U.S. Election
Post Reply
Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Spartan on Tue Oct 19th at 12:17am 2004


? quoting Crono
A good start would be teachers who actually care about the children/student's welfare and education.

A lot of lower grade teachers, don't, and it's quite obvious since they refuse to actually tell kids about certain situations of whatever they may be learning, not to mention the automatic assumption that children are, in general, stupid.

And if they don't think that way, that's how it comes across.

I completely agree with you Crono. I look back on my days when I was I attended elementary school and think it was a waste of time. Kids could be taught so much more but the teachers don't care. Now I know that not all elementary school teachers are the same but many of them are alike. They are also bias against kids. Trust me when I say this because I had friends who's teachers would treat them like s**t compared to everyone else for stupid reasons. I have even seen racist teachers and there were a few of my own teachers that didn't like me because I was a guy. If you have kids you have probably heard them tell you something along the lines of "my teacher doesn't like me". Most of the time it is just an exuse but sometimes it may very well be true.





Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Gwil on Tue Oct 19th at 12:17am 2004


Crono to be fair, I think I recall you speaking on this topic before - it seems a bad experience has soured you to teachers full stop. I obviously can't comment on the standards of teachers in the U.S., but I imagine it is the same as here - the teachers, for the most part, do care - it is the Government policy that dictates the standard of education they can give.

I know my father for instance feels his teaching has suffered over the past few years, as a result of becoming disillusioned with the system that we have in place. That's when things turn start manifesting themselves in ways similar to those which you cite - ie, the teacher becomes apathetic, and treats the job, just as a job - not a love, or a passion, with which most sign up to this thankless career.
[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Oct 19th at 12:31am 2004


*sighs*

you guys ain't gonna listen are you.. i dunno about where you live but this subject brings out the worse responses imaginable..

my advice, for what its worth, if you do not have children in school, be very careful how you postulate your comments/theories.. being in school looking forward, and being out of school looking back, doesn't compare to being a parent and doing the exact same thing.

anyways.. i think i will let you all decide, just how far to go with this.. but i can tell you this much, it is my considered opinion, that the root cause of the school problems, are not governmental..

[edited for people who cannot read very well !! ]

[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Spartan on Tue Oct 19th at 12:34am 2004


? quoting Gwil
ie, the teacher becomes apathetic, and treats the job, just as a job - not a love, or a passion, with which most sign up to this thankless career.

Yes Yes thank you, someone finally said it. This is the problem; like Orpheus said it is not a government issue but one with the teachers.





Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Crono on Tue Oct 19th at 12:37am 2004


Are you telling me that the lack of proper information and studies has nothing to do with bad educations?

I understand raising a child has a lot to do with other childrens/people experience with them. But, come on.

Schools in general are malfunctioning systems.
They claim they need more money for several things, then they don't spend the money on that. They refused to go with cheaper, newer alternatives to several technologies and transportation issues. Did you know a RAZ bus costs the same as a school bus to rent (At least here) ?

The whole point is, it isn't one area's fault. It's all area's faults. Parents, Government, Teachers, subject matter. All of it. [addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Gwil on Tue Oct 19th at 12:37am 2004


yes but teachers become apathetic for a reason i gurantee there are thousands of teachers in the USA who hate the government for implementing crappy policies in education, i absolutely guarantee it.

teachers want to be free to teach, not be bound by policies from above...

Orph, your sentiments smack of "your opinion is not valid and I wont listen" :/

whatever you believe, your stance and ideals do not make anyones opinion ANY LESS VALID

fact.


[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Oct 19th at 12:46am 2004


? quoting Gwil

Orph, your sentiments smack of "your opinion is not valid and I wont listen" :/

get off my ass gwil, before you piss me off, thats NOT what i said at all, i am saying that this is a volatile topic, and should be handled with extreme caution..

believe me, i went through this when i had to home school, its not something you can JUST DO!! you have to show just cause before you are allowed..

i am saying this as nice as i can, if you falsely accuse me once more of having ill intentions, i will go off on you.. am i being perfectly clear??

being an adult with kids does put things into a different light.. but i am telling you, you are wrong about what i have to say, and i am betting you will be surprised with my replies on this topic.

do not falsely accuse me again .. PLEASE. twice in one day, is not accidental.

need i remind you that YOU used those exact words on me when i was telling you how moderators should be?

[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Spartan on Tue Oct 19th at 12:48am 2004


? quoting Crono
Are you telling me that the lack of proper information and studies has nothing to do with bad educations?

I understand raising a child has a lot to do with other childrens/people experience with them. But, come on.

Schools in general are malfunctioning systems.
They claim they need more money for several things, then they don't spend the money on that. They refused to go with cheaper, newer alternatives to several technologies and transportation issues. Did you know a RAZ bus costs the same as a school bus to rent (At least here) ?

The whole point is, it isn't one area's fault. It's all area's faults. Parents, Government, Teachers, subject matter. All of it.

What I am saying is that the lack of education is not because of government used towards schools but the teachers themselves. I have been fortunate to have such great teachers in my high school but there are still many that to say the least are dumba$$es. The reason I say will be explained. We all have home rooms which we only attend about 4 times a year for FCAT test. At the beginning of the year we had to attend our home rooms for the first few days. My "high school home room teacher" wanted to check our papers to make sure we had our names on them.

It's high school and she treated us like 3rd graders for God sakes. Also many of the teachers hate their jobs and will simply give out a worksheet for the students to do while they play solitare on the computer. There was junior high teacher that actually did that too. ALso you will hear how these elementary schools complain about lack of money yet at my little sisters school they spend around $4000 a year on pizza partys for the AB honor role kids. Why not stop wasting it on useless crap and put it to good use. Like buying somewhat decent comps instead of making the kids use 100mghz macs.





Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Crono on Tue Oct 19th at 12:52am 2004


Spartan, I didn't contradict you ... at all ... [addsig]



Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Gwil on Tue Oct 19th at 12:55am 2004


Well, believe what you like Orph but this isn't the first time you've said other people have no good stand to comment on a subject because they don't meet or have some requirement.

If you're going to put your 2 cents into an argument/debate, don't try and belittle others opinions before or after they have been posted, because it looks like incredible ignorance on your part.

And please, don't lecture me. I'm sick to the back teeth of it, moderator or not.




[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Oct 19th at 1:03am 2004


you can get sick till the teeth fall to the floor.. i didn't say no ones opinion was invaluable this time, i said its unique when you are from the perspective of a parent..

i gave you a chance to re-read it and with my explanation you should have had enough opportunity to save face.. you threw it back in my face.

i suggest you re-read it again, it may not help our current situation, but it might shine a bit of light.

next time you falsely accuse me, will be a problem..

for the record, stop using the term "knee jerk" it stinks of spontaneity, i can tell you that on this topic about schools, i have had years..

[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Gwil on Tue Oct 19th at 1:05am 2004


Whatever, I can't be bothered either way.


[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Oct 19th at 1:12am 2004


? quoting Gwil
Whatever, I can't be bothered either way.


dammit, don't do this.. every time your screw up you act this way.. its not wrong to admit mistakes, but its damned immature to run from them.

i look to you much more than you may think, but my patience does have its limits, and 2 times in one day is about maximum.

as i said, you may be surprised at my replies.. but now, you may never know.. we haven't even begun to talk about educational woes and already we have chosen sides.. i seem to be wrong, before i have even posted.

you need to go to bed.. being tired, is not always a good enough excuse.

in fact, i think i'll go to bed, and decide if my knowledge of education is worthy of so knowledged a member-base. :/

[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Gwil on Tue Oct 19th at 1:15am 2004


I'm talking about a much, much wider issue Orph - and it's not about this topic. Like I say, I can't be bothered to thrash it out again because it always, always turns into a lecture.

Either way let the topic roll on, i'm not discussing this any further.
[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Oct 19th at 1:20am 2004


if, you have issues outside the forum.. i am sorry.. i do understand real life.. sometimes its overwhelming. but you cannot let it effect our relationship inside this community, its not as if my woes and yours will ever intermingle.

if i wrong you, i usually accept your word for it and bow out.. you have trouble reciprocating.. i ask you once more, please re-read my reply and see if i didn't have the topics best interest in mind, or at least the possibility that i could have.

you can be anything you want, but you cannot step on me while you are doing it.. i'm sorry but i am adamant on that.

i'm off to bed.. its up to you now to decide if i am still worthy.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Gwil on Tue Oct 19th at 1:29am 2004


? quote:
*sighs*

you guys ain't gonna listen are you.. i dunno about where you live but this subject brings out the worse responses imaginable..

my advice, for what its worth, if you do not have children in school, be very careful how you postulate your comments/theories.. being in school looking forward, and being out of school looking back, doesn't compare to being a parent and doing the exact same thing.

anyways.. i think i will let you all decide, just how far to go with this.. but i can tell you this much, it is my considered opinion, that the root cause of the school problems, are not governmental..

[edited for people who cannot read very well !! ]



Yellow text

? quote:

Posted by me

whatever you believe, your stance and ideals do not make anyones opinion ANY LESS VALID


Blue text

? quote:

Posted by me

If you're going to put your 2 cents into an argument/debate, don't try and belittle others opinions before or after they have been posted,


My opinion is that the Government DOES have a large part to play in the way schools are run, in fact, it is fact. Schools arent just rogue outposts of crazy teachers, you know. We have something called society and administration, and curriculum...

If needs be I can point to numerous other examples of where you do this, on various topics of varying ages? Just in case my judgement, or ability to read is being clouded by my "troubles outside the forum" (way to go presumptions!).

Oh, and i'm not tired. I didn't get out of bed til 2pm, go figure.









[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Oct 19th at 1:36am 2004


gwil,

read my PM, afterward, i expect that smile.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Tue Oct 19th at 1:37am 2004


? quoting Gwil



I haven't said that anywhere, to be fair A slight kneejerk response from me, admittedly, but I have extremely strong feelings about the U.S. foreign policy

I said this

Yeah, it's a generalisation - but I pour scorn on 70/80% of the people eligible to vote in both my country, and your country. Blair capitalises on stupidity over here, just as Bush (and Kerry too) does over there I'm not saying that everyone who votes for Bush is stupid, but they are stupid for voting blindly. The same way people are stupid for voting blindly over here If you do vote Bush yourself, I'd assume you did it because you knew his policies/supported them.


Understood. I also have great faith in the stupidity -or ignorance- of the vast majority of the elctorate... I should have comprehended your meaning.

With respect to education, I think it is practically useless until you get to high school age. Of course that is entirely anecdotal evidence of my own experience...

In my view, the root cause off all our educational woes is that children learn three things in elementary school that cripples them for life:

1. Reading and writing are boring

2. Math is stupid

3. Science is dull

These three lies, primarily "reading is boring" account for 90% of the ignorance in America. By forcing children to "learn" what we say they must before they are ready, our school system robs them of the most precious thing humankind posses: the desire to learn. Children are naturally curious about everything, it is only after the first few years of school that this gift is destroyed.

I spent almost my entire childhood playing. I didn't even read well until I was 10-11 years old. Until I turned 13 I spent practically all my time outside digging in the yard, playing with LEGOs, building in the basement, and running around with Friends. Oh, my parents insisted that I learn SOME things. I could do basic arithmetic, and I knew how to read even though I couldn't do it well. I NEVER spent more than 2 hours a day on what anyone would call "School". However, despite what might seem to be a recipe for ignorance, the next-door neighbors were calling me "the professor" when I was 4-6 years old because I had a huge highly articulate vocabulary. My parents read to me all the time, talked to me as if I was an adult, and absolutely never answered a question with "I'll tell you when you're older" I knew why the sky was blue before I was 8 years old, could tell you all about rain, and condensation, and even the nature of temperature. Finally when I was 13 years old I just sort of decided it was time for school. My reading level went from 4th to 12th+ grade-level in a matter of weeks. I told my parents what I was interested in and they bought me the books. I read them, and the got some more. When I finally went to college at 16, no one to my knowledge ever guessed that I wasn't 18. I had to take one remedial math class (because I had refused to learn that for some reason), but aside from that I started at University-credit level. The only deficiencies such an unusual education has produced are my atrocious hand-writing and spelling skills. I consider that a small price to pay.

I've never asked somebody what they learned in elementary/junior high school and gotten an answer that was worthy of the name. People learn NOTHING of use in those grade levels.

Not everyone is Lucky enough to have well educated parents who make enough money to teach them at home, but if it weren't for that fact, I'd have no qualms in saying that public school is worthless. That I suppose is the point I was trying to get across with this mad rant.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Gwil on Tue Oct 19th at 1:42am 2004


Woah. I read all that, impressive, and interesting reading I must say - although, it does point huge fingers in the direction that play is always the most important part of learning - especially in the early years. It seems to have benefitted you enormously, Tracer. Just why can't our collective government policy makers see it and return education to it's basic roots?

Discovery, play and socialising are key to developing the brain, and thus for learning
[addsig]




Quote
Re: U.S. Election
Posted by Orpheus on Tue Oct 19th at 2:33am 2004


you know, i fully expected at the very least an "opps" gwil, especially when i explained my choice of wording in the PM's.. sadly, you disappointed me.

anywho's.. even though a portion of the government is involved with the situation, the root cause, at least in my region of the world is the parents.. hence my words

? quote:
doesn't compare to being a parent and doing the exact same thing.
i posted that sentence to illustrate my scorn on the parents of today.. not to raise them as you so blatantly accused me of .. read the entire paragraph in this new light and it makes sense, or should if one is capable of admitting it.

anyways, the parents of my state have caused so many issues that the teachers have little choices, they are being sued so often that they are forced to have insurance to cover this eventuality or they cannot seek employment.. parents refuse to allow the teachers to enforce guide lines necessary to the groups they teach as a whole.. parents are always citing that teachers stifle their development by restricting their right to express themselves.. i attended numerous parent teacher meetings where parents belittled the teachers constantly.. i don't know how you guys have these meetings, but the kids are present, if the parents chose to bring them.. the outlook for the teachers are grim when the children see the parents doing these hateful things to the teachers.

in a small way, i blame the teachers as well, because in their defense, they have adopted a policy of placing kids on drugs to ensure compliance.. this is creating more problems than solving, cause now we have children addicted to very strong drugs, and if you have ever seen a child who hasn't had their dose for the day.. its scary.

my experiences only extend from grade school through jr. high so i have to limit it to only those areas.. how the upper grades get treated are not my domain of opinions..

so, all your anger at me was based upon a misunderstanding, in spite of me repeatedly telling you that you would be surprised.. but.. i wanted cash's input before i said anything, because i felt it may have either supported my claim, or because he lives elsewhere, he might have said he had heard such rumors..

as far as the government in this area, i had to butt heads with them somewhat, but perhaps not for the reasons one would think of at first, but upon reflection, may after..
in this state, each school is given a specific amount per child to teach them within the system.. each child that is home schooled reduces that amount.. especially when one considers that we home school with NO GOVERNMENT AID!.. i was forced, due to my only being a high school grad to seek additional schooling for my son.. this monies came out of my pocket, not the government.. but in the end it was worth it.. my son was branded incapable of schooling within the system.. i had him graduated by age 16 and coming from a deficit of being 3 grades behind his age level..

anyways, as i said, you wronged me again.. maybe you felt you based it on past replies, i dunno nor care, since it doesn't move this topic forward.. but being a parent (or older) doesn't always mean s**t to me.. i was forced to do things because other parents made the situation that way..

[addsig]





Post Reply