A Question
Post Reply
Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Gwil on Mon May 10th at 3:55pm 2004


? posted by flashman
? posted by Gwil

Is that an actual famous verse Gollum? it rings a bell..


"If" by Rudyard Kipling.

*me nods to learned friend* thank you sir

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Yak_Fighter on Mon May 10th at 4:17pm 2004


? posted by Kain

...why do I have the impression that all the threads finally turn into US vs UK wars?

Brothers get into fights all the time for the most pointless reasons...





Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Gwil on Mon May 10th at 4:41pm 2004


I'd hardly say 2 threads in about 3 weeks is "all threads" and derailments can't be helped.. restraint is needed by all.

It is harder to exercise it in reaction than it is in gesture.

*whacks pe0ns with meat tenderiser*





Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Orpheus on Mon May 10th at 4:58pm 2004


? posted by Gollum
? posted by Kain

...why do I have the impression that all the threads finally turn into US vs UK wars?

Because they do.

hardly all, but of late..

sadly i end up in some of them, in spite of the fact that i am so un-politically minded..

i kept my words on this subject rather muted the first couple of years i was here, for forum stability, but since the war, the innuendo has exceeded even my patience on the subject.

fortunately, the burning is with a far less intensive flame than they were before i joined the discussions... let us hope the trend continues.

my advice sir gwil, get a bigger stick, cause the peons have not been the issue of late

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by scary_jeff on Mon May 10th at 9:06pm 2004


Hah, well this went sort of downhill

My friends and I always laugh at films where the bad guy is either British, with a strong accent, or German, speaking english in a german accent Films at least never seem to show an american vilain




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Kage_Prototype on Mon May 10th at 9:57pm 2004


? quote:
My friends and I always laugh at films where the bad guy is either British, with a strong accent, or German, speaking english in a german accent Films at least never seem to show an american vilain


Pfft, the best was Hans Gruber from Die Hard. He was supposed to be German, but he spoke with a distinctly english accent. [addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Orpheus on Mon May 10th at 10:10pm 2004


when i was younger, i lived in texas, and arizona, i had lots of mexican friends..

i used to ask them if the translation on the screen of a subtitled movie was actually what the mexican bad guy (or good guy) really said..

most times it was not..close but not what the subs said..

someday, i would like to compare notes with you gents on, is the actor really speaking german,japanese,ect,ect

also, i wanna compare notes in the opinion of, do movies truly stereotype.. germans always villainous, brits always saintly, ect,ect.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Leperous on Mon May 10th at 10:35pm 2004


Brits always seem to be the clever ones, rather than the evil ones... Irish are criminals usually too



Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by KungFuSquirrel on Mon May 10th at 10:37pm 2004


*ahem* Star Wars Universe, anyone?

As if the Chasing Amy conspiracy weren't enough, now we have the uncultured races of the galaxy uniting to bust up the Emperor's tea party on the Death Star. Sad story. [addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Orpheus on Mon May 10th at 10:46pm 2004


? posted by Leperous
Brits always seem to be the clever ones, rather than the evil ones... Irish are criminals usually too

irish are usually depicted as sots (alcoholics), and chinese as evil too ..

hmmm, interesting concepts.. i will definitely watch movies with interests in origins of characters from now on

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by scary_jeff on Mon May 10th at 11:03pm 2004


? quote:
most times it was not..close but not what the subs said..


Often this is because a direct or literal translation would either not make proper sense in the translated language, or not sound natural. This is especially bad with translations to chinese/japanese for some reason... I suppose a good example would be japanese computer games where instructions or what characters say sometimes don't make sense.

I have this cartoon series, 'the mysterious cities of gold', it was originaly french, and apparently a lot of the times where in the english version, a character just grunts or chuckles, this was because there was no english translation of what they said in french that would be meaningful.




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by gimpinthesink on Mon May 10th at 11:55pm 2004


? posted by Gwil
? posted by gimpinthesink
I'd like it if they started sellin g fritsauce over here cos at the min I have to go to Holland for it.

you go to holland to buy one product? that's commitment that is.. unless - Holland? Does one have an "alterior motive" as it were, possibly beginning with A and ending in msterdam.

No my dad used to live there but thats not to say I didnt visit Amsterdam on my travels over there though.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by blu_chze on Tue May 11th at 3:50am 2004


i think it strikes me as odd that for the 5 days i was in canberra, i didnt notice the lacking rail network.

Dam charter buses.

has anyone seen an australian, indian or indonesian villian before? i dont think i have

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Tue May 11th at 4:45am 2004


Well, as most major films are made here, I hardly think it is suprising that there is no sterotypical american villian. there are plenty of american villians, but only when the good guys are americans too

The brtish villian is a long tradition which I don't quite understand...

For some reason americans love the aussies, so an australian villian wouldn't go over so well...

I don't think I agree with you Orph, when you dispute the wealth of america. yes there is poverty, and no I havn't seen everything in this country, but I have never seen anything in this country that even remotly compares to mexico. a bum on the street in an american city looks rich compared to what I have seen in mexico. As I say though, I haven't seen everything...





Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Kain on Tue May 11th at 8:49am 2004


British vilains are usually adequate in a movie with a black good guy. So it's the spontaneous and brotherly hero vs the cold classy vilain, with an "Anthony Hopkins" like accent, who for example mercilessly kills one of his men in the first scenes...

Arabs are usually bad guys, but I guess the subject is still too serious to make jokes about... In arab action movies (whenever they have a sufficient budget for that) villains are always israelians. I once saw an egyptian movie called "Al Massir" (the destiny), where vilains are some kind of fanatic organisation, clearly an allusion to terrorism; I read that this movie has endangered his author, who received threats from integrist formations... Some people just can't stand critics.





Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Gwil on Tue May 11th at 12:27pm 2004


Hollywood just changes its villian casting to suit the enemy at the time russians in the cold war, brits just generally, arabs nowadays/at the time of earlier wars...

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Orpheus on Tue May 11th at 12:33pm 2004


? posted by Tracer Bullet

I don't think I agree with you Orph, when you dispute the wealth of america. yes there is poverty, and no I havn't seen everything in this country, but I have never seen anything in this country that even remotly compares to mexico. a bum on the street in an american city looks rich compared to what I have seen in mexico. As I say though, I haven't seen everything...

first off, poverty is everywhere, but separating it into more/less impoverished??

how would you explain to a hungry child in the US, that there are more hungry ones in mexico exactly TB ?? that would be like separating murders, well victim #1 got killed with a polo mallet, so its less violent than #2 who was killed by a shotgun? or a woman is raped by a man with an 8 inch penis, so victim #2 is worse off cause here raper had a 12???

poverty is poverty, and IMO its more a tragedy if a country can support its population and still fails to do so.. yes, the US qualifies in that regard, we have more than enuff resources to support our own, yet we fail miserably.

i don't see mexican poverty around here, i see american poverty, and thats closer to home, hence MORE IMPORTANT.

mexico has the resources, it choses to spend them in other areas.. in fact many countries have enuff resources...

anyways.. i appreciate your sentiments, but i live them.. poverty is less than a few miles away

http://www.ssa.gov/legislation/image008.gif

http://www.lift.nccp.org/images/state_charts/chart_family_structure_AR.gif

http://www.uaex.edu/hempstead/images/county_profiles/fig36.gif

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Gwil on Tue May 11th at 1:19pm 2004


I think the point is that no-one is doubting US poverty levels, but we want to see changes made by Governments and corporations who play BIG roles in affecting poverty in countries around the world.

Cheap labour, overinflated food prices, non-trading, unfair localised trade agreements... these aren't policies that affect bums/hobos on US streets etc most of the time, but they can give millions of people a better quality of life with the sacrifice of a few dollars or over-production. It just becomes a bigger issue for all of us to deal with, when entire countries are affected by our actions/policies in developed nations.

On a side note; I don't believe LEDC's do have the resources to tackle their problems - poverty is already widespread over underfunded infrastructures, and the largest employers are usually corporations from abroad, who simply set up shop to exploit cheap labour and desperation amongst unemployed people. A lot of these countries are far behind us, because we have meddled with them for the last century - backing regimes with dubious motives, exploiting them for military/economic purposes, etc etc. We destroyed what could have been prosperous nations, now is the time to redress the balance and support them - not use them.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Orpheus on Tue May 11th at 1:36pm 2004


the things you think are important, may not effect the average hobo/homeless, once they become that way, but it is usually the catalyst for creating hobo's and homeless gwil.

people don't just decide one day that it is desirable to be a hobo (although i have read articles of the beggars making a fair wage on the freeways of america :/ )

anyways, it seems a fair assessment, that we see things differently, have different priorities, we share a common belief, but think the causes are not the same importance.

i suppose, this is a clear case of agreeing to disagree..

from my persecutive, i want to fix whats close at hand, work from the ground up.. you want to fix what you cannot, thats far away and from the top down.. i think my ideals are more realistic, but i don't fault you yours.. dreamers sometimes prevail..

[addsig]




Quote
Re: A Question
Posted by Gwil on Tue May 11th at 1:45pm 2004


Heh, i'm the first to admit I mostly back futile causes and ideas, and acknowledge compassion doesn't "swing" in international affairs, money and power politics do.

There can be some movement though on the smaller issues, and I hope by raising money/vocally supporting organisations etc I can make my small change, become one big change for the better.

Indeed, no major shifts will happen until people are united to fight poverty, injustice and exploitation at home, and abroad - but thats another kettle of fish entirely, and probably impossible judging by our very nature as humans. It's all a great shame really, when compassion for the fellow man is a rare trait in todays individualist world

and yeah, agree to disagree - we could debate this til we were blue in the face

[addsig]





Post Reply