new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Post Reply
Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by fishy on Wed Jun 15th at 1:35am 2005


a piece of last weeks news that seems to have slipped by without much attention.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/4610755.stm

either that or i slept through most of the week, which is a possibility.

i really don't like all this big brother s**t that's happening. national id cards etc. before you know it, you'll be getting your own personal tracker implanted in the back of your neck, whether you want it or not.




i eat paint



Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Wed Jun 15th at 1:58am 2005


That has to be one of the dumbest ideas I've ever heard. All you'd have to do is raise gas taxes to achieve the listed goal and you wouldn't have to spend a fortune of infrastructure.


Some people are like slinkys...

They aren?t really good for anything, but you can't help but laugh when one tumbles down the stairs.



Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by G4MER on Wed Jun 15th at 3:12am 2005


yeah I read that in a gamer mag I have.. how they use GPS to track you. And you thought ON-STAR was a good idea..




Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by French Toast on Wed Jun 15th at 3:15am 2005


hmph.



Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Spartan on Wed Jun 15th at 5:02am 2005


All this big brother stuff is scary but it's slowly being integrated into society whether we like it or not. Our future is going to look like something from Dues Ex.




Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by gimpinthesink on Wed Jun 15th at 9:27am 2005


Another one of the governments "bright" ideas to get us to use public transport. It works brilliantly where there aint none or it comes when ever the driver feels like it.

I like what Lenny Henry said on Friday. He'd been driving backwards every where so now the government owes him money.



<B><A HREF="http://www.ben-hodgson.co.uk" TARGET="_blank">Tinterweb site</A></B>
<B><A HREF="http://gimpinthesink.deviantart.com" TARGET="_blank">Deviantart</A></B>

<FONT COLOR=gold>Human knowledge belongs to the world</FONT>



Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Leperous on Wed Jun 15th at 10:26am 2005


If you think about it, it's really the fairest idea to charge people by the mile. However, the government, as ever, has shown tremendous stupidity in the details: they should have variable costs for the type of car you use (so that freight and economic cars are cheaper) and keep main commuter and rural routes cheap. Right now the proposals are to flat charge but vary some routes, with stupidly high amounts for certain motorways (up to ?1.40/$1 mile?!) which really just penalises people who have to drive further, such as those in the country or where there is inadequate public transport.





Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Orpheus on Wed Jun 15th at 11:47am 2005


The sad thing is, there are just to many people to stupid to be allowed to make their own choices.

I know thats an unpopular view but its oh so true. I see people doing the stupidest things every day just driving, I can only imagine what else they are doing.

Someday, I will make a list of things that stupid people do.. ( a list is pretty stupid in itself so I will add it as well)

Bottomline, todays society breeds people so into themselves that its as if no one else even enters their little worlds.. Those are the people who need someone to "big brother" them.. Look around you, but start at the top. Its usually the people with the money. THOSE are the really stupid ones.





The best things in life, aren't things.



Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Dred_furst on Wed Jun 15th at 12:25pm 2005


as lep said, we should encourage more environmentally safe cars, like something on the MOT to grade the rating, then a dynamic system of changing prices day by day using things like the traffic counting methods already in use, say if theres a rise in daily traffic through a certain route, it charges more and things, or GPS even, seems even more fair than the silly government system they are proposing at the moment, hell! do what france does, charge on the motorways, and then you can tell if people are speeding too!
meh, my little rant is over now <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/icon_biggrin.gif">



I need a new sig



Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Orpheus on Wed Jun 15th at 1:03pm 2005


I drive a lot.. I see countryside that has had crops in them before yet are going fallow now.

I see no reason what so ever why these fields cannot contain a fuel crop of one type or another. I talk to people all the time who are also confused on these points. One side claims that if we produce more crops, the price will drop, the other claims that if the crop is used for fuel, and not food, then the price will remain constant or even rise.

I think we need to educate people on this topic, then push the fuel crop idea till it takes hold.

millions of acres go unplanted each year.. Its bad enough that we have hunger present in the name of higher prices, why do we have to add fuel shortages as well <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/sad.gif">





The best things in life, aren't things.



Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Gwil on Thu Jun 16th at 4:36am 2005


? quoting Tracer Bullet
That has to be one of the dumbest ideas I've ever heard. All you'd have to do is raise gas taxes to achieve the listed goal and you wouldn't have to spend a fortune of infrastructure.

Petrol prices are already obscenely high in the UK, compared to other large Western oil consumers. Raising the price without relation to the price of crude oil would just trigger another blockage and ensuing shortage we saw back in the late 90s/early 00's. I can't remember when it was but it was madness.

I see also the reports of the US Government and Exxon editing scientific reports on climate change have been muffled by most. Strange.





Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Thu Jun 16th at 5:14am 2005


? quoting Gwil
? quoting Tracer Bullet
That has to be one of the dumbest ideas I've ever heard. All you'd have to do is raise gas taxes to achieve the listed goal and you wouldn't have to spend a fortune of infrastructure.

Petrol prices are already obscenely high in the UK, compared to other large Western oil consumers. Raising the price without relation to the price of crude oil would just trigger another blockage and ensuing shortage we saw back in the late 90s/early 00's. I can't remember when it was but it was madness.

I see also the reports of the US Government and Exxon editing scientific reports on climate change have been muffled by most. Strange.

What do you mean by blockage...? did OPEC stop exporting to you or something?




Some people are like slinkys...

They aren?t really good for anything, but you can't help but laugh when one tumbles down the stairs.



Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Loco on Thu Jun 16th at 9:52am 2005


Tracer: he probably means the fuel strike a while ago where drivers blockaded the refineries (I think that's what he means...)

I can't say I agree with this idea. The government seems to think that it will reduce cogestion, as if everybody takes a certain route just to irritate them. Additionally, even if you did have a system where a guy in a Nissan Micra wasn't charged the same amount as a guy in a huge fuel guzzling machine, the system would be so horrendously complicated to enforce. Thirdly, what happens to proffesions like HGV, driving instructors, taxis, buses etc? The companies will have to fork out huge sums.

Top Gear had a good article on this the other night, bet you can't guess which side they were in favour of...







Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Leperous on Thu Jun 16th at 1:55pm 2005


? quoting Loco
Additionally, even if you did have a system where a guy in a Nissan Micra wasn't charged the same amount as a guy in a huge fuel guzzling machine, the system would be so horrendously complicated to enforce.

Hardly, since your car type is linked into your vehicle registration & numberplate. If vehicles were classified in different bands, it's simply a case of saying "this person has driven X miles, with a class Y car, so they need to pay Z amount." It should be fairly easy to manage with computer systems, though the government has proved several times it's incompetence in this area (c.f. NHS computer systems, PFI, air traffic control, etc...) The hard part about enforcing it is installing the tracking equipment in cars in the first place and locating cars without it (though lots of hidden 'checkpoints' should be able to get round this effectively).

Again, I still think charging by the mileage you do is the fairest system. What do you do for taxis and freight and buses? You zone areas (city centres, motorways, rural roads, etc.) and class them in such a way that the people who have to use them pay the least. That way, it's fair!





Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by $loth on Thu Jun 16th at 2:27pm 2005


Lucky for me, i'm not planning on driving for a longgggggg time.....




Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by fishy on Thu Jun 16th at 3:13pm 2005


the whole idea is about cutting congestion by making it more expensive to drive. simple as that, and nothing to do with being fair to anyone. or isn't it fair atm, with people who only drive 2 miles a week paying very little in fuel duty, while those that drive longer distances would pay proportionatly more?


i eat paint



Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by ReNo on Thu Jun 16th at 3:25pm 2005


That is true, but people driving around for miles in the highlands of scotland aren't really contributing to congestion problems, yet still pay the same for petrol as somebody who, for instance, drives to work every day through edinburgh's crowded city centre. Its not only about how much you drive that they want to consider in extra costs, but about where you drive. The only real ways to do that are through road checkpoints where you pay to use certain roads, or a tracking system that keeps track of what roads you are using. The former of these is rather impractical, while the latter is a little too "big brother" style for some people's likings.






Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by $loth on Thu Jun 16th at 3:28pm 2005


Toll booths? Are we yanks!?




Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Loco on Thu Jun 16th at 3:56pm 2005


? quote:
though the government has proved several times it's incompetence in this area (c.f. NHS computer systems, PFI, air traffic control, etc...)


Ah, this is where reading Private Eye becomes useful. The government tend to use a big company called EDS, who caused the biggest computer crash in the UK involving 80,000 PCs (from what I remember) - at least, that's what Private Eye said... <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/icon_biggrin.gif">






Quote
Re: new plans to tax drivers by the mile
Posted by Tracer Bullet on Fri Jun 17th at 12:18am 2005


? quoting $loth
Toll booths? Are we yanks!?

There are very few (if any) toll roads in the states. Bridges, yes.




Some people are like slinkys...

They aren?t really good for anything, but you can't help but laugh when one tumbles down the stairs.




Post Reply