A HEALTHY political topic.
Post Reply
Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Sun Mar 14th at 8:40am 2004


Well said Cass. The way Orph has been attacked in this thread for his views is disgusting.

On another note, I don't see how any of you can difinativly state whether homosexuality is heredetray or an environmental phenominon. To the best of my knowledge very little scientific work as been done on this subject, therefore any impression you may have one way or the other is most likely a simple product of the cultural environment which formed your personality.

In reality it is probably not an either-or situation. Homosexuality has been around for all of recorded history, thus it must have some genetic componant. However I see no selective darwinian benifit to being attracted to individuals of the same sex. Quite the opposite in fact. If indeed it is a genetic abboration, it seems to me that the levels of occurence in present society are unreasonably high. this suggests environmental influences, i.e. people learning homosexuality.

On a personal level I'm disgusted by homosexuality. I simply cannot comprehend the consumeing hunger I feel towards women being directed towards men.





Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 9:46am 2004


1st off, allow me to express my gratitude for the support, but i must say, it sure would have been nice had this topic remained as it did the first 7 pages, and you wouldn't have had to.

*blushes*

its hard for people like me to accept assistance, i always win, or lose, on my own.

2ndly, the answer is no jinxy, i am not racist, never have been nor will i.. the ideas of racist and prejudiced against gays, are not similar at all.

you must understand my upbringing guys, and you must accept this as i type it, not how YOU would interpret it to be.

racism is wrong, because people cannot help being BORN the way they are, hence it is so wrong to be racist.

homosexuality is a learned process, and a choice made by people, for whatever reasons, and can be frowned upon, without having to justify oneself.

now understand my quandary, i cannot blame people for how they are born, and if many of you are correct, and gays have no CHOICE, because it is a condition they are born with, then everything i have lived for has been for nothing.

people like me cannot accept being wrong on that scale, so we defend it until overwhelming proof is displayed to the contrary.

if its genetics, i am wrong, and i promise you i will alter my viewpoint accordingly, but i will retain the hope that science will isolate the deformality, before birth and repair the damage, there by removing the future hassles that poor child would have to endure from crass and uncaring people such as myself.

i will never apologize for my beliefs, no more than i expect you to appologize at being so close minded, about your open-mindedness (what a crock of an oxymoron).

if i am wrong i will admit it and strive to correct my wrongs, none of which have thus far involved real people. you may not live to see it, and maybe not i, but it will happen.

till then, i have committed no wrong, and need not answer to anyone, most especially not someone on the net.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Crono on Sun Mar 14th at 10:34am 2004


I was honestly curious or rather confused when I asked about your position several pages ago, Orph.

I don't think anyone here is trying to say you're wrong for believing what you believe.

I mostly think that people are being taken back by it, because they haven't been introduced (thoroughly) to someone as opposed to this situation as you. I know I haven't, short of my parents. I think it's kind of funny though when people think its okay for gays to have a sexual relationship, and some find it erotic or funny, yet the moment they want something more from it, it's not okay anymore.

It's actually a continuing theme in our society and I for one and appalled by it. In general I'm disgusted by people?s lack of intimacy and monogamous relations. I also am confused by the double standards that exist at the moment. But, whatever. Everyone has the right to think what they want, and as Cass said, it isn't hurting anyone unless (or Evil) they manifest it to effect other individuals. [addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by scary_jeff on Sun Mar 14th at 10:38am 2004


OK, so you would disown your own grandson.

Let me clear up the second question by breaking it down. What do you think is the cause of somebody being gay?




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by fishy on Sun Mar 14th at 10:57am 2004


? posted by scary_jeff
Let me clear up the second question by breaking it down. What do you think is the cause of somebody being gay?

do you want it broken down into the millions of individual answers that you would get from millions of individual gay people?





Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by scary_jeff on Sun Mar 14th at 11:14am 2004


Is that a joke? I'm trying to get a meaningful answer to my second question. After I have done this, I will have no more questions concerning Orphs position on this issue.



Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by KoRnFlakes on Sun Mar 14th at 11:20am 2004


I saw a program on mice, studying homosexuality. they cut mice brains into slices until they found a point that occured in most gay people, They reproduced it into female mice & they became lesbian so to speak, they thought they were male.

[addsig]



Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Leperous on Sun Mar 14th at 11:43am 2004


Someone once told me about a study that linked overpopulation with homosexuality (done on rats/mice) which could certainly be one reason. Seems to have turned into an 'urban myth of the internet' though- plenty of crappy ezboard n00b topics about it, but no references to the original study :/

Unless Korn is right and there is something (genetic) in your brain, I can't see how being gay is anything other than nurture?





Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Kage_Prototype on Sun Mar 14th at 11:50am 2004


All the gay people I've known, they've been gay for as long as they can remember. Hell, they don't even call themselves gay, it's just the way they've been their whole lives, and they wouldn't see it any differently. Call it a genetic defect if you want, but it seems to be more like nature to me. [addsig]



Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by $loth on Sun Mar 14th at 12:13pm 2004


? quote:

homosexuality is a learned process, and a choice made by people, for whatever reasons, and can be frowned upon, without having to justify oneself.

WRONG

Homesexualaltiy CAN happen during the whole birthing process, its all o do with the XX for females and the XY chromosones for males, the body is still the same for the male but with one slight problem, he is born with one extra X chromosone instead of a Y chromosone. [the opposite for females]

[addsig]



Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Jinx on Sun Mar 14th at 1:06pm 2004


my replies inserted in orange

? posted by Orpheus

racism is wrong, because people cannot help being BORN the way they are, hence it is so wrong to be racist.

homosexuality is a learned process, and a choice made by people, for whatever reasons, and can be frowned upon, without having to justify oneself.

Religion is a learned thing, too... so is all culture... does that mean it's okay to hate people from other cultures or religions? You have to understand that your way of life is not the 'only' way, nor is any more 'right' than anyone elses.

I think it's still out there whether or not homosexuality is learned or genetic... I suspect it's more of a continuum genetically, tbh, with culture influencing which way peopel 'go'. For example, in the Goth subculture there are many more people who are BIsexual, rather than identifying as strictly hetero or homosexual. The guy I'm reading now says it's probably because the subculture is more accepting, whereas in mainstream society, or gay subculture, you are pushed into choosing one or the other.

Whether it is genetic or learned, gay-bashers will still argue against it. If it's genetic they'll call it a 'defect' to be 'fixed'. If it's cultural they'll say it's a 'choice' that people make to choose something that is 'wrong' (in their opinion). There is nothing rational about this anti-gay hatred, and certainly nothing scientificly or ethically justified.

which reminds me... OF COURSE you have to justify yourself. That's the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Yes, you are entitled to your OPINION, but if you can't back it up in any reasonable way you can't expect anyone to respect it or take it seriously.

now understand my quandary, i cannot blame people for how they are born, and if many of you are correct, and gays have no CHOICE, because it is a condition they are born with, then everything i have lived for has been for nothing.

"everything I have lived for"?! you make it sound like hating gays is the focus of your entire existence. do you run some anti-gay organization or something?

I never imagined you could have so much hatred in you Orpheus, for a group of people who have done nothing to you. It's really, really scary to me.





Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 1:19pm 2004


? posted by $loth

? quote:

homosexuality is a learned process, and a choice made by people, for whatever reasons, and can be frowned upon, without having to justify oneself.

WRONG

Homesexualaltiy CAN happen during the whole birthing process, its all o do with the XX for females and the XY chromosones for males, the body is still the same for the male but with one slight problem, he is born with one extra X chromosone instead of a Y chromosone. [the opposite for females]

sloth, i am not even going to justify this, but i will say, i took advanced anatomy in high-school. i realize thats not college level stuff, but we thoroughly covered the chromosomes. you might check this out more and get back to us on it, cause unless some new discovery has happened in the last 23 years....

jeff, i have not been there when it occurred but i would think fishy is a lot closer to the answer than you might think. if i am correct, then it would actually be a myriad of things or events that cause gays to actually chose gay over straight.

many men, are in denial, but its a fact that men usually understand men better than women do, if the conditions warranted it, some men might just be weak minded enuff to not only seek out the counsel of men, but want, (thru the hormonal imbalances of puberty, and ALL the confusing things puberty brings with it), more than just counseling.

before puberty, i doubt that there is any way to show/prove/identify that a child will eventually turn gay, but during puberty, thats a whole different matter.

could this explain all? i doubt it, but i do know, children are very impressionable, and forgetful as well. most will not remember when this "gay" transition occurred, they will only remember it as "ALWAYS"

we all know, that in some shocking circumstances the mind defends itself, by forgetting, this might also attribute.. i am only speculating cause i cannot, and will not attempt to think like a gay, the thought of being aroused by my own sex, is worse than appalling so that precludes it, even were i able to force the thought.

how are gays taught? well jeff i reckon you will 1st need to find some, preferably more than just one, that will admit they were enticed (NOT COERCED as andrew would lead you all to believe ) and ask them to tell you. only in this way will you know, what it takes to make men, seek out the companionship of other men. if all gays deny they were taught, then all i can say is, it must have been one awful experience, to have caused them all to forget the event..

theres your answer jeff, take it, or leave it, but its the only one you will receive from this camper.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 1:31pm 2004


jinxy, has anyone ever told you that you have the ability to make mountains out of mole hills.. you really should not quote people till you can focus better, my life is all important to me, i do not have organizations founded to me, i have a belief system i govern my life with, when i speak of my life, it involves no one outside my family.

there are many wrongs in this world that have never involved me, should i ignore them too.. and don't attempt to persuade me gay is not wrong, cause it will effectively end this discussion.

lastly, there is either Gay, or Straight, there is no BI-sexual, once you have crossed the line, you are gay, you no longer have any claims on straight.. it would be akin to a part time rapist, or a part time robber, or murderer, you cannot part time an action even if you think gay is not a crime, it is a choice of action and there is no going back.

stop over analyzing my words, and adding meaning to them. i would appreciate it.

as i said, hate means a lot of different things, my hate, is more akin to a child hating spinach, if that analogy escapes you, oh freaking well

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by fishy on Sun Mar 14th at 2:11pm 2004


? posted by scary_jeff
Is that a joke? I'm trying to get a meaningful answer

what kind of meaningful answer can you get to a question like

? posted by scary_jeff
What do you think is the cause of somebody being gay?

i didn't know there was only one cause, so i posted a rhetorical question that reflected this.




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by scary_jeff on Sun Mar 14th at 2:18pm 2004


Well from what you are saaying Orph, it doesn't seem like, in your opinion, people make a decision to be gay? What I am trying to find out is whether or not you hate gay people for something that they didn't simply make a decision to be. Do you?



Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Leperous on Sun Mar 14th at 2:20pm 2004


Orph, define "being gay" for us, I'm confused about your bisexual point..?





Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 2:43pm 2004


? posted by scary_jeff

Well from what you are saaying Orph, it doesn't seem like, in your opinion, people make a decision to be gay? What I am trying to find out is whether or not you hate gay people for something that they didn't simply make a decision to be. Do you?

jeff, IMO gay is a choice, a conscience decision, how that choice is made, is a bit fuzzy, cause like fishy said, it could have, or be most anything... i doubt anyone breaks some poor kids arm and forces them.

? posted by Leperous

Orph, define "being gay" for us, I'm confused about your bisexual point..?

bisexual is another non-word, created to make undecided gays feel better about their choice of partners.

again lep, its the sex thing.. i realize gays see themselves as more than sexual partners, but straight people for the most part do not see gay people as partners for any other purpose than sex.. is that wrong? possibly, but that is another discussion entirely.

IMHO you cannot be a part time gay, once you have had sex with a partner of the same gender, you are gay, you just happen to like sex with the other sex also... sounds a tad greedy if you ask me. <--- points at feeble attempt at humor.

now i have no qualms about continuing this topic, but someone else really must assume center stage.. the amount of dislike not withstanding.. many have said no to this question... how about you all ask THEM why..?

[edit] LEP the stupid edit option is forking up again i had to make jeffs answer red, i dunno why, but my responce is there it just fails to show up.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Kage_Prototype on Sun Mar 14th at 3:00pm 2004


? quote:
again lep, its the sex thing.. i realize gays see themselves as more than sexual partners, but straight people for the most part do not see gay people as partners for any other purpose than sex.. is that wrong? possibly, but that is another discussion entirely.


Ok, I think we're generalising WAY too much here. [addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 3:15pm 2004


? posted by Kage_Prototype
? quote:
again lep, its the sex thing.. i realize gays see themselves as more than sexual partners, but straight people for the most part do not see gay people as partners for any other purpose than sex.. is that wrong? possibly, but that is another discussion entirely.


Ok, I think we're generalizing WAY too much here.

of course its generalizing, how else would someone say this without being so?

i mean seriously guys, whats this fixation on perfect clarity you all seem to have.. it has to be another attribute of age, cause i vaguely remember going thru the stage myself, but there are limits, and most of you have exceeded them.

a persons opinion doesn't have to be clear to anyone other than themselves, to be real.

stop asking me to explain myself, work harder at this open-mindedness you claim to possess and include MY opinions as a possible outcome too. i am not asking anyone to share my views, but i am asking you to take them seriously, that is if you really want some level of respect to remain.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A HEALTHY political topic.
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Mar 14th at 4:08pm 2004


i am about to leave for kentucky, if you guys want to continue being close minded, about your open-minded views, you will either have to wait for my return, or continue without me.

just bare in mind, if you continue, nothing you post will alter my mind, so chose your wording as best you can to reflect upon yourself, continuing to disregard my opinion as valid, only reinforces my view of not taking you seriously... disagree, but don't do so in a way that discounts my view as wrong. unless you are omniscient, i doubt any of you know for certain i am indeed incorrect.

i would like to point out, that although i am not privy to the entire world, my small piece of it has many whom share my views on this topic, (the marriage issue)

anywho's

be good.

[addsig]





Post Reply