the lunacy continues....
Post Reply
Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Mar 27th at 1:50am 2006


? quoting fishy
? quoting Orpheus

I seldom win an argument, but in losing I retain an audience simply because of how I lost. I never lose poorly. I just fail to win.

3 out of 4 is quite good....

Friends? or losses ol'fishman?

I know that I seldom win, but you gotta admit that there are many ways to lose.

*giggles*

One can lose through utter confusion and still maintain a modicum of winning. Or, the essence of it.

I have lost nearly every debate you and I have had, and yet, in losing I still made my point/position clear. One can lose and lose totally.

Nite-nite Fish... And Nite-nite everyone else too.





The best things in life, aren't things.



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Nickelplate on Mon Mar 27th at 3:33am 2006


Restructuring my arguments would change what I'm arguing for. If you don't like the truth, then you never will, because then you would have to admit being wrong all that time.

I mean, think about it. If christianity turns out to be what is right, (hypothetically of course, so we don't have any whining) then think of how many people will have living completely detestable lives. Breaking tons of commandments and doing so many immoral things that they have been justifying to themselves and other people for so long. It's not easy to give control of your life like that, so I can see where you would want to resist what I have to say.

Anyway, a debate is not a highschool popularity contest where you try to get as many people as you can to agree with you or like you. I don't really care how many people "got my back." because it's MY side of the debate that I'm presenting. If you need to validate yourself by taking the majority side of a debate and patronizing the other side, then do it.

You just need to tell the difference between an ARGUMENT and a DEBATE. I think you turn the former into the latter too often.




I tried sniffing coke, but the ice cubes kept getting stuck in my nose.
http://www.dimebowl.com



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by fishy on Mon Mar 27th at 4:03am 2006





i eat paint



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Addicted to Morphine on Mon Mar 27th at 4:41am 2006


Fishy, is that Kermit's head?




Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Nickelplate on Mon Mar 27th at 6:22am 2006


Yeah, that's kermit's head.

And what's with the HUGE fish?




I tried sniffing coke, but the ice cubes kept getting stuck in my nose.
http://www.dimebowl.com



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Crono on Mon Mar 27th at 6:42am 2006


? quote:

...
You just need to tell the difference between an ARGUMENT and a DEBATE. I think you turn the former into the latter too often.


I kindly concur.

I'm not entirely sure how you win or lose a debate exactly, and what does "winning" consist of? The other person's dropping out? Or their change of view? What is losing? Leaving the debate? Or not being able to convince the other debaters?

Sadly, online dictionaries don't separate these words much. However, plenty of things online are wrong anyway.

I'll probably never understand why you, Orph, try to make things about right and wrong so often. It's silly. Not to mention, half the time you're arguing with facts ... like saying blue isn't blue. And, I know you don't have a fourth color band, since you're not a woman ... right?

It's just ... odd.

Enjoy your long ass drive to Illinois or some such place.

Back on track:

While it's great to see diplomacy in this type of situation ... there's some things people don't particularly understand. In these countries, they're all ran religiously ... if they don't know what to do they check a holy text to see what it says. Of course, this leads to crazy things happening, since the texts were written several hundred years ago and don't apply almost at all to current situations (except in morality, maybe).

However, this is where problems arise. How do you be "just" about something in a country where the government, for the most part, is dictated by religion? Especially because religion requires interpretation, and, obviously, people can interpret anything to mean what they want. Injecting this "separatist" view on this type of society leads to such bizarre situations, I don't understand how people can be surprised or even mildly shocked.

In any case, I DO hope some acceptance of differences reached everyplace some day. That isn't to say change things everywhere to a democracy or something like that. But, just that differences are accepted rather than hunted out and destroyed on a global scale.

There are some funny aspects to things like this though. For instance, Libya, since the sanctions from the 70-80s are now lifted, the US can send things over ... in studying for this I found there are only three things not allowed to be imported:

1. Any alcohol product
2. Any pork product
3. Anything Israeli



Blame it on Microsoft, God does.



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Andrei on Mon Mar 27th at 10:17am 2006


? quote:


3. Anything Israeli


Hmm...i guess they're trying to give Israel a rejection complex. Economically, it doesn't matter; they're exporting all sorts of stuff to Romania and Bulgaria. I just wish they had instructions in english (or at least that french gibberish ) so that I'll know that i'm not buying fermented goat parts (they're good for you, though).




Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Mar 27th at 2:06pm 2006


? quoting Nickelplate
Restructuring my arguments would change what I'm arguing for. If you don't like the truth, then you never will, because then you would have to admit being wrong all that time.

.

What you seem to be overlooking Nickel is, I wasn't part of that particular discussion. I, being an outside viewer, can form opinions about your part in it without ever typing a word.

What you want to attempt to do is draw in anything from my past as part of your defense of position. Since I am wrong so often, AND don't mush words, you are saying that I am "wrong" then by association, my comments about your sexual debate must be also inaccurate.

Just because no one understands why I see life as a series of "rights" and "wrongs" doesn't place you in a position of knowing that my viewpoint is a total fallacy.

I have said, on numerous occasions that I view life in Black and White. It is not going to change because a bunch of "younger folk" (I hesitate to say children in spite of my thinking it) tell me that doing so is weird or strange. I argue the facts as I understand them. If I want to argue about the color blue I will. I was a house painter for almost a decade and believe me there are so many shades of blue that one could actually argue over them if they so chose to. I wouldn't but the fact remains that I could.

Now, the best thing you can do, each of you is "LEARN ORPHEUS" and stop trying to mold him into your own images of how things are. None of you are nearly old enough, nor experienced enough to tell me how to live my life. My successes and failures are 100% of my own making and I am proud of each.

Nickel, you were/are on the losing side of the sexual debate. I do not believe in majority rules so I do not feel that you are on the wrong side because so many are on the other side. I feel that you are on the wrong side simply because you do not know how to postulate your ideals in a satisfactory method.

I personally agree with you on it, but abhor your words of expression. It shows a decidedly ignorant methodology.

(Although I was primarily talking to NickelPlate, my words encompass you as well Crono. Mind your own business in how I view the world)

/2 cents





The best things in life, aren't things.



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Nickelplate on Mon Mar 27th at 2:53pm 2006


I view the world as black and white too. Either something is wrong or it is right. And you are wrong.

Nobody "wins" or "loses" a debate. Debates in public fora should not be about competition. They should be about expressing ideas, and learning from one another. But when one person refuses to learn from others, they turn a debate into an argument and seek only to "win." Then they end it with things like "/2 cents" so as to justify thier antagonistic position by telling everyone it's just thier free expression of ideas.

[edit] how DOES someone "win" anyway? whoever can call eachother n00b or "immature children" the most? I mean... what?




I tried sniffing coke, but the ice cubes kept getting stuck in my nose.
http://www.dimebowl.com



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Mar 27th at 3:06pm 2006


OK, since you seem to want to mush words we'll use yours.

In the debate over casual sex, you were the least able to express yourself in anything approaching satisfactory. Everyone else seemed more aptly able and you failed to pose your position adequately.

Now, that did not read "you lost"

Does that make you feel any better now?

As I said, I agreed with you, mostly. You just seemed hell bent to lose.

Stop splitting hairs with me Nickel. You can't win that way I assure you.





The best things in life, aren't things.



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Nickelplate on Mon Mar 27th at 5:06pm 2006


GRRRR! Nobody here is trying to WIN anything but YOU! Full Stop.

I'm not discussing it any further, because YOU seem hellbent on being a troublemaker.




I tried sniffing coke, but the ice cubes kept getting stuck in my nose.
http://www.dimebowl.com



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Mar 27th at 5:16pm 2006


Did it really escape your notice that I didn't even participate in that discussion?

How can I cause trouble, being a non-participant?

I think you are confused on what it means to "win" and "lose" at anything. There are many shades of each, and all are not marked by a checkered flag at the finish line.

I honestly think you are losing track of any forms of proper discussion, and the value of being in a "winning" line of thinking.

Anyway, the other discussion wasn't important enough for me to discuss then, and it sure as hell isn't worth my time now either.

/methinks you are still bent and since I am stupider than the people you "lost" to, your wanting to vent upon me.

Why don't you go back and lose some more to the smart kids, and leave this dumb old man in peace.





The best things in life, aren't things.



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Nickelplate on Mon Mar 27th at 7:06pm 2006


? quoting Orpheus
Did it really escape your notice that I didn't even participate in that discussion?

How can I cause trouble, being a non-participant?

You're making trouble in THIS one, you crazy nut! you just keep talkin trash trying to get people all angry so you can point out how "irrational" they are being, so you can appear to be right.

? quoting Orpheus
I think you are confused on what it means to "win" and "lose" at anything. There are many shades of each, and all are not marked by a checkered flag at the finish line.

What happened to "seeing the world in black and white?" Coz, by principle, you should beleive that you either WIN or you LOSE. Make up your mind, Kerry.

and nobody won OR lost the OTHER convo because YOU weren't in there screwin' it up.




I tried sniffing coke, but the ice cubes kept getting stuck in my nose.
http://www.dimebowl.com



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Mar 27th at 7:21pm 2006


? quoting Nickelplate
and nobody won OR lost the OTHER convo because YOU weren't in there screwin' it up.

Read this 10 times, then tell me honestly that you meant it.

If you did, read it 10 more times and get back to me because its a level of craziness that I would like to document for posterity.





The best things in life, aren't things.



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Nickelplate on Mon Mar 27th at 7:27pm 2006


Whatev.


I tried sniffing coke, but the ice cubes kept getting stuck in my nose.
http://www.dimebowl.com



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Mar 27th at 7:40pm 2006


Think of it this way. I am a dumb old man, and you cannot complete a thought without getting flustered. Its no wonder that those smart kids outflanked you.

Call it winning, or losing. Call it anything you wish that denotes primary and secondary placement in any debate, but the fact remained, you had a chance to prove your point and all you can do is get angry with me about it.

*shrugs*

Oh well. But I know where I stand in every conversation I attend. At least when its over with I do.





The best things in life, aren't things.



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Nickelplate on Mon Mar 27th at 7:56pm 2006


Nobody outflanked me, and I'm not angry. It's just pointelss trying to talk to you.


I tried sniffing coke, but the ice cubes kept getting stuck in my nose.
http://www.dimebowl.com



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Orpheus on Mon Mar 27th at 8:02pm 2006


I concede. You win, by default.

Have a good day.





The best things in life, aren't things.



Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by Gollum on Mon Mar 27th at 10:13pm 2006


What an apposite thread title, though unintentionally so.

Nickel, I think that Orph has tried to offer peace several times, following your initial bitter revisitation of a previous discussion.

As Orph said, your arguments in that discussion were not persuasive. He was being conciliatory in his language; I am more blunt: over the point in question, your arguments were incoherent.

But so what? We all make mistakes. I often have the error of my thinking corrected, and not always by people smarter than I (I flatter myself that they are in short supply). It's easy to miss an unintended consequence of your opinions; the mature response is to reconsider your theory, and either adjust or abandon it.

Alternatively you can sulk in the corner.

I stress, as Orph has done, that we are not talking about you being wrong. We are talking about you presenting an incoherent view. That view could, with a little modification, become self-consistent.

Indeed, you may already have a self-consistent view; but if so, it was poorly presented before.

Now, about more general issues:

Clearly, it is wrong to state that "actions = consequences". The relationship between actions and consequences may be more or less direct, but it certainly cannot consist of identity. This is a staggeringly blithe simplification and reflects your previous careless thinking.

And, on a yet more general note, some words of wisdom that I wish were mine:

"Believe those who are seeking the truth. Doubt those who find it."
-Andre Gide




Quote
Re: the lunacy continues....
Posted by fishy on Mon Mar 27th at 11:10pm 2006


i've got a 3rd point of view, but i don't think it would win the debate. i'll keep it for the play offs, though.


i eat paint




Post Reply