| ? posted by Myrk- |
Critiques affect the map, reviews critisize... therefore critiques are more useful to the mapper, but reviews are useful to 56k users because they want to know wether the map is worth waiting 10 mins to download  |
10 minutes? I tryed to download a map yesterday and gave up after 20
| ? posted by Myrk- |
| Critiques affect the map, reviews critisize... therefore critiques are more useful to the mapper, but reviews are useful to 56k users because they want to know wether the map is worth waiting 10 mins to download |
i would hate to think, i got, or lost snarkmarks because i was not 56k friendly on my critiques 
| ? posted by Orpheus | ||
i would hate to think, i got, or lost snarkmarks because i was not 56k friendly on my critiques |
I would read your reviews any day
Hey if you need a template review ish thingy, take Cliff Complex for a run I've been waiting more months than I have fingers for HLatlas to review it.
ty for the comment to.i agree with everything you said duncan, but cannot help thinking, reviews are more intended to be ego boosters, or worse, they can end a mappers career.
but the lost critique you mentioned, i dunno, it has to be more valuable simply because its a vital step to the completion of the map, for which there would be no review otherwise..
i don't wanna give the wrong impression, i wanna do reviews myself, if its possible for me to do so.. and i do not plan on short changing people because i feel critiques are more valuable, i will give it/them 100% of my efforts as well.. but i just cannot see them as equal at all..
sorry to disagree, but thats ok, doesn't make me right after-all
[ontopic]
WHAT!?!? HL1 snarks arent scabby, theyre cool.
[/ontopic]
Do the ratings for your maps/tutorials/etc. get counted in the calculations? I know your user rating does...
[addsig]
