Snarkpit Forum Index » General Banter » Map posting rules?
Map posting rules?
1
Post Reply
Quote
 Re: Map posting rules?
Posted by ReNo on Mon Mar 1st at 10:03am 2004

I've been thinking lately that with the uploadable screenshots this site now uses, there is absolutely no excuse for NOT having screenshots with a map. Posting a little bit of info is all fair and well but a screenshot can tell a thousand words and all, and if the map isn't developed enough to even have one screenshot to show, it shouldn't REALLY be getting put up on the site. Perhaps it should be set so that if you don't have screenshots, you can't post it?

What are other people's thougths on this?

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Map posting rules?
Posted by Leperous on Mon Mar 1st at 11:00am 2004

Probably a good point for the maps forum, but otherwise I don't see the problem... Methinks a bit of laziness has crept in and now people look at the screenshots before commenting, and don't bother downloading the map itself





Quote
 Re: Map posting rules?
Posted by Kage_Prototype on Mon Mar 1st at 11:20am 2004

I think we should leave it with maps in member profiles, but in the map forum, the topic should at least have either a download link, or some screenshots. It's rather annoying when someone posts "Look at my map! Tell me what you think! Screenshots in a few days when I figure out how to use Paint ROFL!11!!!". Waste of space really when they could have waited until they had screens. [addsig]



Quote
 Re: Map posting rules?
Posted by ReNo on Mon Mar 1st at 4:30pm 2004

Well it certainly could be attributed to laziness, but in my situation its near impossible to comment on maps themselves (well, it takes a fair bit of effort to do in any detail, since I have to use the uni comps for a net connection), so screenshots is a nice thing to be able to talk about.

Perhaps it is more hassle to implement than its worth, as most people have the sense to not post maps without either a link to download or screenshots, but it feels like half of the maps on this website have no reason to be listed as they can't be downloaded OR looked at.

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Map posting rules?
Posted by $loth on Mon Mar 1st at 8:43pm 2004

i think reno has a good idea, not to post maps unless u have some screenies, or a download link. otherwise there is no point really.

we should have a vote!

bang bang

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Map posting rules?
Posted by Myrk- on Mon Mar 1st at 9:03pm 2004

Please, no picture of killbox can make a thousand words, unless they are repeated over and over and consist mostly of swear words..... [addsig]



Quote
 Re: Map posting rules?
Posted by Vash on Mon Mar 1st at 9:04pm 2004

/stops uploading killb0x2k4 [addsig]



Quote
 Re: Map posting rules?
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Mar 1st at 11:49pm 2004

/my 2 cents...

laziness aside.. i still think valuable input can be obtained with just screens alone, considering the alternative is NO INPUT at all without them...

secondly, some of us no longer have HL installed, and its rather tuff to load a map without it..

thirdly, some of us have put in our time for god and country as far as downloading,installing,critiquing, and posting a zillion screens of our own, its a fair request IMO, if anyone wants input, show at least as much effort, as you want in return.. if they want MY input, i want THEIR effort..

/2cents

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Map posting rules?
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Tue Mar 2nd at 1:05am 2004

I agree with Orph. I don't think I've ever bothered to do a critique if the poster hadn't already put up some screens. [addsig]




1
Post Reply