Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by Crono on Mon Sep 5th at 5:43am 2005
? quote:
Well, does this mean that Americans are less mature than the rest of the world?
There are different types of maturity. But, don't think that this line of thinking is absolute. But for the most part: I'll agree.

Crono
super admin
6628 posts
633 snarkmarks
Registered: Dec 19th 2003
Location: Oregon, USA
Blame it on Microsoft, God does.
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by KingNic on Mon Sep 5th at 6:45am 2005
That was a sad story Brasso but it most certainly qualifies for a
Darwin award. The guy obviously didn't know how to handle his drink and
had never touched it before. This would've happened if it was his 18th
birthday, his 21st or his 25th.
My parents started me off drinking when I was bout 14-15 (Can't
remember much). All I was given was a bottle of Bacardi Breezer to have
with my tea on holiday maybe twice a week. They've gradually built me
up over the past few years and I know what to expect with Alcohol. I'd
been drinking a fair few times with friends before my 18th and as a
result, I knew my limit. On my 18th I went right up to that limit, but
didn't go over.
I'm a lightweight (gradually getting better) and if I hadn't been
introduced to alcohol gradually then I'd have gone right that limit and
may well have ended up with a Darwin award. Raising the drinking age to
21 would do nothing. Americans obviously drink before 21 and the people
who get harmed by it are those who stick so religeously to the law.
KingNic
member
185 posts
49 snarkmarks
Registered: Feb 5th 2004
Location: UK
Occupation: Student
-KingNic
-Slapping polygons together incoherently since 2000
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by Junkyard God on Mon Sep 5th at 8:27am 2005
thye should not lower the drinking age as they get to drive at an earlier age.
would be dangerous!

Junkyard God
member
654 posts
73 snarkmarks
Registered: Oct 27th 2004
Location: The Nether Regions
Occupation: Stoner/mucisian/level design
Hell, is an half-filled auditorium
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by Fjorn on Mon Sep 5th at 2:26pm 2005
Well, look at it this way honestly
Country A:
There is no minimum drinking age. Youre family raises you, maybe about
10-12 your parents think you can handle a little, give you a small
amount for christmas dinner. Later on, you're parents give you
little bits here and there, more as you mature and become able to
physically handle it, you grow up drinking responsibly.
Country B:
Minimum drinking age is 21. You are raised in a 'YOU WILL NOT DRINK
UNTIL YOU ARE 21' household. You turn 21, go on a binge, you're found
next morning dead of alcohol poisoning
While B is a bit extreme, its happened.

Fjorn
member
250 posts
24 snarkmarks
Registered: Jun 5th 2004
Location: California - USA
Occupation: Student/Amateur Writer
Signature? What signature!?
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by jake on Mon Sep 5th at 2:57pm 2005
As I understand it any individual state could lower the minimum
drinking age but only at the expense of losing federal highway funding.
This suggests that one of the principal reasons for raising the age
limit is to reduce the number of drink-driving fatalities in the 18 -
21 age group. I've just read the following:
"According to research at the Center of Alcohol Studies, at Rutgers
University, raising the drinking age to 21 increased drinking-induced
fatalities in the 21-24 age group, by about as much as it lowered
fatalities for those aged 18-20. The study researchers suggested that a person's amount of drinking experience, not the age of the person drinking, played the most important factor in alcohol fatalities."
If this is true then the sensible course would seem to be to reduce the
legal age for drinking to 18 and raise the age at which you can legally
drive to 21.

jake
member
59 posts
6 snarkmarks
Registered: Jul 21st 2005
Location: England
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by parakeet on Mon Sep 5th at 3:48pm 2005
i was never taught against over drinking , they just assumed i
knew. luckily i learned from my older brother. i dont like alcohol
anyways though..
only kinda thing like that i drink is the wine at communion

parakeet
member
544 posts
64 snarkmarks
Registered: Apr 30th 2004
Location: Eastern US
Occupation: n/a
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by Crono on Mon Sep 5th at 9:21pm 2005
You guys are assuming that everyone who drives also drinks and everyone who drinks also drives, which neither of which are true. I wouldn't want to wait until I was 21 ... before ... to drive just because some douches drank too much. Not to mention, I don't drink ... So, that's kind of the s**t end of the deal, don't you think?
[vent]
There are other problems too. A large majority of teenagers here (not saying all, I wasn't like this, neither were any of my friends) are the most irresponsible drivers I've ever seen. Besides some anal-douche who thinks they're hot s**t cause they've got a BMW and cuts you off going about 60. Yeah, way to go, you almost killed us to get to the red light 2 seconds sooner, ass.
I'm sorry. I hate other drivers who're irresponsible, not only does it risk people's lives, needlessly, but it also costs me more money! Since they're in my age range, I get tacked with premiums in the area. I really hate insurance, also ... and the IRS ... what kind of moronic country would have a mandatory taxation system that wasn't part of the government, America, that's who.
[/vent]

Crono
super admin
6628 posts
633 snarkmarks
Registered: Dec 19th 2003
Location: Oregon, USA
Blame it on Microsoft, God does.
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by FatStrings on Wed Sep 7th at 1:21am 2005
in the great words of adam sandler
peeing your pants is cool
but neway pete was a jacka**
EDIT: that better French?

FatStrings
member
1242 posts
132 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 11th 2005
Location: USA
Occupation: Architecture Student
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by FatStrings on Fri Sep 9th at 12:46am 2005
sorry i forgot to add the sarcasm coloring
it wont happen again

FatStrings
member
1242 posts
132 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 11th 2005
Location: USA
Occupation: Architecture Student
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by Cash Car Star on Fri Sep 9th at 6:05pm 2005
Raising the driving age is a poorly thought-through idea. Far too much of our service industry is built on temporary labor from students. Far too much of our country is also to spread out to make public transport / bicycling / walking a decent replacement. You can raise the driving age in a place like Manhattan (and indeed, they have), but it's not gonna work in Generic Connecticut Suburb #1-25.

Cash Car Star
member
1260 posts
301 snarkmarks
Registered: Apr 7th 2002
Location: Connecticut (sigh)
Occupation: post-student
Re: U.S. Drinking Age
Posted by Nickelplate on Sat Sep 10th at 12:20am 2005
I think that if every state's department of transportation started building an interstate and inter-town train system, it would eveolve into something like England's system where every town has a station and the larger towns have the long-haul stations. Like in Missouri. Start with a train from St. Louis to Kansas City and one from those two cities to Springfield. It would get a s**tload of towns in between and eventually they could add more and more stations and the larger towns would hold "interstate stations."

Nickelplate
member
2770 posts
327 snarkmarks
Registered: Nov 23rd 2004
Location: US
Occupation: Prince of Pleasure