[addsig]
Posted by pepper on Sun Nov 21st at 12:21pm 2004
[addsig]
Posted by glenc on Sun Nov 21st at 4:28pm 2004
-Orpheus, Master Critiquer
Hmmm... No - not elitist at all. Okay this is my last post in this thread I promise.
[addsig]Posted by Forceflow on Sun Nov 21st at 4:33pm 2004
I don't want to spend a lot of time on a mod I don't even get the basic info from. It puts me in the risk of devoting to a project I don't really like, you see ...
And that would be bad for me, and for the mod team counting on me.
[addsig]
Forceflow
member
2420 posts
342 snarkmarks
Registered: Nov 6th 2003
Location: Belgium

Occupation: Engineering Student (CS)
Posted by Yak_Fighter on Sun Nov 21st at 6:05pm 2004
I really don't see how anything here was trolling, but you're the boss. I also don't see why this mod shouldn't be looked down upon, given the fact that there is no information about it on the website, all they have to show for it are a couple of model renders, and once again we have some overused theme that will inevitably lead to tactical combat in an urban environment with counterstrike weapons, with a focus on realism. I mean Orph's post was making fun of their tired and overused theme, and the first thing they do instead of trying to explain or differentiate themselves from all the other mods they start calling people assholes and such. Why exactly would we want a forum that fawns over whatever bulls**t mod comes around the bend?
Yak_Fighter
member
1832 posts
406 snarkmarks
Registered: Dec 30th 2001
Location: Indianapolis, IN

Occupation: College Student/Slacker
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Nov 21st at 6:41pm 2004
1)can someone explain the term "trolling" for me?
2)and how my replies fall into the hypocrisy end of the discussion?
i realize thats a 2 part question, but i really wanna know cause i thought i was very generous considering how the thread degraded so rapidly.
its obvious these guy's don't know what true elitism is, and they also doesn't seem to know that we do high level map critiques, hence the title "Master"
it has been my experience that elitist are anything but masters, more monsters than anything else.
still i want a definition to my two questions, before i misunderstand and decide that i was just accused of something. :/
lep, you wrote it, you define it.
[addsig]Orpheus
member
13860 posts
1547 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 26th 2001
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA

Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Posted by $loth on Sun Nov 21st at 6:46pm 2004
$loth
member
2256 posts
286 snarkmarks
Registered: Feb 27th 2004
Location: South England

Occupation: Student
Posted by Yak_Fighter on Sun Nov 21st at 6:53pm 2004
2)and how my replies fall into the hypocrisy end of the discussion?
i realize thats a 2 part question, but i really wanna know cause i thought i was very generous considering how the thread degraded so rapidly.
its obvious these guy's don't know what true elitism is, and they also doesn't seem to know that we do high level map critiques, hence the title "Master"
it has been my experience that elitist are anything but masters, more monsters than anything else.
still i want a definition to my two questions, before i misunderstand and decide that i was just accused of something. :/
lep, you wrote it, you define it.
Trolling is posting with the intent to piss off people and starting an argument. Deliberately taking an unpopular opposing opinion just to start s**t is trolling. Insulting people can also be considered trolling.
As for the hypocrasy, I think Lep was making a poke at you taking things perhaps too seriously at times ![]()
Yak_Fighter
member
1832 posts
406 snarkmarks
Registered: Dec 30th 2001
Location: Indianapolis, IN

Occupation: College Student/Slacker
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Nov 21st at 7:02pm 2004
Trolling is posting with the intent to piss off people and starting an argument. Deliberately taking an unpopular opposing opinion just to start s**t is trolling. Insulting people can also be considered trolling.
As for the hypocrasy, I think Lep was making a poke at you taking things perhaps too seriously at times ![]()
well I'll be damned, trolling doesn't sound nothing like the word would seem..
and i am sorry that sometimes i slip into admin mode, but dammit, it was my name being dragged through the mud.
if, by some stretch of the definition my joke was trolling, i appologise... but honestly, making me feel bad enough to have to say i am sorry is a bit OTT.
lep, you need to make up your mind, either its mature, or childish, i cannot do both. ![]()
Orpheus
member
13860 posts
1547 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 26th 2001
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA

Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Posted by Gwil on Sun Nov 21st at 7:11pm 2004
Too true.
[addsig]
Gwil
super admin
2864 posts
293 snarkmarks
Registered: Oct 13th 2001
Location: Derbyshire, UK

Occupation: Student
Posted by Campaignjunkie on Sun Nov 21st at 9:15pm 2004

Oh well. I guess we'll just have to discourage every mod that tries to recruit here. That'll show 'em.
[addsig]
Campaignjunkie
member
1309 posts
291 snarkmarks
Registered: Feb 12th 2002
Location: West Coast, USA
Occupation: Student
Posted by $loth on Sun Nov 21st at 9:21pm 2004
$loth
member
2256 posts
286 snarkmarks
Registered: Feb 27th 2004
Location: South England

Occupation: Student
Posted by fishy on Mon Nov 22nd at 12:40am 2004
[addsig]Posted by Leperous on Mon Nov 22nd at 12:42am 2004
*sighs* I don't have a problem with people asking for more information or whatever; I agree this mod does seem to have the typical noob-style "we'll give you more information later but right now it's SECRET!!!1" description (in particular CJ I wasn't attacking you in any way). However, I DO get annoyed when certain members take the "oh look at my experience" attitude or somehow imply that an attack on them is somehow against unwritten forum rules... Perhaps trollism isn't the right term, but I am getting worried at the elitism that is slowly forming here 
Leperous
member
3382 posts
788 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 21st 2001
Location: UK
Occupation: Lazy student
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Nov 22nd at 1:13am 2004
all i can say is, in times past this thread would have been locked already due to poorly thought out replies, and innuendo's. this thread went better than could have been expected, had timely intervention not occurred when it had.
most, if not all the replies were positive, yes they had some negative content, but dammit, even when discussing tumors one cannot be all rosy about the diagnosis. its expecting a bit to much to handle every new member with kids gloves, especially when they take the first poke at someone.
its also expected that a certain amount of defensiveness will occur, after all we have known each other for years. i fully expect that each of us can cope, and defend ourselves if need be, but most times it speaks 10 times clearer if others do it instead.
lep, i know you mean well, i know that you must take a stand, and yes it speaks mounds that you are defending the new member, but sometimes its best to let them swim or sink.
i will add, that if my term "Master Critiquer" is considered by majority to be an elitist title, i will lose it in a second.
most of you know, i tack on the title master off handedly to many people, because i truly feel they deserve a tiny bit of recognition.. fishy-master modeler, lep-master webmaster, gollum-master mod programmer, KFS- lucky son-of-a-bitch-level-designer-master ![]()
as i said, i apologize if my joke started all this, but i shouldn't HAVE TO 
honestly, i think these two dug a hole, its up to them to decide if its to big a hole to fill, or move on.
another thing you need to consider lep, you are never going to dissuade us from uniting against a perceived threat.. as you said earlier today, learn from your mistakes.
/ 2 cents.
[addsig]Orpheus
member
13860 posts
1547 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 26th 2001
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA

Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Posted by Dr Brasso on Mon Nov 22nd at 1:44am 2004
okay, just to add insult to injury. my 2 cents... 
i too have detected a bit of arrogance among quite a few folks around these parts in the past few months....(just because i didnt post every day as i used to, doesnt mean i didnt do a spot of reading from time to time....
) i remember the days not so long ago when i was asking all the noobish questions and was pestering and certainly annoying and.......noobish. but i had a leg up on most of the rest of these guys, because of my background...the humility was the reason i kept coming back, because i felt "comfortable" asking "the noobish questions"....
so its another mod with the same ole criteria and the same ole setting.....big deal....handle it like we used to and we may run across our next NS, or kfs, or reno or finger or orph or mikee or, or god knows wht other super talented mapping God .....to those i didnt list, my apologies...you know who you are...
leps right when he says the "tone" is changing.....whether it's "elitist" BS is a mute debate, imho
orph's been orph since orph BECAME orph.....and imho, hes one of the most consistent, and honest, and sincere folks around here, with a dry sense of humor to boot.....i like him...
......and ya get "his neck up:, ya know what to expect......yes?
so, now that ive run my tab up to a quarter, i leave us to ALL ponder our behaviors, like any DAD would....
comments?....
btw, glenc, it helps to help us help you.....comb yer neck hairs down, and lets try this again, shall we? diplomacy also works marvels around here mate.... ![]()
Dr Brasso...
Dr Brasso
member
1878 posts
198 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 30th 2003
Location: Omaha,NE

Occupation: cad drafter
Posted by Agent Smith on Mon Nov 22nd at 1:45am 2004
In that case I better reply before its locked. Hello!
Agent Smith
member
803 posts
200 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 30th 2003
Location: NSW, Australia

Occupation: Uni Student
Posted by 7dk2h4md720ih on Mon Nov 22nd at 1:50am 2004
...
Dr Brasso...
Actually Doc, you were one of the most pleasant newbies I've come across here.
Posted by fraggard on Mon Nov 22nd at 1:56am 2004
fraggard
member
1110 posts
201 snarkmarks
Registered: Jul 8th 2002
Location: Bangalore, India

Occupation: Student
Posted by Dr Brasso on Mon Nov 22nd at 1:57am 2004
thats kind of you to say dave, and i appreciate it immensly....
but do you see my point?....maybe the absence for minor periods gave a bit of a "tonal tuning fork" that i hadnt had due to attendance.....im thinking we should all have a look at ourselves..../end rant....
btw, missed ya man...![]()
Doc B...
and where the hell IS mikee these days...??
Frags....what are you on about....??
[addsig]Dr Brasso
member
1878 posts
198 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 30th 2003
Location: Omaha,NE

Occupation: cad drafter
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Nov 22nd at 2:10am 2004
I would have to second that thought......
also, i think perhaps, well maybe we should just allow this thread to die before someone begins burning flags in effigy, or worse, someone accuses someone of doing so.
i have detected a certain amount of hostility, i have voiced my concern of it as well, but i must say i detected little or none in this thread. all i really detect is a s**t load of false guilt, none of us should be shamed into saying sorry, or even inquiring that they may have crossed some line.
HL2 is out, the boredom should dissipate IF ITS ALLOWED TO!!!
no one was wrong enough to be made to feel guilty, even the new guys.
and doc, *wipes sudden increase of eye moisture* thanx.. it means more than you know.
[addsig]Orpheus
member
13860 posts
1547 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 26th 2001
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA

Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Snarkpit v6.1.0 created this page in 0.0411 seconds.

