A HEALTHY political topic.
Post Reply
Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Crono on Sun Mar 14th at 1:00am 2004


Wow....less then 24 hours into this thing and it's huge.

I didn't think I would strike such a pipeline for conversation while keep the whole thing civilized

My earlier response was that, Orph, you getting divorced doesn't make sense if it's a protest unless EVERYONE, or a good majority of people knew of it.
If you, your wife, and your friends knew.......you're not protesting much, because with all those people you've already had indepth conversations.
The point of a protest is to publicly show your opinion. How is getting a divorce, which happens by the masses, going to do this? Now if you're doing it for the principle to satisfy yourself and your family....that's up to you and do whatever you want.

I'm just questioning it as a form of protest. Because, You also might be saying that marriage doesn't mean anything anymore if gays are allowed to be married as well, so you don't want to share a 'tainted' practice. But in that same right, no one holds marriage in proper lights anymore, by the very fact that you can get divorced.

To me, on a personal note, it shows disrespect to your spouce, a person you comitted your entire life to. If you hold marriage so highly that you would do this, the fact that you'd revoke it so easily puzzles me.

I'm not saying you don't love you wife or family, it just seems disrespectful that you'd end a union, legally, because there was some law passed.

Couldn't you rather hold the idea that your marriage is religiously upheld? I mean wouldn't that be enough? Or would you have to be as spitful as to make you and your family suffer simply because you didn't agree with someone elses lifestyle.....

Again I'm not picking on your anything, I'm really trying to understand your reasoning on this.

And I don't want the thread to deviate from you posting every third post lol. [addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Mr.Ben on Sun Mar 14th at 1:04am 2004


I've spent a while trying to write a post for this and have got no where. Not really knowing where i stand on it hasn't really helped. It's not that i'm homophobic, closed minded or anything like that but something just feels wrong about it all.

Marriage between a man and a women is like salt and pepper, knive and fork, black and white and all those other things which go together to me. I really can't articulate but it just feels iffy, not how it was meant to be.

I guess i shouldn't hide from change, if they change it so gays can get married so be it, yey for all the gay people out there and good on you but if they don't then i'll not kick up a fuss about it.

Society has to evole but there is something about marriage, the tradition of it all that to me should stay unchanged. I don't know what else to say, good day to you. [addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 1:09am 2004


crono, my wife and i share exactly the same views on homosexuality, everything i type, she agrees with.

we are very committed to our beliefs as well, to the point that if one of our sons came out today, he would not be our son tomorrow.. its that serious a breach of etiquette.. we would not try to discourage them from it, it is afterall a free country, but choices come with prices, and that the price in our family.

i hope that clears it up for you, as i said, its not religiously based, i have been married since 1981, and will not share that commitment with gays.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by scary_jeff on Sun Mar 14th at 1:21am 2004


? quote:
me: Orph, would you be opposed to it if one of the couple had to have a sex change before they could get married?


? quote:
if the partner knew in advance of the sex change, then no, i would however be opposed to any hidden information like that.


Orph, in this case, your total lack of respect for your fellow man (and don't give me that s**t about homosexual people not being your fellow man, they are, get over it), totally sickens me. You talk about gay men as if they are the great evil doers of our society, spouting off about how you hate them.

? quote:
the word hate means many things to many people, but it truly, best describes my feelings about the subject, when i think about it at all


? quote:
the only thing i hate more than gays are cell phones, but people always tell me to mind my own business about those two, in spite of the fact that they do indeed infringe on my rights to drive on safe highways


What on Earth are you talking about? Name one way in which a gay man has even so much as inconvenienced you. That crap about the taxes is a weak excuse. Gay people don't get married for money any more than anybody else. 'but I saw it on tv.. the gays were saying!' - oh WOW, who would have thought it, an american news company blowing things out of proportion and putting accross a totally slanted and inflamatory view!.

What would you do if 17 years from now, you find out your grandson is gay? Would you disown him? Would your love for him suddenly turn into burning hatred? Will you now just dismiss this as an impossibility, and if so, how can you possibly do this?

Your very own reasoning is simply obsurd. If 'gay is passed down', then how the f**k could you ever hate somebody for being gay? Going by your logic, if it was passed down, it would not be their fault, and you would be hating somebody for something that is totally out of their control - that's as bad as hating somebody for being disabled.

Look at it another way, let's say 'all gay people are just delusional and misdurected' - if this is the case, how could you hate somebody for making a bad choice? If you have made the wrong choice so much as once in your life, then you would be a fool to hate somebody else for making a mistake in theirs.

So which is it orph? Either gay people are misdirected, and you are condeming a whole section of society to eternal hatred just because they made a mistake, or 'gay is passed down', and you are passing the same judgement based on something that isn't even in their control?

Please either pick one of these options, showing that you are capable of such baseless hatred, or reject both of these rediculous notions and admit that what you are saying is totally insensitive at best.

Two question, please answer them without yet another bulls**t 'i have my opinions, and i like them' post




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Crono on Sun Mar 14th at 1:23am 2004


Kay, but:
? quote:
The point of a protest is to publicly show your opinion. How is getting a divorce, which happens by the masses, going to do this? Now if you're doing it for the principle to satisfy yourself and your family....that's up to you and do whatever you want.


That cleared it up, I was asking if it was a protest or not. [addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by scary_jeff on Sun Mar 14th at 1:26am 2004


? quote:

WHY SHOULD GAYS HAVE TO GO OUT OF THEIR WAY TO GET WHAT EVERYONE ELSE GETS?

because?

you should not be different, but be treated the same?


I don't believe my eyes. The whole point of this debate, and many before it, is that everybody is different but should be treated equally. I suppose 100 years ago, you would have said women shouldn't be allowed to vote etc, because 'they are different and shouldn't be treated the same'. Or what about black people, I suppose they should be treated differently? Or native americans? The list goes on and on, and you find that in each case, people got over it and accepted the fact that not everyone is the same, and that we should not punish people just because they are different




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 1:28am 2004


crono, its a principal, not a protest..

and jeff.. as bogoted as i seem to be, i am just to fagged (pun definitely intended) to argue about it any longer..

you are my friend, but no where does that mean you must share my views, as flawed as they are.

nite/nite all

btw, its a shame you were not here today.. you peaked my interest jeff..

[edit] jeff, did you notice, that even tho many disagree'd with my reasoning, many still said they disagreed with married gays, yet you only quoted me.. does that mean you also disagree with same sex marrage, but for their reasons and not mine?

again, nite/nite

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by scary_jeff on Sun Mar 14th at 1:31am 2004


Whatever Orph, I specifically said not another bulls**t 'my opinions bla bla' post, and that's exactly what you did. Well done for having such valid and founded opinions.



Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 1:35am 2004


? posted by scary_jeff
Whatever Orph, I specifically said not another bulls**t 'my opinions bla bla' post, and that's exactly what you did. Well done for having such valid and founded opinions.

jeff time and again, i have been counseled to ONLY post my views as opinions, now you condemn me cause i listen??

thats not entirely fair.. if i posted my views as factual, then you might have a case, but either i am allowed to voice my opinion as such, or not.. now which is it? or should we poll it to appease the gods?

i wont argue the point of gays, but i will defend myself from hypocrites who discount my beliefs.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Mr.Ben on Sun Mar 14th at 1:36am 2004


I love how my posts are totally ignored because someone always has to say something stupid just before or after i post. I don't even know why i post this, it'll only be overlooked. YEY?! [addsig]



Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 1:38am 2004


? posted by Mr.Ben
I love how my posts are totally ignored because someone always has to say something stupid just before or after i post. I don't even know why i post this, it'll only be overlooked. YEY?!

*gives ben a cookie*

you want center stage.. you have it.. but your previous post, the one between the two stupid ones, wasn't particularly monumental.. you might practice a bit

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by scary_jeff on Sun Mar 14th at 1:39am 2004


Why can't you answer either of my questions? They may be your opinions, but they mean nothing if they don't stand up to any kind of questioning. Of course you don't have to be quized on your opinions, but it makes what you are saying look kind of pathetic if you don't seem to have any basis for them, and can't answer simple questions on them.

[edit] MrBen.. what Orph said [/edit]

[edit2]I only quoted you because you were the only person who has totally falable reasoning for his views.[/edit]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Mr.Ben on Sun Mar 14th at 1:41am 2004


Cookies = win. Well i've derailed this topic enough, carry on hating each other. [addsig]



Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 1:46am 2004


? posted by scary_jeff
Why can't you answer either of my questions? They may be your opinions, but they mean nothing if they don't stand up to any kind of questioning. Of course you don't have to be quized on your opinions, but it makes what you are saying look kind of pathetic if you don't seem to have any basis for them, and can't answer simple questions on them.

[edit] MrBen.. what Orph said [/edit]

[edit2]I only quoted you because you were the only person who has totally falable reasoning for his views.[/edit]

will it be ok then if i answer to morrow jeff, truly this day has been long.. you know i respect you on many levels, but we have disagreed often, with IMO no discernible winner, altho you might disagree with that assessment as well ..

[edit] in truth i didn't even read it , its length alone told me it was another dictorial, jeffery style, and i am tired.

if you made valid points, i might concede you them, but no promises..

you know, me being wrong in your eyes has NEVER altered my view of myself

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 2:12am 2004


ok jeff i read all that, and i must say, you managed to once again mix quotes, but thats ok, everyone does..

also the 2 questions seem unclear but i will answer what i felt was asked.

working under the pretense that gay is a taught thing, cause thats exactly how i view it.

1) if my grandson came out, he would indeed fall into the disowned category, that is not my choice, that is how it is. if you think like i do, then it makes sense, he would know up front, and non-negotiable the terms of his decision. again its not up for debate from members of the snarkpit, its how it is in this home. my wife and i are in agreement, and since we are the ones having to pay the price, i feel it is our decision alone, not yours.

2) respect for fellow what? who gives a rats ass about fellow man crap. i base my likes and dislikes on my own criteria, they are also not up for debate by the pit..

i am sure that something in your life has meaning to you, but to no one else save you, so how is it different when i, or anyone else has them?

if these answers are not satisfactory, tuff, its as good as they get. seems to me, my rights to have absurd viewpoints come in a distant second to anything here sometimes

my views are not required learning jeff, accept them at face value and you will sleep better.. its not as if i am out to recruit members to my cause, in fact its quite the contrary, if i detected or was told i did so, then it would be different... corrupting young minds is no more my task than gays teaching the next generation of gays.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by KungFuSquirrel on Sun Mar 14th at 2:23am 2004


? quote:
corrupting young minds is no more my task than gays teaching the next generation of gays.


You know, if it actually worked that way... Jesus Christ, Orph, it's not a matter of a secret "re-education process" or some Orwellian bulls**t. Every one of your views and presumptions is coming from the standpoint that there's this huge goddamned conspiracy in the world.

Here's the news: There's not. Homosexuality is not contagious, and it's not f**king taught for chrissakes. It happens. They are people. Deal with it.

And what's this "we pay the price" bulls**t? Don't you think he'd pay a price. Do you think he'd voluntarily just choose to cause you to do that to him if the situation arose? A kid at my high school stayed in the closet until the day his father died because he had the same mindset as you. If the same were true of your grandson, would you want him to do the same? To hold it inside, practically living a lie, just because he didn't want to deal with the trauma of having your aforementioned reaction? I guarantee living his life that way until the day you and your wife have both passed on would be far more traumatic to him than dealing with it would be to you.

Anyway, I'm out of this one. I'm having a more and more difficult time keeping my responses controlled from what is practically outright rage at some of the things I've read in this thread. [addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 2:37am 2004


see you are still setting yourself up as MY judge, which is the same thing you are accusing me of.

i find it very difficult to accept, or to take people seriously, when they do the very same thing they are condemning me of.

my viewpoint is not up for debate, we are not discussing Orph getting married.

people know in advance, if you rob a bank and are caught, you go to jail, its not the same ,cause many believe homosexuality is NOT a crime, thats fine, but I DO, i do not have to justify it, i don't even have to defend it, people have had far more absurd beliefs without doing so.

listen close guys, you are making this go poorly, i could spout narrow views of your views of me, but thats wrong, and i refuse to stoop to such tactics.

my family KNOWS the price extracted for coming out, if it were to happen, so would the results, screw any other viewpoint cause they hold no value in my home, where guess what, I AM LORD.

now dammit, who needs to step back here? sure isn't me cause i have as of yet, committed no wrongs, there are no gays in my family, and by all i hold dear , i intend for it to remain so, in spite of public opinion, my word is law around here. (in my home)

andrew, all i can hope is, you do not have to face decisions that have no winners, cause you will screw it up with thinking like you currently have. sometimes, there are no winners, but choices still have to be made, i just like contingency plans. ones everyone are aware of. i would regret my decision all my life, but i would still do it.

my advice to both andrew and jeff, don't back me into a corner, cause as wrong as they are, i have my convictions, and will defend them. even if it cost me everyone here to do so. think about it, if i would judge my own kin so harshly, how do you think you would fair?

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Skeletor on Sun Mar 14th at 4:12am 2004


I have to admit that I will celebrate the day when all the people with these outdated, unfounded views on gays and other minorities are gone. [addsig]



Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Cassius on Sun Mar 14th at 5:53am 2004


Ladies and gentlemen, whatever your drive to insult each other may be, debate is impossible without respect. Let's keep that up here, shall we?

Here's how it is: homosexuality, while accepted and even promoted in American pop culture, is disdained by the American public. The fact that we have voted time and time again for our officials and measures that put down gay marriage proves that the subject is at odd with flat-out democracy.

However, I look at it this way: if you held a vote for all the American people of if they wanted to pay taxes or not, what do you think they would go for? Democracy, while it is the most functional large-scale political system, gives its people the freedom to be wrong.

But we can't control that, and we shouldn't try to; Newsom, elected himself by democratic procedure, should not cut straight through that in order to make himself more liked.

I see it like this: if it is truly good and right that homosexuals get married, we as a nation will eventually realize this, and do so on a wider scale than from pockets of very outspoken but very few defenders. Until then, do not try to rush the people, do not try to rush the law.

And I say again: the idea of 'thoughts that are incorrect to have' sickens me. Actions that hurt people are wrong, but words and thoughts cannot be evil. This of course means that I would not embark on these crusades you all seem to relish in participating in against Orph, damning his anti-gay views with every last politically correct term in the book. While Orph shouldn't be going out of his way to insult all homosexuals either, if he is indeed the head of his household, the decisions he makes with his own children are his to make.

Realize this: a world that is all-accepting is just as bad as a world that is super-prejudiced, because both are ideas of perfection through same-ness. Both sides here are promoting their way of thinking as the 'best', and you'll excuse me if I don't quite believe such a thing exists.





Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Jinx on Sun Mar 14th at 7:09am 2004


? posted by Mr.Ben
Marriage between a man and a women is like salt and pepper, knive and fork, black and white and all those other things which go together to me.

JUNGLE LOVIN'! Or does interracial marriage offend Orpheus, too? You're just being close-minded, Orph...

One of my fellow Action HL mappers was gay. Awesome guy, we used to tease him about how he liked to make giant skyscrapers.... often two of them side-by-side... gay phallices perhaps?! The funniest was when some stupid kid would make homophobic remarks while playing his map. If only they knew!

on a penis-related digression, in the AUT2k4 dev channel we were talking about the need for GIANT PENIS SMESHES.

<Superfisch> for some reason everyone wants a penis static mesh
<Melon> a huge one, please
<seekm> well you can always scale them
<seekm> to your pleasure
<Potshot> hehehe
* Superfisch scales Mels penis
<seekm> lol
<Melon> wow feels great!
<seekm> oh man
<seekm> hahaha
* seekm wipes tears
<seekm> you can scale mine next fisch!
<Jinx> lmfao
<Potshot> no do me!
<Melon> haha
<Melon> its your turn gentelman, im all done now
<Jinx> okay, I might have to share that in the other channel
<Superfisch> you will all receive penis scaling emails soon
* Jinx gives away secrit beta penis info
<seekm> aut2k3 is ready to beta test penis scaling!
<seekm> make announement!






Post Reply