Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Gaara on Fri Sep 23rd at 3:15am 2005
I wish my school didn't have mandatory uniforms, although I voted to have them because I'd hate to think how much money I'd spend on clothes if we didn't have mandatory uniforms.
If we didn't have mandatory uniforms I'd dress like an insane hoboe like I usually do when going out with a raggedy old Jim Beam shirt and hoboe-esque jacket and jeans.

Gaara
member
219 posts
22 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 12th 2005
Location: Australia
Occupation: Freelance Gynacologist
Reckless disregard for childrens well being, women and nothing but utter contempt for other cultures.
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Crono on Fri Sep 23rd at 3:33am 2005
It depends on where the school is.
Something cloths usually implore is: first impressions. On the one hand, no one would make a bad first impression, since everyone's wearing the same thing. But then again, you may not become friends with the same people, since, honestly, when you meet people, you get a certain opinion of them just by seeing their taste in clothes.
Also, in the argument of "slutty" girl outfits ... make cheerleader skirts different, which are mandatory if you're one of them, before you start talking about the rest of the population. Not to mention, some people just hate those kinds of clothes. Many girls despise skirts. And, that kind of re-inforces a segregation of sorts.
So, there are good points and bad ones. But, uniforms will not fix problems like they're talking about. It'd be a better idea to just have "dress codes", which most all schools have anyway. I remember some were like, no mid-drifts or something for women ... men didn't do it anyway. Skirts cannot be too short. Little things like that, and if you disobeyed the dress code stuff, you got suspended. Or better yet, detention.

Crono
super admin
6628 posts
633 snarkmarks
Registered: Dec 19th 2003
Location: Oregon, USA
Blame it on Microsoft, God does.
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Nickelplate on Fri Sep 23rd at 3:38am 2005
YEah, it just seemed to me that the popular people when iwas in HS were always the rich ones anyway: the ones who washed thier clothes properly and who would look the most presentable anyway, thus ruining the first impression tihng. Plus the non-popular kids, even if they DID take good care of thier uniforms, they would still nto take care of thier bodies, and have stick-up hair or whatever it is that ppl made fun of them for.

Nickelplate
member
2770 posts
327 snarkmarks
Registered: Nov 23rd 2004
Location: US
Occupation: Prince of Pleasure
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Cash Car Star on Fri Sep 23rd at 6:27am 2005
Do you really have a problem with guys wearing "phallic imagery shirts"?

Cash Car Star
member
1260 posts
301 snarkmarks
Registered: Apr 7th 2002
Location: Connecticut (sigh)
Occupation: post-student
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Gaara on Fri Sep 23rd at 8:18am 2005
? quoting Cash Car Star
Do you really have a problem with guys wearing "phallic imagery shirts"?
Yeah that's pretty gay.
Anyway I don't wear our uniform more than once a week cause all you get if you don't wear it is a "uniform slip". A peice of paper. No other consequences.

Gaara
member
219 posts
22 snarkmarks
Registered: Aug 12th 2005
Location: Australia
Occupation: Freelance Gynacologist
Reckless disregard for childrens well being, women and nothing but utter contempt for other cultures.
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by fraggard on Fri Sep 23rd at 11:47am 2005
I was in a school that enforced uniforms. We had to wear the same
Navy-Blue/White outfit every single day (except saturdays, when it was
all white). I can tell you, from experience, that uniforms do not solve
anything. Students from more affluent backgrounds who want to show off
will still find ways to do so.
The problem, IMO, is that people want to segregate. Uniformity
does not come naturally. In any group people will try and be different
from each other. In large groups cliques will always be formed, on one
basis or another. Sometimes, the groups are just like-minded people.
Sometimes, it's still the money. Like the Cool Dudes With Esprit
Watches Gang, or somesuch.
One good thing about uniforms: you can never match the sight of a whole
bunch of school students, all dressed alike, marching together for a
school parade. The only thing to beat that sight is to be part of it.
I voted No.

fraggard
member
1110 posts
201 snarkmarks
Registered: Jul 8th 2002
Location: Bangalore, India
Occupation: Student
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Addicted to Morphine on Fri Sep 23rd at 12:41pm 2005
I voted No.
I went to a school where during the weekdays the guys couldn't wear
blue jeans and had to wear a collared shirt of some kind. Girls
couldn't wear skirts shorter than their fingertips when standing up
with their hands by their sides, and they couldn't wear tank tops but
other than that it was harder to enforce the girls dress code.
Personally, it felt nice to get up in the morning and put on a nice
button down shirt and go to class. And the weekends let me dress
however I wanted (it was a boarding school so everyone was hanging out
on weekends). I thought it was a really good system. My
school was thinking about bringing about a dress code like you
suggested except the guys would have to wear jackets and ties all the
time. I think that's going a little overboard. While the
school certainly looks nicer from an exterior perspective I just think
it would attract a different sort of person, and I'm not one to choose
a school with a strict mandatory dress code over one with a more
relaxed dress code.
Social segregation will never go away, it will just take kids a little
longer to figure out who they want to hang out with. Although --
clothes never really dictated who I hung out with anyway.

Addicted to Morphine
member
3012 posts
411 snarkmarks
Registered: Feb 15th 2005
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Underdog on Fri Sep 23rd at 1:39pm 2005
I voted yes. My reasons are my own. I am considered somewhat old fashioned when it comes to children so you really do not want to hear my reasons I am sure. Imagine all the old concepts about children's rights and you probably have my viewpoint. Seen and not heard is definitely among them.

Underdog
member
1018 posts
102 snarkmarks
Registered: Dec 12th 2004
Location: United States
Occupation: Sales-Construction
There is no history until something happens, then there is.
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Andrei on Fri Sep 23rd at 2:01pm 2005
Mandatory school uniforms? Maybe I don't feel like having someone's personal tastes imposed on myself. Nazis.
A stricter dress code would be much better.
And I think kids are such spoiled brats because parents are afraid to
beat the crap out of them when they step out of line. Kids nowadays
think they can get away with anything and will probably end-up being
horse-thieves.
And Attention Deficit Disorder is bulls**t; just a fancy term to hide the fact that your kid is a lazy spoiled douche.

Andrei
member
2455 posts
618 snarkmarks
Registered: Sep 15th 2003
Location: Bucharest, Romania
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Underdog on Fri Sep 23rd at 2:31pm 2005
ADHD is real. The problem lies in its diagnosis. Most are inaccurate to say the least.
I am not privy to the numbers, but I am betting that 90% of the kids currently diagnosed with this are just hyperactive, or spoiled. I believe this based on my own observations of current parenting skills. If I err, then blame it on my observational habits of noticing bad parenting.

Underdog
member
1018 posts
102 snarkmarks
Registered: Dec 12th 2004
Location: United States
Occupation: Sales-Construction
There is no history until something happens, then there is.
Re: Mandatory School Uniforms
Posted by Underdog on Fri Sep 23rd at 3:32pm 2005
? quoting Andrei
Mandatory school uniforms? Maybe I don't feel like having someone's personal tastes imposed on myself. Nazis.
A stricter dress code would be much better.
What exactly is the difference between a uniform dress, and a stricter dress code? Both are imposing a certain viewpoint on an otherwise unwilling subject. If someone can so candidly throw around the word "Nazi" Perhaps they could define the two in such a way to make it understandable for those of us whom do not like the term used at all.
and,
don get me started on Doc Spock.

Underdog
member
1018 posts
102 snarkmarks
Registered: Dec 12th 2004
Location: United States
Occupation: Sales-Construction
There is no history until something happens, then there is.