What is a decent monthly income?
Post Reply
Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by Underdog on Thu Nov 10th at 6:36pm 2005


Don't quote me on this because I am not sure but, I read once that the average income in the US is now around 60 thousand.

I am not sure of the 60 grand figure but whatever it was, it was about or nearly double what I figure the average should be.

Seriously, I know perhaps 10 people who actually make that much. I know about a thousand who make less than 30 however.

Either I live in a very low rent part of the world or, the people who got these averages are cheating somehow.

Averages are tricky things. To average 60 grand, a lot of people would have to be making in excess of 250,000 or more to compensate for the people who make minimum wage, which is still very much a reality.

I realize that there are people who make 250 grand or more, but its probably 1 in 100 compared to those making 12 to 15 thousand, which is poverty level.

I wonder, do we have any mathematicians here who could figure out how many rich people it takes to offset the vast majority of poor people enough to make an average of 60,000 annually?

I wish I had the article I read. <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/sad.gif">




There is no history until something happens, then there is.



Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by satchmo on Thu Nov 10th at 11:25pm 2005


As others have said before, a "decent" income depends entirely on where you live.

For example, if you live in rural China and make $10 a month, you would be the richest person in the village. People would look at you with envy, and think you're a rich bastard.

In the States, and especially in a nice (read fancy) neighborhood, you can barely survive with $150,000 a year. The mortgage itself would be $10,000 a month, plus other expenses.

Most of my friends make between $2,000 and $10,000 per month. I know it's a big discrepancy. Some of my friends are surgeons and lawyers, and others are just school teachers.




"The greatest thing you'll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return." -- Toulouse-Lautre, Moulin Rouge



Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by Underdog on Thu Nov 10th at 11:52pm 2005


? quoting satchmo

Most of my friends make between $2,000 and $10,000 per month. I know it's a big discrepancy. Some of my friends are surgeons and lawyers, and others are just school teachers.

...and all are well above poverty level. Not necessarily a bad thing but on the other side of the coin, I know no one at all who makes 10,000 monthly and many who make a whopping 2,000. I am not saying there are no high income people around, I just do not associate with them.

Says a lot about the dividing lines of the US that are still present. <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/sad.gif">

Teachers, now thats a thread we should begin.




There is no history until something happens, then there is.



Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by ReNo on Thu Nov 10th at 11:52pm 2005


You must see a "nice" neighbourhood as a helluva fancy one!






Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by Underdog on Fri Nov 11th at 12:02am 2005


? quoting ReNo
You must see a "nice" neighbourhood as a helluva fancy one!

Me?

I was raised to believe that "Nice" meant neighborly, not fancy. I assume you mean fancy? Ritzy?

I once met the man who now owns the biggest house in Arkansas. When he asked what I thought of his home I didn't know exactly what to say. I couldn't think of one "nice" thing anyway.

In the end I settled for "Embarrassed"

He asked "Why are you embarrassed?" I told him "Because you obviously are not aware that you should be you have 1 wife and 2 very small children, why do you need all this?

At that time I lived in a modest home. 3 bedroom 2 bath. His living room alone was as big as my entire home.

I left with a bad taste in my mouth.




There is no history until something happens, then there is.



Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by satchmo on Fri Nov 11th at 12:16am 2005


My wife and I visited one of my co-worker's house, and it could be described only as a mansion.

However, I've been to a gastroenterologist's house before during residency. He lives in BelAir, a gated community near Beverly Hills. His house has fourteen bedrooms, I don't even know how many bathrooms. His backyard has an orchard, two tennis courts, two swimming pools, a small house just for the servants, and he has more than a dozen vintage cars in his garage.

I used to live in Brentwood, where all the Hollywood stars live. I only rented an apartment there, for $1,500 a month. I had to split the rent with a roommate. But I'm used to seeing filthy rich people walking around. It's part of the LA culture.




"The greatest thing you'll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return." -- Toulouse-Lautre, Moulin Rouge



Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by ReNo on Fri Nov 11th at 1:10am 2005


I was referring to Satchmo's post Underdog - your post wasnt there when I posted.






Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by Mephs on Fri Nov 11th at 8:54pm 2005


? quote:
I doubt it. My brothers rent is R3000 a month, and his salary is R18000 a month.


This illustrates Addicted to Morphines posts's point.

In South Africa, however the quality of life is still racially dependant to a large degree rather than how qualified you are (I don't even need to ask if your brother is white or not). I used to joke about saving up my dole money and building a palace in some of the Forsaken countries in Africa.

However in the United Kingdom or Ireland, he you would not go far financially if he wished to maintain the same lifestyle. He would have to either be a businessman or something in the upper classes here.




Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by SpoolE on Sun Nov 13th at 9:24am 2005


@ Mephs: He's white! <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/icon_biggrin.gif">

Its not really wise to do direct translations (eg.$ - Pound) since diffrent countries have diffrent income taxes and stuff. Here in SA (Against the typical elephants-walking-in-the-streets theory) it is becoming a 1st world country, and has a very high level of technology. Food here is cheap, housing is not! We have a large number of very rich people, and a huge number of poverty. If you came here, and you came to a city such as Cape Town or Johannesburg, you would be impressed <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/icon_biggrin.gif">





Just a few pics of where I live <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/icon_smile.gif"> (Cape Town)





I would love to change the world, But they would'nt give me the source code.



Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by mazemaster on Sun Nov 13th at 11:39pm 2005


? quote:
Don't quote me on this because I am not sure but, I read once that the average income in the US is now around 60 thousand.
I am not sure of the 60 grand figure but whatever it was, it was about or nearly double what I figure the average should be.
Seriously, I know perhaps 10 people who actually make that much. I know about a thousand who make less than 30 however.
Either I live in a very low rent part of the world or, the people who got these averages are cheating somehow.
Averages are tricky things. To average 60 grand, a lot of people would have to be making in excess of 250,000 or more to compensate for the people who make minimum wage, which is still very much a reality.
I realize that there are people who make 250 grand or more, but its probably 1 in 100 compared to those making 12 to 15 thousand, which is poverty level.
I wonder, do we have any mathematicians here who could figure out how many rich people it takes to offset the vast majority of poor people enough to make an average of 60,000 annually?
I wish I had the article I read. image


You hit the nail on the head with that part about how averages are tricky things. Thats exactly the reason why the average salary is 60k, whereas the "average person" makes less that.

There are people out there who make many million a year. For every person who makes a million a year, that compensates the average for 30 people that make 30k a year. For every person who makes 250k a year, that compensates for 6 people who make 30k a year.

If you take the entire distribution into account, I think you'd find that the median (how much the "average person" makes) is in fact a lot lower than the mean (60k).






Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by Underdog on Mon Nov 14th at 12:00am 2005


? quoting mazemaster


You hit the nail on the head with that part about how averages are tricky things. Thats exactly the reason why the average salary is 60k, whereas the "average person" makes less that.

There are people out there who make many million a year. For every person who makes a million a year, that compensates the average for 30 people that make 30k a year. For every person who makes 250k a year, that compensates for 6 people who make 30k a year.

If you take the entire distribution into account, I think you'd find that the median (how much the "average person" makes) is in fact a lot lower than the mean (60k).

Yeah, averages are nasty things. I wonder though, how many millionaires it takes to compensate poverty level incomes enough to make 60k feasible? I used to live in Dallas. The mean income was higher than the outlying areas but still 60k was not so common as be an average. I now live in a much lower income area. 60k would be an astronomically high average.

Personally, I think they should omit the high and low end pay scales and average whats in between to get a more realistic average. I don't know if that would work but I have seen companies do it to tally loss and gain.

All I know for sure is, 60k seems a bit high.




There is no history until something happens, then there is.



Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by SpoolE on Mon Nov 14th at 12:15pm 2005


I think they should not take the average, but find out what a low and a high salary is. Then take the ones in between that, take their averages and you should have a accurate amount?



I would love to change the world, But they would'nt give me the source code.



Quote
Re: What is a decent monthly income?
Posted by wil5on on Mon Nov 14th at 12:54pm 2005


The median income is found by placing everyone in order of income, and taking the value in the middle of the list. So if the distribution is skewed towards one end (as you are suggesting), the median will make light of this. Hence this is a more meaningful measure.

To gauge income equality (which is the real issue here), the most common statistical method is to find the Gini coefficient. I forget the method, its something like the ratio of people in the top 20% income bracket with the bottom 20%. It gives a number thats a fairly good measure of how even the distribution of wealth is in an economy.




&quot;If you talk at all during this lesson, you have detention. Do you understand?&quot;
- My yr11 Economics teacher




Post Reply