new snarkpit record for integrity of the topic! /me claps for lep

but yea... like i said earlier, your friends' lives can only improve with christianity. as much as we may know its BS, if they're capable of believing it... i say more powa to em.

[addsig]



Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Orpheus on Fri Feb 13th at 6:23pm 2004


? posted by Tracer Bullet

-Orph, the problems you have are with the church as far as I can tell, not with god. I myself do not belong to any particular church. any organization of people christian or otherwise becomes twisted from its purpose in time, most particularly in a capitalist society. the largest of churches have generaly lost sight of their faith in a flood of material gain. it also sounds as though most of your experience is with what i call "rapid christians". these people are always throwing religion in your face and behaving in the most ignorant boorish evangalistic manner possible. people like this are what gives faith a bad name. I believe that everyones path to god and eternity is different. there is no one "way". if you want a jesus quote for that try this on for size. "in my fathers house there are many rooms"

you are probably right, as long as everyone here understands, i really don't know anyone well enuff to be singling anyone out.. its just how i view it all.

i am not attacking religion, because it exists, i am only ... well i am not sure exactly what my goal here is, other than to put my 2 cents in somehow.. i am not trying to convert, pervert or any other vert.

also, i have met people who truly have faith, and they liked me just the way i was.. no praying for me, no insulting whats so ever.. it was almost enuff to make me believe, their god truly did them right

anyways, i meant no harm to anyone at SP

[addsig]




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Yak_Fighter on Fri Feb 13th at 8:14pm 2004


Bah, if there's one topic I despise it's religion. To me it all comes down to personal faith. If someone wants to believe in something, let them. However, that person has no right to infringe upon others' beliefs to tell them what they are doing wrong or that they are going to hell or whatever.

'Spread the good word' my ass. Nothing makes me cringe more than when people play off their beliefs as the one and only and it's their personal job from God to save the rest of us from damnation. I am Catholic, and no amount of your bulls**t will change that fact. I don't care what you think about your religion compared to mine. I let you practice your's, let me practice mine.

So Lep, I would think the best course to take here is to not try and change their beliefs. What you should do is to tell them to cram their missionary work up their asses, just like you should about your personal beliefs. Keep them personal





Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Cassius on Fri Feb 13th at 8:16pm 2004


? posted by Leperous

With that attitude, seems like you're more likely to be the one going round with 'armed militias' Why are you so angry? What is wrong with questioning your religion?

Let me break it down for you Lep: you've just trashed my own mother as ignorant, morally and mentally inept, selfish and thoroughly un-enlightened. Shall I now politely and calmly engage you in quiet discussion upon your qualms about a religion which you have little concept of? I don't really think so.

You can question what I believe in any day of the week, dear Leperous, but you will do it politely and you will do it with respect, otherwise it has no meaning to me as being anything but a resentful insult.

Lastly, you seem to have done little to actually understand my post. There is no 'smarter' religion, no spirituality supermarket. "Oh, you got Islam today? Always a solid choice." No.

? posted by Leperous

Yes I am challenging your religion's legitimacy, because there are huge inconsistencies if you actually bother to study it. Was Jesus actually God or just a man without sin? Why does Judaism refuse to accept that Jesus was the son of God, despite making all the prophecies, being the chosen people of God, etc.? How can you believe the bible when it's half a collection stories from seemingly insane 'prophets' which you can't really take literally, and when it's blatantly been changed and mistranslated over the ages? (cf. the last section to the Gospel of Mark)

First of all, I would like to make it clear that I have bothered to study it, having been confirmed when I was thirteen and having gone to church nearly every Sunday since. For this same reason, I couldn't tell you about Judaism, because I've never really gone into it very deeply.

To the rest, Lep, that's called evolution. Do you think I would have a 'better' and 'more solid' or 'enlightened' belief in Christianity had the Bible not changed a word since it was first written down? Should I follow the laws from thousands of years ago and half a world away? The Bible, admittedly, has changed little over time for various reasons, but I said that for you to understand. You can't trash religion without understanding its origins and dynamics.

As for the insane prophets, I would ask you why you consider them insane. Why, because they liked to preach? Aren't you committing the same folly?

Lastly, I believe in that part of Christianity which applies to my life, nothing more, nothing less. It was written in a different time, but some values still do apply to my life.





Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by tom on Fri Feb 13th at 9:58pm 2004


? quote:
cure a Leper


hmmm, maybe if you believed in him, he might solve all your problems leperous..




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by fishy on Fri Feb 13th at 10:03pm 2004


forums are bad at he best of times for communicating ideas, but oh dear.

if i say that i believe in god, it would be safe to say that every one of you would have a different idea of what it was that i actually believe. some may picture an old guy with a big white beard, sitting on a throne, surrounded by fluffy white clouds and little cherubims. if you have that image of god, then thats what YOU believe in, not me.

even athiests, Lep, will conjure up some sort of image or concept, and having read through your .doc, i see that you would be quite right not to believe in the image that you have.

[edit] would someone care to define the term 'believe in', because if it's the same as 'believe god exists', then doesn't that mean that the devil will get into heaven?[/edit]





Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Orpheus on Fri Feb 13th at 10:08pm 2004


? posted by fishy

forums are bad at he best of times for communicating ideas, but oh dear.

i see that you would be quite right not to believe in the image that you have.

you know, these two statements are IMO, the only two completely unbiased sentences in this whole thread.

we would be wise to listen and learn.

/me bows to a master spokesperson.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Fri Feb 13th at 10:13pm 2004


-Fishy,

What you say is true regaurdless of the medium of exchange. even if we were all sitting in the same room we'd still have wildly differing concepts of god. One of the things that makes the Pit so great, is the wide range of intelligent people with wildly differing values who are perfectly willing to share them. You can find idiots expressing their opinions anywhere; it's hard to find the same thing with thoughtfull individuals.

I think the diffaculties of mapping must help to filter out some of the morons.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by fishy on Fri Feb 13th at 10:15pm 2004


Orph

/me *blushes*

T-B

some of the stuff i read on these boards blows me away.





Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Orpheus on Fri Feb 13th at 10:21pm 2004


? posted by fishy
/me *blushes*

meant it.. you said alot, in very few words.. a true spokesperson indeed.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Bewbies on Fri Feb 13th at 10:25pm 2004


if all of our statements weren't biased, would we have any reason to write them? =P

anyway... i think you should just quit, lep. you've managed to get a certain someone thinking that your opinion on a broad subject was a was a personal attack on him. god knows how he seems to come to these conclusions, but you won't get anywhere with reasonable logic =P

and is it just me.. or does this "cat" look an awful lot like a penis?

[addsig]




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Orpheus on Fri Feb 13th at 10:34pm 2004


? posted by Bewbies

if all of our statements weren't biased, would we have any reason to write them? =P

actually yes, you see, the beginning of comprehension is the ability to see the others perspective, without biased getting in the way.

i know, most of you feel that because i am "IN" most of the confrontations around here, that i somehow started them, but the fact is, i can see both sides most times, i just fail to express in in such a way as to seem otherwise.

anyways, i stand by my words, you cannot fix a thing, till you admit its broken... comprehension needs/requires it.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Bewbies on Fri Feb 13th at 10:37pm 2004


misquote!! you made me sound an awful lot like a middle-aged busdriver

[addsig]




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Orpheus on Fri Feb 13th at 10:49pm 2004


? posted by Bewbies

misquote!! you made me sound an awful lot like a middle-aged busdriver

aside from my utter confusion about this quote.. i can only concede, that you must know what you just said.

i stand corrected.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Myrk- on Fri Feb 13th at 11:41pm 2004


You believe a book written by Jesus the stoner? The man who smoked opium along with all the other peeps round that time? The miracles are just them tripping lol! [addsig]



Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Leperous on Sat Feb 14th at 12:08am 2004


Cassius, don't try to turn this into a flame war. I did not attack your mother, and I certainly never called anyone ignorant, inept, selfish or un-enlightened. 'Wrong,' yes, and if you take offence at that I don't give a crap. I'm sure you're thinking that's what I am, but I guess that's okay because you believe in a religion and it's okay for you to voice your opinion.

Christianity is a very clever concept and I have yet to find an arguement to destroy it (like I haven't found one to prove it utterly), but I still believe it to simply be an attempt to try to fulfill our lives, to give it a purpose and to feel better during it. And there is nothing at all wrong with that- my friend has actually since 'converted' and I'm happy for her as she seems to be happier now she's decided- but I don't need it, and most people can live a perfectly happy life either without fooling themselves.

Anyway yes there were some stupid things said in it and I've taken it down for some editing.





Quote
Re: An essay thing
Posted by Dr Brasso on Sat Feb 14th at 12:32am 2004


ok...in my unqualified demented reasoning.....something happened to create all we see....everthing in the world....pop was a chaplains administrator for 13 years when i was growing up, so i saw and heard quite a few things that disturbed me, in lew of what a "benevolent and caring God"... "should be like"....as ive grown up, ive seen things change, that a merciful God, as per the texts of the bible, would not let happen....in my humble opinion, religion in general is a state of mind people need to have comfort in thier lives...not all people mind you, but some...personally, i dont know if there is a God....and if there is, then i truly believe none of us has a handle on what he/she/it may be....we live, we die; ashes to ashes and all that.....the world had been in turmoil in one way or another since the inception, and if this is what it takes for people to have a sense of being, a sense of comfort in a tumultuous world, then so be it....i see no harm in that.....what i do have a problem with is people taking it to fanatical extents....forcing ones beliefs, especially without proof, is a sure way to alienate yourself eventually....and as for using religion as a basis for wars, well, thats about the dumbest ass s**t ive ever heard, basicly because it circumvents the basic things the religion teaches to begin with....fanatisism in any form or fashion is dangerous....as i sit here and ponder the words of the Leperous one, i can only conclude that you sir, have not yet been exposed to the trials and tribulations of a tumultuous world, and therefor are not in need of the psycological comforts that a religion brings....it boils down, in my mind at least, that people all the world over find comfort in something....in one way or another.....from the junkies on the street, to the pastor in the pulpit...the "mystery" is what breeds the needs....and your means help determine what you can and should believe in, in your own mind....

Doc B...

i look forward to a healthy debate, but as soon as it gets in a realm otherwise, im out....peace.






Post Reply