This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Post Reply
Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by DrGlass on Thu May 12th at 1:54am 2005


? quote:

? quote:
People always say the same thing to me on forums when i'm moaning about Valve. "Yeah but how many updates do they do? Practically 1 every 2 weeks, no other games company does that."

Blizzard makes and update every week on World Of Warcraft, so it is possible to provide more customer support.


They also have get about $14,000,000+ a month in gross income from players.



Valve does what it does for almost nothing after the $50 retail price. Half life isn't the only game, CS is its own game, as is DoD. Not to mention Steam and HL2. I'm not trying to be a fan boy for them, I get just as pissed when I get goinked in CS or when steam friends doesn't work. But attacking Valve isn't going to fix any of that.

I recall a video a few months ago that showed AI bugs in HL2 and hit box errors. In the end they tryed to burn Valve with it. It is so easy for us to bitch about things like this when we have no idea what kind of work it takes to keep over a million people all around the world running on millions of diffrent computer set ups, playing the same game.

I payed $50 six years ago for CS, and I still play it almost every day. Valve makes good products and they will fix this problem, so what if they cant just snap their fingers and solve it? Maybe if we all payed 15 bucks a month they would put a few more people on the job, or maybe we can deal with it and enjoy the soon to be three+ games we got from valve for the price of one.


[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Cassius on Thu May 12th at 2:59am 2005


Come on. If this actually screwed up the gameplay, we would already have known.



Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by SaintGreg on Thu May 12th at 4:09am 2005


? quote:
They set the interp to 0.3


the tfc interp bug was a different thing I believe. No matter how long my client interpolates for it should draw the viemodel where I need to shoot, because the engine should lag compensate for the increased lag from interpolating longer. But it doesn't do this at all, I think it only lag compensates from ping.

Plus if I set cl_interp 0, there should be no difference between that and with cl_interpolate 0, since the time for the interpolation is 0, so it should just put the same thing on the screen. But even with interp 0, the viewmodel lags behind the hitboxes. Maybe this is because it will still interpolate for the time of the last frame, but at 70 fps the distance between truth and interpolated should be alot smaller than it is. With cl_interpolation 0, the viemodel is in the exact right spot, but then your view is very jerky so thats not really a solution.

? quote:
Valve makes good products and they will fix this problem

They haven't fixed steam yet, and its been over a year. Either they aren't working on that or are making no headway. (im thinking of the 2 things I experience worst in steam - friends doesn't work nearly ever, and it never selects the right content server) If they haven't been working on that, or are making no progress, what makes you think they will fix this, seemingly much much more difficult bug.
[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by DrGlass on Thu May 12th at 4:32am 2005


Well in the past, when there has been a problem they have fixed it.

Cheating was one of the biggest things, if you want to know about things that f**K up game play... try CS 1.2 before anti-cheat.

I cant imagin that they have these known bugs just sitting around not getting any work done on them, sure they could fix this stuff faster but then everyone would be "wtf? when will DoD source come out!"

so, maybe I dont know that they will fix the problem, but it makes more sence to me that they will fix it in due time rather than just forget about it and let the bug reports pile up.
[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Thu May 12th at 5:18am 2005


I have noticed this problem too. My guess is that because of the physics etc. they have allot for trouble making the hitbox move smoothly through the world without using up a prohibitive amount of bandwidth. Thus, rather than have jerky character motions in online play, the quick fix was to partially decouple the model from the hitbox to make it look as though the gameplay is smooth. Kind of clever really, but not a great solution in the long term.

Note that this is an entirely unsupported hypothesis. I'm probably wrong.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Cassius on Thu May 12th at 5:59am 2005


World of Warcraft is truly formidable. From the first, Blizzard sought to produce a game that avoided outright the downfalls of others in its genre, fit in and expanded upon the world they'd hewn over the course of five games and some four novels, and could measure up aesthetically to the newest releases using an engine far less powerful.

I'd say they succeeded.

The game boasts no bump maps, shaders, or real-time shadows - but it looks great. Every texture you see was drawn by hand - which, believe me, is no mean feat, especially considering how well they turned out. The zones, nigh thirty in number, are expansive and diverse, and feature major landmarks from all five games (granted, some more accurately than others. I'm looking in your direction, Dalaran) - not to mention the transitions between them are visually seamless. Immersive quests are offered to players of all levels, and rarely does gaining experience become a chore to be ground through. The player classes are fairly balanced; each is fairly original, insofar as MMORPG classes can be, and offers a distinct experience from the others. There are some forty servers, I believe, with new ones being introduced periodically; Blizzard performs maintenence on them weekly, and they generally remain stable, despite it that their subsciptions number over a million.

And then, on occasion, servers crash, quests and enemies behave strangely, etc. - and guess what people say?

"Blizzard sucks." "Blizzard pays no attention to their fans." "Blizzard never fixes anything." "Blizzard doesn't put in enough work." "Blizzard is getting enough money that they should be able to produce a completely flawless and infinitely stable game." "Blizzard is a s**tty company."

And I respond: shut the f**k up. Just shut the f**k up. Seriously, a good game comes along which is entertaining, which is far more stable than others in its genre, into which its maker has poured an undeniable amount of sweat and blood, and which you regularly enjoy - and the very moment it f**ks up even slightly, perhaps clearing away a few hours of effort tops, you've got to let the whole world know that its creators are a gang of incompetant hacks.

And I say the same to those of you who complain about Valve: shut the f**k up. Here's a game with an engine that's solid and rife with potential (good God, just look what we did to HL1), extremely accessible developer's tools, and an impressively organized (though often buggy) online distribution and patch system, whose developers, too, constantly work to create new content - see DoD Source and the soon-to-be-released additional HL2 level - even though they aren't paid a dime past what they received when you purchased their product and, I assume, have enjoyed far less commerical success than Blizzard.

Are Steam and Valve's lineup perfect products? - by no means. Are they, in fact, flawed? - in some respects, very much so. Should you go off and run your f**king mouth about every inconvenience you happen upon? - no. In my humble opinion, it's a pretty damn good game, and Valve is doing a better job of keeping it up to date than most games' developers do.

Oh, and about this hitbox s**t - I've never had a problem fragging. I believe someone on the Plan of Attack forums explained this as being latency compensation, though whatever the case may be, I will guarantee you that you'll all be ready to pounce on Valve as though it'd been trying to f**k up your game all along.

Now please, tell me about how I'm a bulls**tter blindly fawning over my favorite game development company.





Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Crono on Thu May 12th at 6:53am 2005


? quote:

World of Warcraft is truly formidable. From the first, Blizzard sought to produce a game that avoided outright the downfalls of others in its genre, fit in and expanded upon the world they'd hewn over the course of five games and some four novels, and could measure up aesthetically to the newest releases using an engine far less powerful.
I'd say they succeeded.
The game boasts no bump maps, shaders, or real-time shadows - but it looks great. Every texture you see was drawn by hand - which, believe me, is no mean feat, especially considering how well they turned out. The zones, nigh thirty in number, are expansive and diverse, and feature major landmarks from all five games (granted, some more accurately than others. I'm looking in your direction, Dalaran) - not to mention the transitions between them are visually seamless. Immersive quests are offered to players of all levels, and rarely does gaining experience become a chore to be ground through. The player classes are fairly balanced; each is fairly original, insofar as MMORPG classes can be, and offers a distinct experience from the others. There are some forty servers, I believe, with new ones being introduced periodically; Blizzard performs maintenence on them weekly, and they generally remain stable, despite it that their subsciptions number over a million.
And then, on occasion, servers crash, quests and enemies behave strangely, etc. - and guess what people say?
"Blizzard sucks." "Blizzard pays no attention to their fans." "Blizzard never fixes anything." "Blizzard doesn't put in enough work." "Blizzard is getting enough money that they should be able to produce a completely flawless and infinitely stable game." "Blizzard is a s**tty company."
And I respond: shut the f**k up. Just shut the f**k up. Seriously, a good game comes along which is entertaining, which is far more stable than others in its genre, into which its maker has poured an undeniable amount of sweat and blood, and which you regularly enjoy - and the very moment it f**ks up even slightly, perhaps clearing away a few hours of effort tops, you've got to let the whole world know that its creators are a gang of incompetant hacks.
And I say the same to those of you who complain about Valve: shut the f**k up. Here's a game with an engine that's solid and rife with potential (good God, just look what we did to HL1), extremely accessible developer's tools, and an impressively organized (though often buggy) online distribution and patch system, whose developers, too, constantly work to create new content - see DoD Source and the soon-to-be-released additional HL2 level - even though they aren't paid a dime past what they received when you purchased their product and, I assume, have enjoyed far less commerical success than Blizzard.
Are Steam and Valve's lineup perfect products? - by no means. Are they, in fact, flawed? - in some respects, very much so. Should you go off and run your f**king mouth about every inconvenience you happen upon? - no. In my humble opinion, it's a pretty damn good game, and Valve is doing a better job of keeping it up to date than most games' developers do.
Oh, and about this hitbox s**t - I've never had a problem fragging. I believe someone on the Plan of Attack forums explained this as being latency compensation, though whatever the case may be, I will guarantee you that you'll all be ready to pounce on Valve as though it'd been trying to f**k up your game all along.
Now please, tell me about how I'm a bulls**tter blindly fawning over my favorite game development company.


Well said.
However, I wish more people held this type of logical sense towards more things. [addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by DrGlass on Thu May 12th at 7:46am 2005


indeed. Alot of people think that everything that they dont like is some how the creators fault. I remeber when they took out the bunny hop or lowered the power of the AWP in CS. People take things like that personaly.

I feel sorry for developers like Valve, they cant win. People want all kinds of things and for the most part you always will have to let one group down.

anyways that is getting off topic.
[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Orpheus on Thu May 12th at 7:57am 2005


"Ahem"

I, personally am the last person to "blame" games. I notice, I study, I continue to study, THEN I bitch.

I have noticed this bug from day numero uno. I also fail to see any correlation between this games defects, and another games lack of them. I am sorry Cass, but your whole pretense of defense sounds exactly like one of Crono's "The worlds gonna end if I cannot explain every last nuance" type of bulls**t tangents. (notice: this is the blue of sarcasm, not humor)

There is a tiny bit of truth however. People bitch. People always wanna blame their problems on someone. In this case its Valve.

Personally, this whole "Steam Sucks" thing?? I don't get it. I have had ZERO problems with steam. Its no more buggy than the old "GameSpy" program used to be as far as server locating is concerned. As far as Steam updating my game? I have DSL, I can see where 56k users may have a complaint but NO ONE ELSE!!!

My HL game runs smoothly. If yours does not its more than likely YOUR FAULT guys. STOP BLAMING VALVE!!! Fix your piece of s**t PC and get over this blaming stuff.

Now, for my part, I would really like to see this BUG fixed. I have turned it on during a LAN game with my son, and the theory that its to compensate for latency is bulls**t. THERE IS NONE of note during a LAN game and its still there.

Any Who's, I just had to clear that up. I think you were way off base Cass, and Crono worse for backing you up.

Yup, I fully expect at least one of you to bitch at me for saying that, but.. I expect it no more than you must have while each of you were typing so.. *shrugs*

[EDIT] f**king figures. I waste my 8000th post on a bitch session. Mile marks of the 8000 variety should not be wasted on ranting.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Crono on Thu May 12th at 8:24am 2005


Right, we want people to become more ignorant. smiley [addsig]



Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by ben_j_davis on Thu May 12th at 8:36am 2005


Don't get me wrong, i am not criticising Valve. I work for a games company, i know about all the BS that goes on. Endless amounts of legal BS.

For a user the solution is simple, but for most games companies its months of discussion.





Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Orpheus on Thu May 12th at 8:46am 2005


? quoting Crono
Right, we want people to become more ignorant.

Don't get me wrong. I feel you had a point but also feel you could have found a better way to express it.

*sighs*

I dunno exactly what I mean except that using another game to defend this one just sounded wrong. I said almost the same thing but concentrated my explanation on the people bitching instead of valve. I honestly feel that if these people have a complaint about steam, its their own creation. Think on it a bit. How many people make maps and have unexplained problems, and after weeks/days of problem solving, it boils down to their machine either having a bug, or the person was just so dumb that issues like that are inevitable?

I think that anyone who has genuine issues with steam should examine their machines first then look elsewhere.

Course, I could be at least as wrong as you two from another's perspective.

Bottom line. My respect for both of you is genuine. I think I deserve the right to disagree with each of you on occasion, especially when neither of you hesitate to return the favor.... 10 fold. smiley

[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Crono on Thu May 12th at 9:04am 2005


I have no problem with someone disagreeing with me or anyone else. Just if that disagreement is conducted improperly.

You basically said both of us are wrong ... for our opinions and that this level of "wrong" was in fact "bad", hence: 'worse'.

Cass's post was simply a comparison between the two games to bring a better understanding, taking that they follow the same trend of bashing and online maintenance.

Omega brought up WoW and how it releases patches every week. [addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Orpheus on Thu May 12th at 9:19am 2005


? quoting Crono
I have no problem with someone disagreeing with me or anyone else. Just if that disagreement is conducted improperly.

You basically said both of us are wrong ... for our opinions and that this level of "wrong" was in fact "bad", hence: 'worse'.

Cass's post was simply a comparison between the two games to bring a better understanding, taking that they follow the same trend of bashing and online maintenance.

You have a very unique way of defining words and phrases i grant you that. i would prefer the term. "improper" or "ill conceived" not wrong,bad or worse. sometimes you fail to see that you are taking the scenic route to express your desires, when the direct path would suffice.

in any event, you seem to be no more, or less correct than i so i bow out. Just chalk it up as your superior intellect and my own lack of same.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Cassius on Thu May 12th at 11:12pm 2005


The World of Warcraft example wasn't about the number or severity of errors in a game, but the attitude towards them in the game's fanbase - which is more than analogous, if not identical, to that of HL2.

I still don't see where I'm wrong. Occasionally troublesome faults in a fairly above average game, whether they go fixed or unfixed, are not cause enough to cast judgment on the developers as if they'd done everything wrong.

Does a bad scene in a movie make the whole piece garbage? No. Does it make the director a hack? No. Granted, Valve's content isn't quite so cutting edge as it was to the gaming world in 1996, they invariably miss deadlines, and they take a long time to fix bugs, but I'd say their products boast qualities that more than redeem their screwups.





Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Orpheus on Thu May 12th at 11:30pm 2005


I would not like to be the one to keep tally on how many times someone said I was wrong Cass. In this case, I could very well be talking out my ass again, so unless its really important to you to prove me incorrect I do not think its worth our butting heads on it.

I know you had a good point, I just felt you could have expressed it without using another game is all. I am on your side on the point of people crying needlessly and blaming Valve. I could be the exception, but I personally have no real issues worthy of mentioning. Yeah, I think it stinks that I cannot HIT what I aim at some of the time, but its not a major issue.

anyways, I was sleepy and crabby. Ignore me.

[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by G4MER on Fri May 13th at 11:07am 2005


? quoting Crono
Right, we want people to become more ignorant.

You mean like you are being right here?

[addsig]




Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Dark Tree on Fri May 13th at 11:17am 2005


Blah blah blah blah blah......Anyone care for some food and porn?

[addsig]



Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by G4MER on Fri May 13th at 12:20pm 2005


? quoting Dark Tree
Blah blah blah blah blah......Anyone care for some food and porn?

PORN AND CHICKEN PLEASE!

( Oh and cass, I quit WOW, not because it sucked, or blizzard sucks or anything of that nature.. The game just didnt entertain me after 3 weeks. Did I go on the forums and bitch, nope.. am I bitching nope. Besides I made level 60 in 3 weeks how hard can the game be? )

[addsig]



Quote
Re: This video is shocking!! - Sorry if you have seen this already
Posted by Cassius on Fri May 13th at 9:57pm 2005


Good for you.




Post Reply