for some, they won't buy an album sight unseen, so they download a couple songs to get a feel for the group and then buy them if its their cup O tea..
so yeah, i guess you were right.
[addsig]for some, they won't buy an album sight unseen, so they download a couple songs to get a feel for the group and then buy them if its their cup O tea..
so yeah, i guess you were right.
[addsig]
I have downloaded probably about 80 songs in my entire life. I never downloaded entire albums but simply 1 or 2 songs from a band. Some bands just plane suck and may only have one good song that I like but I'm not going to go out and buy an entire album for 1 song. That would be a waste of my time and money. Other songs that I downloaded were hard to find ones. I think it's alright to download a few songs but when your downloading entire albums and games that's just plane stealing. Some people never bother to realise that there are people out there who worked hard to make a product only for it to be ripped off by some punk sitting at his computer sipping on his Hi-C his mother got for him outa the fridge from 5 feet away because he is too lazy and his mother has no spine.
Wow what detail I can go into things.
sounds to me like you are selective.. 1 or 2 is fine, more is stealing..
so if i take portions of your car, and not the entire thing its OK by you?
i don't sanction theft, but to borrow is another animal entirely.
point in fact, if i had a PC gamer magazine on my coffee table and you read it, would you be stealing it? if i let you take it home would it be theft? if i copied it, how does that differ from lending you the magazine for the time it takes you to partake in its content?
if you borrow my car, will GM holler foul? borrow and steal are not interchangeable, nor should they be.
basically it boils down to viewpoint i suppose, but as long as i am, in my mind, guilt free i am fine. its sorta like this, think what you will cause you will never convince those whom don't want to be.
[addsig]

A car is different from a song but at the same time I see your point Orph. If a band wants to put out a bunch of garbage that's fine by me but once they finally come out with one good song should I be forced to by the entire album? Now of course you could say that I don't have to buy the album and that I'm not being forced but when the resource is being made available for me to get the one song I want why shouldn't I have the choice to take the one song and leave the rest to rot in a void of 1s and 0s. I don't expect you to understand anything I say even half of what I just wrote is a little confusing to myself but I think I made my point... or not.
They have been making cassette tape singles, and cd singles for years now, so the "entire album" thing is moot. either you see downloading of MP3's as wrong, or you do not.
i have never understood the difference between tuning a song in on the radio, or tuning it in online, but oh well :/

i have never understood the difference between tuning a song in on the radio, or tuning it in online, but oh well :/
Just like taping a film from TV?
[addsig]
I hate game piracy just as much as you do Reno. Would you consider burning a CD from a friend an act of moral crime? I don't remember if it is legal as long as you don't sell the the burned copy. The only game I have done this with was StarCraft. Even now I consider buying the game retail after owning a burned version of it.

I think it would now be a nice time to quote someone's signature from the Sven-Coop boards :]
"Thank You for Using Steaming pile of s**t."
[addsig]
this is the true crux of the matter for me. i personally have no issues one way or the other, if someone feels its wrong, hell thats not bad of them, and if they feel its not wrong, no harm there either, but to distinguish wrong as just so much piracy really burns my butt. either its wrong, or its not, it shouldn't be just a bit worse than you are committing ATM
i cannot, nor am i able to convince you that money lost and money never gained are two totally different things so i will desist trying.. but look at it this way and maybe you will understand human concepts of money gained and lost.
you wear a coat, its your coat but you have not put it on for almost a year. in the pocket is a 20 dollar bill.. you are elated for finding a 20, but the point is, it was yours all along only you never missed it nor knew it was missing.
the games never bought are not lost, its money they never had so unlike the 20 dollar bill, it never was theirs to claim. but people look at money so oddly, you are elated for finding the not missing 20, but WHY???
anywho's i hate people who say its wrong, yet do it on a less impressive scale so its OK.. "I only download a few songs" thats what i hate. LIARS are far worse than SOFTWARE PIR8's. 
[edit] and burning copies to play on a lan just as Duncan just described is JUST AS WRONG no more, and certainly no less.. all he described was cutting out the internet process of the steps involved.
wrong is wrong, there are not subtle degrees of wrong when it comes to obtaining a video game to play.
[addsig]
the games never bought are not lost, its money they never had so unlike the 20 dollar bill, it never was theirs to claim. but people look at money so oddly, you are elated for finding the not missing 20, but WHY???
Duncan, i was not taking anything out on you, i was only using you as an example of how people justify things, or better rationalizing a wrong away in favor of doing it with a clear conscience.
if i over stepped myself i apologize. i didn't mean to be a hypocrite, after all you know my collection status i assume ![]()
my point was only to say, people tend to set the "WRONG" of any situation at just worse than they are committing. i say what you are doing (you as in anyone who copies any game for any reason) is exactly the same as what i am doing, no worse, no better.
as i said many times, i buy all the games i want.. i am poor but i buy everything worth having. i can scan the disk covers to prove just how often if anyone is in doubt. on average i buy 5 to 10 games annually, considering i play only 1 or 2 half way through that sounds obscene, but i am not the only gamer in this house.
anywho's, i hope you accept my apology as it looked as if i may have crossed your line of tolerance.
/me bows out.
[addsig]
For myself I don't download games, as I only play games worth buying, and as such I buy them. The problem is the high price of games. Granted, a lot of money and time is spent making a game, but like you pointed out Reno, the target audience of game developers are individuals like us. I don't know about all of you, but I might only buy 2-3 games a year, in a good year, because I cannot really afford to purchase anymore than that. $100+ (here in Aus) is a lot to pay for a game. I'd happily spend that on something really good, like HL2 or Call of Duty, but thats a lot to pay for something you might think is okay. Which I think is what a lot of people think, hence pirating occurs. If the general price of new games drop to around $60-80 Aus, or your equivalent, you'd see a lot less pirating because more people are willing to spend that much. Sure the companies would loose some money due to the price decrease, but they'd make it back with an increased number of sales. At least thats what I think.
Often myself and a couple of mates my buy a new game each, then lend them to each other so we each have copies of the new games, but the cost is split. We're still paying for the games, just not as much as the often rip off price.


