Interesting Article on Videogame Design
Post Reply
Quote
Re: Interesting Article on Videogame Design
Posted by Addicted to Morphine on Tue Nov 22nd at 5:15am 2005


An excerpt from the NYTimes.com:

November 22, 2005
Making Artists
Video Games Are Their Major, So Don't Call Them Slackers

"So you have these four basic types that occupy the environment: the Achiever, the Explorer, the Socializer and the Killer."

Nick Fortugno, the 30-year-old teacher, turned away from the whiteboard and faced the 14 undergraduate and master's-level students in his Thursday seminar. "Killers act like predators, and like any ecosystem, if you increase the number of killers and facilitate them, you decrease the number of achievers and socializers."

A forestry class on the ecology of the African savannah? No. A psychology course on the ways of the grade-school playground? Closer, but not quite.

Rather, in his video game design seminar at Parsons the New School for Design in Greenwich Village, Mr. Fortugno was recently explaining the basic taxonomy of players in online role-playing games like World of Warcraft or Lineage, games that millions of people around the world play every day.

"You might think that killers are just bad for the game, right?" he said. "Well, they actually provide a really valuable social function: they provide something for other players to talk about. 'Oh, my God, did you hear that Dorag407 got killed last night at the dungeon?' See, all of these things exist in a social network, which is what really provides the game experience."

Most of the students kept pecking at their laptops. A few took notes the old-fashioned way.

Three decades after bursting into pool halls and living rooms, video games are taking a place in academia. A handful of relatively obscure vocational schools have long taught basic game programming. But in the last few years a small but growing cadre of well-known universities, from the University of Southern California to the University of Central Florida, have started formal programs in game design and the academic study of video games as a slice of contemporary culture.

Traditionalists in both education and the video game industry pooh-pooh the trend, calling it a bald bid by colleges to cash in on a fad. But others believe that video games - which already rival movie tickets in sales - are poised to become one of the dominant media of the new century.

Certainly, the burgeoning game industry is famished for new talent. And now, universities are stocked with both students and young faculty members who grew up with joystick in hand. And some educators say that studying games will soon seem no less fanciful than going to film school or examining the cultural impact of television.

According to the International Game Developers Association, fewer than a dozen North American universities offered game-related programs five years ago. Now, that figure is more than 100, with dozens more overseas. At Carnegie Mellon University, a drama professor and a computer science professor have created an entertainment technology program that now enrolls 90 students and will soon open branches in Australia and South Korea.

At the Georgia Institute of Technology, which started new undergraduate and Ph.D. programs in interactive media last year, the director of graduate studies at the university's liberal arts school likens the multiple outcomes possible in video games to the magical realism of writers like Borges.

"The skills and methods of video games are becoming a part of our life and culture in so many ways that it is impossible to ignore," said Bob Kerrey, the former Nebraska senator who is now president of the New School, which includes Parsons.

Parsons has offered game courses to graduate students for five years and this fall began an undergraduate program in game design.

"But if you just look at the surface of people playing games, you are missing the point, which is that games are all about managing and manipulating information," Mr. Kerrey said. "A lot of students that come out of this program may not go to work for Electronic Arts. They may go to Wall Street. Because to me, there is no significant difference - except for clothing preference - between people who are making games and people who are manipulating huge database systems to try to figure out where the markets are headed. It's largely the same skill set, the critical thinking. Games are becoming a major part of our lives, and there is actually good news in that."

It is certainly good news to students like Johnny Trinh, 18, a Parsons sophomore from Queens.

"When I came here, I was really surprised that they had so much in-depth set aside for people who want to go into gaming culture," Mr. Trinh said last month during a break in his multimedia programming class as, multitasking, he skimmed the Web message boards for his online gaming team. "When you talk to your parents, they want you to be a doctor or a lawyer, but they are starting to understand that you can have a real job making games, and among the students it is definitely becoming more popular."

Electronic Arts, the No. 1 game maker, based in Redwood City, Calif., has been a leader in encouraging universities to develop game programs. Last year, the company, which is known for franchises including Madden football, contributed millions of dollars to help underwrite a new three-year master of fine arts program in interactive entertainment at U.S.C.

"For 20 years, students came out of school and they had to kind of unlearn what they had learned in computer science, and the stuff they had done in art wasn't appropriate, and we had to do a lot of training internally," said Bing Gordon, the company's chief creative officer. "The big idea now is that in the last three or four years, the students are starting to come out of school immediately able to contribute to real projects, which is what we need.

"Just imagine that a movie studio showed up at a cinema school and said, 'You know, we need three times as many directors and screenwriters as we are able to get now.' That's where we are. In all of traditional media there is a glut of people who want jobs, and that makes for some dog-eat-dog competition. But in our business there still is not as much talent as there is opportunity."

Jason Della Rocca, executive director of the game developers' association, said that no firm figures were available for overall employment in the industry.

But at bellwether Electronic Arts, employment has almost doubled since 2000, to roughly 6,450. Over the same period, the number of employees in Electronic Arts's creative operations - the people who actually make games - has almost tripled, to 4,300.

At universities that have embraced video games, the curriculum varies. Georgia Tech has taken a more humanities-centered approach that focuses on the study of games as cultural artifacts, much as a scholar who has no interest in making television programs might study "All in the Family" and "The Jeffersons" to try to parse American race relations in the 1970's.

Institutions like Parsons and U.S.C. try to give students both the technical and academic backgrounds to become working game designers. That involves some traditional lectures, but often means assembling students into teams to make games, starting with pen and paper and gradually incorporating more sophisticated technologies.

"To create a video game project you need the art department and the computer science department and the design department and the literature or film department all contributing team members," Mr. Gordon said. "And then there needs to be a leadership or faculty that can evaluate the work from the individual contributors but also evaluate the whole project."

Most of the game programs are so new that track records hardly exist, but Mr. Gordon said that the master's-level program in entertainment technology at Carnegie Mellon had been the most successful in embracing a multidisciplinary approach and producing work-ready students. That program, which helped pioneer the field when it began in 1999, is led by the odd couple of Donald Marinelli, a drama professor, and Randy Pausch, a computer scientist.

"When students want to come in and complain that they can't work with people from other disciplines, we tell them to come in and tell us both about it," Mr. Pausch said.

Mr. Marinelli added, "When we first got the program started, we worried about if these hardcore geeks would be able to communicate with the artists. But now we find it common to see applications from people who have an undergraduate major in computer science and a minor in visual arts, or a major in music and a minor in computer science. The students have actually been doing this right brain-left brain crossover on their own."

Yet even some in the game industry express doubts about the merit of such programs.

Jack Emmert had already earned his master's degree in ancient Mediterranean history from the University of Chicago and was working on his Ph.D. in Greek and Latin at Ohio State University when he dropped out in 2000 to become creative director at Cryptic Studios, a game company based in Los Gatos, Calif., where he has helped design the successful City of Heroes and City of Villains online games.

"This whole idea of teaching game design is a fabrication," Mr. Emmert said. "I'm a serious academic, and what is the actual skill that they're teaching? If you're not teaching a quantifiable skill, then you are teaching an opinion. Making games is an art form. You need to understand the technical side, but I loathe any attempt to teach game design as an academic discipline."

It is a familiar refrain to Tracy Fullerton, a professor involved with many of the new video game programs at U.S.C. She said it reminded her of complaints from Hollywood old-timers in the late 1960's and early 70's when film schools first started producing directors and screenwriters who had spent more time in classrooms than fetching coffee on Hollywood lots.

"There are definitely some people in the game industry who wonder why academia is taking an interest in them after all this time," Ms. Fullerton said. "It reminds me that there was a moment when film studies really took off and the guys at the studios were like, 'Who are these Spielbergs and Lucases and Coppolas coming out of these film schools with these crazy ideas?' They'll come around."






Quote
Re: Interesting Article on Videogame Design
Posted by ReNo on Tue Nov 22nd at 12:59pm 2005


I'm on a games tech course and can't say I'd wholly recommend it. It might be due to the fact it's not the best of uni's (it was the first place in the UK to offer the course, hence why I'm here), but I find the course to be made up of a lot of filler that dilutes the experience with pointless crap. Like Flash. Or web programming. Or introduction to java. Or bollocks modelling modules that are CLEARLY not aimed at games developers (Rhino 3D?! Who the hell uses that!?). There is a fairly strong backbone of c++ programming, with time mixed between various platforms like openGL, Direct3D, Playstation and Playstation 2 (apparently soon we might be getting PSP's too, and the masters students get to do Xbox and Gamecube programming I'm told), and of course there is a fair old bit of maths, but more time should really be spent on these areas instead of s**t like "Creating music using MIDI" for god's sake. I'd say any wannabe games programmers should get themselves into a good uni to do a computer science degree or AI or something. Granted, there will still be a lot of stuff in there that bears no relation to game programming, but I'm sure most of it will have more overall use than some of the s**t we get forced through.

Game art courses seem to have a bit more success from what I've seen. My uni also offers a computer arts course that focuses on game and film content creation, and I sorta wish at times that I'd applied to that instead. Judging by people over at mapcore, some game art or related courses seem to teach lots of ACTUAL tools of the trade like Max, Maya, ZBrush and the like.

I'd say that anybody who wants to do a games related course should first of all check if the uni is any good. My course had high entry requirements, but nothing else in the uni does - this is a bad sign. Also check out the syllabus if you can. If I'd done this I would thought twice - seeing mention of MIDI and dozen other bulls**t subjects is enough to scare anybody.

In a related topic, there is a kitemark that is going to be given to games related courses that meet the standards set by a group of industry members, so look out for that if you are going to be applying in the future. There is it seems a wide array of crappy games courses around that have forced this card - hopefully it will seperate the good from the bad.






Quote
Re: Interesting Article on Videogame Design
Posted by satchmo on Tue Nov 22nd at 5:10pm 2005


I think it's always a good idea to attend a regular uni instead of a specialized technical school. It gives you a much broader perspective, and it's potentially enriching.

Even though I am a doctor today, some of the most memorable courses I took back in college was art and literature classes. I truly believe that they have made me a better person. As for all those biochemistry classes I took, I have no desire to retain any of those information, and I have no use of them in my daily practice of medicine.



"The greatest thing you'll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return." -- Toulouse-Lautre, Moulin Rouge



Quote
Re: Interesting Article on Videogame Design
Posted by Addicted to Morphine on Tue Nov 22nd at 5:40pm 2005


Satchmo, I agree completely. And as an extension of that thought, in a lot of ways the things you do out of the classroom to enrich yourself (hiking, hobbies, conversations you have with people) are more edifying than some of the classes you take.

As a Film Minor, this part was paritcularly interesting:

"There are definitely some people in the game industry who wonder why academia is taking an interest in them after all this time," Ms. Fullerton said. "It reminds me that there was a moment when film studies really took off and the guys at the studios were like, 'Who are these Spielbergs and Lucases and Coppolas coming out of these film schools with these crazy ideas?' They'll come around."

This surprised me because I was under the impression it was very difficult to land a job in the gaming industry:

"Just imagine that a movie studio showed up at a cinema school and said, 'You know, we need three times as many directors and screenwriters as we are able to get now.' That's where we are. In all of traditional media there is a glut of people who want jobs, and that makes for some dog-eat-dog competition. But in our business there still is not as much talent as there is opportunity."




Quote
Re: Interesting Article on Videogame Design
Posted by Crono on Tue Nov 22nd at 6:53pm 2005


You got that right, Satch.

Another reason why is: there are no specialized classes for your major from other areas (like math). You get to learn the whole thing :

AI is hard, but fun. I'm liking it so far, especially when I finally get to see real world application of logic work.

I seriously think my major at my university was designed to let people start software companies or something like that ... because we're learning everything. And that's an undergraduate degree.



Blame it on Microsoft, God does.



Quote
Re: Interesting Article on Videogame Design
Posted by Agent Smith on Tue Nov 22nd at 10:14pm 2005


I've found that my degree in graphic design and new media has been about as well recieved as a certificate in game design from one of the larger colleges in Canberra (this is where most of the game design collages are found). It comes down to the fact that with creative stuff, if a person isn't creative to begin with you can't teach them to be creative. My combination of amatuer game design and my study in graphic design seemed to work well, combined with the fact I am a creative person. Of course I'm not working in the industry yet, I've only just finished uni, so cut me some slack <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/icon_smile.gif">.



Ham and Jam Contributor
http://www.hamandjam.org

'Get your stinking paws off me, you damned dirty ape!'



Quote
Re: Interesting Article on Videogame Design
Posted by wil5on on Tue Nov 22nd at 11:12pm 2005


My uni doesnt do a specialised game design course as far as I know. A computer science degree makes sense for that field, you learn programming and maths with options to go into graphics and AI. I'm doing an engineering degree (computer systems, doubled with a comp sci degree), and I'm definitely learning lots of stuff I'll never use again, but its all interesting. Well, mostly :P


&quot;If you talk at all during this lesson, you have detention. Do you understand?&quot;
- My yr11 Economics teacher




Post Reply