the Passion.....
Post Reply
Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Dr Brasso on Mon Mar 1st at 11:02pm 2004


whether you believe in God or not, this is a very moving film, if for no other reason, than to re-evaluate your take on mankind.....from a purely cinematic viewpoint, it very good, imho....it portrays the final 12 hours of Christ's life, and definately embosses your mind with the level of cruelty in the human heart, and the ability to perpetrate that cruelty to your fellow man....on a human level, i was seriously moved...on a spiritual level, you cant help but contemplate the reality of life as we know it.....this assumes you have a heart to begin with.....

Doc Brass...

ps..i am not trying to instigate anything here, i just felt the urge to share a thought or two......

[addsig]




Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by 7dk2h4md720ih on Mon Mar 1st at 11:26pm 2004


I don't think I'm going to waste my money watching JC get crucified on the big screen. [addsig]



Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Kage_Prototype on Mon Mar 1st at 11:43pm 2004


I do plan to see it, not sure when it's out in the UK though. Or is it already...? [addsig]



Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Leperous on Mon Mar 1st at 11:51pm 2004


I *hate* Mel Gibson, so sadly won't be able to watch this without being biased against it (although I hear it's not really that Christian so that's okay...)



Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by scary_jeff on Tue Mar 2nd at 12:04am 2004


A lot of people seem to not like Mel Gibson... I don't see what he did that was so awful?



Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Kage_Prototype on Tue Mar 2nd at 12:10am 2004


I blame that god awful excuse for a scottish accent in Braveheart. [addsig]



Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Myrk- on Tue Mar 2nd at 12:31am 2004


If I'm right I think Mel Gibson and his family are actually part of a serious cult which claim jews are meddling fools..... well Mels father said alot of contriversial stuff to the media about jews.... [addsig]



Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by gimpinthesink on Tue Mar 2nd at 12:49am 2004


I dont know why people dont like mel gibson I like quite alot of his films especially the Leathal Weapon series and Mad Max 2 but I didn't like Braveheart or Patriot that much.

I liked the battle seanes in Patriot especially when the cannon ball hit that bloke in the head but apart from that it was pretty boring and Braveheart well that was just crap especially the crap accent he did it didnt sound that scottish.

But as for the film about jesus I won't begoing to the cinema to see it not that I think it looks s**t cos from what I've seen it looks alright I just dont go to the cinema unless I really want to see the film.

I'll either wait for it to come on DVD or I'll aquire it in a few months.

There is one group of christians that got a license to show it at 3 venues around the US and they are (or were) planing on using it as a pice of propaganda for recruting perposes like they did with the last film about jesus.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Mar 2nd at 12:57am 2004


i have no real interest in this movie, but have been a big fan of Mr. Gibson since his mad max days..

i doubt he has any ulterior motives for this movie, no more so than many gay stars are out to promote gay-isms..

professionalism precludes most attempts at a "statement"

ask Elton John how well he faired with Disney when he "came out" and insisted he be allowed to..

Disney s**t canned him faster than .... well he is no longer associated with any Disney movies..

shoulda kept his mouth shut..

if Gibson has a motive, i doubt its anything religious.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Tue Mar 2nd at 12:59am 2004


It's a good film, and I think even non christians would agree with me.

The strongest message I recieved was, as Brasso says, the level to which human cruelty can go. regaurdless of weather you believe in Jesus, the things they show being done to him were standard forms of punishment in that time. The thought that ran through my head throughout was "how could you do that?" how could you bring yourself to accept such brutality as part of your job and society?

As to the rampant claims in the media of antisemetism, I think that's hogwash. Jesus was a jew, his followers were jews. It's completly irrational to caste the situation as antisemetic. If Jesus and his followers had been portrayed unrealisticaly as caucasian, then there would be a valid point, but the film was quite biblicaly accurate.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Yak_Fighter on Tue Mar 2nd at 1:06am 2004


Ah, Mel Gibson. Every time he releases an action-adventure or drama I am reminded of the Simpsons episode where he remakes Mr. Smith goes to Washington and changes the last scene into a overly violent action sequence with such brilliant scenes as impaling a senator with the American flag and cutting off the President's head with the Senate seal. That basically summarizes all the movies I've ever seen him in.

Ebert called this the most violent movie he's ever seen. Gibson likes violence and God bless him for it.

And Myrk-, that's just his father. You know, old people and their strange beliefs and prejudices...





Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by gimpinthesink on Tue Mar 2nd at 1:07am 2004


Did it have the suiside squad?

sorry I just started thinking about the Life of Brian where he's being crusifyed and a guard comes and askes who's Brian and every one but Brian says there Brian I love the bloke that says "I'm Brian and so is my wife".

I carnt beleve that that film was banned for 20 years for being anti-christian.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by whiteLegion on Tue Mar 2nd at 1:25am 2004


I got noth'n against mel. I do not like the Passion. I found it very shallow. I left at the part when they are beating him with whips which have razer blades attached to the ends. First of all anyone who has never heard of JC would learn nothing about the purpose of his life as christ. The movie showed none of gods teachings. And 2 hours and 30 minutes of a man being tortured is repulsive to me, and is not movie content. The movie is graphic to say the least. This movie doesn't set JC apart from others of the time because many others were also crusified. If it is a measure of suffering many people have been tortured worse.



Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Cassius on Tue Mar 2nd at 2:42am 2004


? posted by Dr Brasso

this assumes you have a heart to begin with.....

Well, that ruins my plans.

And, Mr. WhiteLegion, I don't think if you were getting your ass whipped with razor edge whips and nailed on a cross that you would give too much thought to the fact that crucifiction was a common practice (which I don't believe it was until Spartacus' slave revolt), much less that it was unfair to focus on your own suffering because others had been given worse treatment.

Had the movie explored into any of God's teachings, people would be having a much larger hissy fit about the whole thing, but that was not its end - the movie was made to show you exactly what happened to Jesus to inspire respect for the belief that he died for us.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by whiteLegion on Tue Mar 2nd at 3:05am 2004


My argument stands



Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Mar 2nd at 3:14am 2004


assuming the whole Jesus thing even occurred, i think a graphic depiction is in order, or at the very least, past due for one..

hell we have much more recent atrocities, that have been authenticated, and documented with video.. (i refer to the Holocaust movies such as shindlers list and/or the very REAL atrocities the american cavalry did to our native americans )

personally i doubt almost anything written as long ago as the bible for anything resembling authenticity, but considering so many DO believe its accurate enuff to read, i see no real issue with watching it in video form.

remember, i have not seen the movie, i am only commenting on what people seem to be saying.. i am not trying to start another Theo-war just voicing my concerns and/or thoughts.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Gwil on Tue Mar 2nd at 3:42am 2004


tbh orph, i dont think there is much actual doubt as to whether jesus existed, its more how you interpret his role in society at the time..

perhaps a particuarly gifted doctor/healer type, judged by the authorities to be an attack on their power - thus you have the crucifiction and whatnot..

ive not seen the movie but i'd like to, more out of curiosity than anything else, to see how Gibson fairs in his role as "director".

[addsig]




Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Mar 2nd at 3:50am 2004


my theory sir gwil.. any society that depicts jesus as a caucasian, deserves my scorn at best, and my outright .. well i have no faith in a people who cannot even get the race illustrated correctly :/

as to the guy "jesus" , i have no doubt he lived, but i also contend his life... was just as boring as the next sheep herder of the time..

jesus is larger than life, because it has been "told' that way, not because of anything that occurred..

[addsig]




Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Yak_Fighter on Tue Mar 2nd at 4:13am 2004


? posted by Orpheus

my theory sir gwil.. any society that depicts jesus as a caucasian, deserves my scorn at best, and my outright .. well i have no faith in a people who cannot even get the race illustrated correctly :/

Uh, Orph... Caucasian got its name from the Caucasus Mountains where Georgia, Armenia, part of Russia, and other countries now reside. Caucasian languages were spoken in Turkey and Syria. Caucasians come from the area that divides Europe and Asia, and if the term is applied liberally it's not a far stretch at all to call the people who live in the Middle East caucasian.

Anyways, what 'race' would the people who live in ancient Israel be anyways?





Quote
Re: the Passion.....
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Mar 2nd at 4:22am 2004


choosing to dissect my wording yakman

the race would definitely not be of the image we commonly see throughout the american churches thats for sure..

fair hair, light skin, essentially american white people.

now you could also dissect, my description or american white too.. but i think you grasp the gist of my comment, even if i illustrated it poorly..

america has "whitened" our rendition of the jesus we know today.

pictures of jesus, may look more authentic in other places, or countries, but i find it difficult to imagine the "jesus christ superstar" image coming from the location of Israel, or wherever his origin..

[addsig]





Post Reply