A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
locked
Quote
Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
Posted by French Toast on Thu Feb 8th at 10:06pm 2007


? quote:
? quoting French Toast
Because it's based on irrational fears and straw man arguments?



what, the war on terror?


No, the whole '9/11 was an inside job' mentality.




Quote
Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
Posted by Bewbies on Thu Feb 8th at 11:09pm 2007


yea frenchy.. i misunderstood that at first. i wrote a big, mean post about how it's actually the conspiracy theorists that are using irrational fear and straw man arguments.. ... but that's what you meant in the first place! ha

i agree with frenchy, someone please mark this date and time for posterity.




the players tried to take the field
the marching band refused to yield



Quote
Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
Posted by French Toast on Thu Feb 8th at 11:50pm 2007


Why must everyone say that when they agree with me image

EDIT: Oh, I see the confusion now. I misread Stadrics post. I said that 'there's no denying the conspiracy theory unless you look at any evidence', so like, the only real evidence is the stuff against conspiracies. And then he said that and I thought he meant why don't we consider evidence that supports them and bla bla bla.




Quote
Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
Posted by Stadric on Fri Feb 9th at 12:26am 2007


Ya know, I'm still waiting for a rebuttal for my video analysis... <img src=" SRC="images/smiles/icon_rolleyes.gif">


Also change the texture of the dock. Docks are rarely tile. -Facepunch
As I Lay Dying



Quote
Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
Posted by DocRock on Fri Feb 9th at 3:31pm 2007


? quoting Bewbies
Doc, you've managed to ignore my post regarding this 'evidence' you want to see. It took like 25 minutes to write that, cmon. =| anyway, here's a link to a report that breaks down the collapse. (bewbies, master of puns)

http://www.tms.org/pubs/journals/JOM/0112/Eagar/Eagar-0112.html[/quote]

That's a good report. What about this one? The guy who wrote it worked for the company that certified the steel used in the twin towers, then was fired because of his statements. Why fire the guy? What were they afraid of?

I don't know why some of you guys want to lock this thread. Lots of good info and debate. What are you afraid of? Why lock it? Because it's been discussed before? How many times have things on this site been discussed more than one time? lol cmon.




Condemnation without Investigation is the Highest Form of Ignorance!



Quote
Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
Posted by Dr Brasso on Fri Feb 9th at 7:58pm 2007


bottom line here, imho? in 30 years, when im dead and gone, and world war three (started on sept 11, btw) is in its third decade of "life", and my kids are fighting the battles, they arent gonna give a flying s**t about who started it....you can take all your liberal conspiracy theories and stick em, and then theorise as to why yer walking funny

.....it makes no difference, it was gonna happen anyway.....

Doc B....





Quote
Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
Posted by DocRock on Fri Feb 9th at 8:58pm 2007


? quoting Dr Brasso
.....it makes no difference, it was gonna happen anyway.....

Another war time veteran who doesn't care... I am a war time veteran, and frankly, I do care. I also care about generations of our children who will be fighting these wars. I would hope that they would want to know why they are fighting, and for what reason.

So sad that some people can be so cold hearted and not even care about the world around them. No wonder the global elite are manipulating us all so easily. God help us.




Condemnation without Investigation is the Highest Form of Ignorance!



Quote
Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
Posted by Bewbies on Fri Feb 9th at 9:29pm 2007


doc, he was fired for misrepresenting the company.. if someone was making stupid and all-around unknowledgeable statements, I wouldn't want that person working for me, either. in that letter alone, he's mistaken not only about the fire-proofing, but the melting points of steel. ..and this isn't some sort of opinion. these are scientific facts that he's wrong about.

NIST actually coordinated an investigation that consisted of experts from multiple fields, and from a scientific standpoint. call me gullible, but i'm willing to believe such a force of educated and experienced folks.

? quote:
Following pressure from technical experts, industry leaders and families of victims, the Commerce Department's National Institute of Standards and Technology conducted a three year $24 million investigation into the structural failure and progressive collapse of several WTC complex structures. The study included in-house technical expertise and drew upon the knowledge of several outside private institutions for aid to include:

  • Structural Engineering Institute of the American Society of Civil Engineers (SEI/ASCE)
  • Society of Fire Protection Engineers (SFPE)
  • National Fire Protection Association (NFPA)
  • American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC)
  • Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat (CTBUH)
  • Structural Engineers Association of New York (SEAoNY)

    A fact sheet from the report can be found here, one of the entries that I think is more relevant right now is:

    ? quote:
    7a. How could the steel have melted if the fires in the WTC towers weren?t hot enough to do so?
    OR
    7b. Since the melting point of steel is about 2,700 degrees Fahrenheit, the temperature of jet fuel fires does not exceed 1,800 degrees Fahrenheit and Underwriters Laboratories (UL) certified the steel in the WTC towers to 2,000 degrees Fahrenheit for six hours, how could fires have impacted the steel enough to bring down the WTC towers?

    In no instance did NIST report that steel in the WTC towers melted due to the fires. The melting point of steel is about 1,500 degrees Celsius (2,800 degrees Fahrenheit). Normal building fires and hydrocarbon (e.g., jet fuel) fires generate temperatures up to about 1,100 degrees Celsius (2,000 degrees Fahrenheit). NIST reported maximum upper layer air temperatures of about 1,000 degrees Celsius (1,800 degrees Fahrenheit) in the WTC towers (for example, see NCSTAR 1, Figure 6-36).

    However, when bare steel reaches temperatures of 1,000 degrees Celsius, it softens and its strength reduces to roughly 10 percent of its room temperature value. Steel that is unprotected (e.g., if the fireproofing is dislodged) can reach the air temperature within the time period that the fires burned within the towers. Thus, yielding and buckling of the steel members (floor trusses, beams, and both core and exterior columns) with missing fireproofing were expected under the fire intensity and duration determined by NIST for the WTC towers.

    UL did not certify any steel as suggested. In fact, in U.S. practice, steel is not certified at all; rather structural assemblies are tested for their fire resistance rating in accordance with a standard procedure such as ASTM E 119 (see NCSTAR 1-6B). That the steel was ?certified ... to 2000 degrees Fahrenheit for six hours? is simply not true.




    the players tried to take the field
    the marching band refused to yield



    Quote
    Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
    Posted by Dr Brasso on Sat Feb 10th at 2:56pm 2007


    yo doc....how you construed that i dont care is beyond me.....i care a hella lot sport, and dont even get me started in that direction....ive also done my time in the service, and i was one of the first mother f**kers to try and re-enlist when this s**t started....i would gladly give my life for this country, and the sparing of the kids having to fight this s**t ass war....we didnt start it, and we sure as hell could finish it quick, if we didnt worry about what every other two bit 3rd world f**king nation is going to think....

    ? quoting Dr Brasso
    .....it makes no difference, it was gonna happen anyway.....

    read it again man, and this time open yer mind up a bit....where the hell do you get "i dont care" from that?? you sound like every other liberal chicken s**t ive ever encountered....bah....and shame on you for assuming....that was not my meaning

    Doc B.....





    Quote
    Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
    Posted by DocRock on Sat Feb 10th at 5:09pm 2007


    ? quoting Bewbies

    NIST actually coordinated an investigation that consisted of experts from multiple fields, and from a scientific standpoint. call me gullible, but i'm willing to believe such a force of educated and experienced folks.

    You present solid information. Although I have read all of that before, it still brings me to a question that I cannot find an answer for.

    Since the buildings only burned for a very short time, was it enough time to cause the metal structure to bend and then cause the whole building to distintegrate? Was the fire hot enough not only to bend the steel, but also hot enough to cause the cement to implode as the building fell? Physics are manipulated in the fall of the three buildings that day. How can that be explained away? There are quite a few videos of the collapse of the buildings. I'm not sure how many you've seen, but this one shows where a MIT engineer and research scientist Jeff King details how the official government story violates the laws of physics and chemistry. He goes on to explain how the subsequent government investigations were designed NOT to uncover what happened. He also provides insight into what most likely happened that day

    ? quoting Dr Brasso
    .....it makes no difference, it was gonna happen anyway.....

    Sorry for misunderstanding, but it seemed like you didn't care. Kinda sounded, to me, like 'who cares either way,' and I took it that you meant you didn't care which caused me to want to know why when I knew you were a Veteran. I would fight for my country too, any day, and die for the truth, any day.




    Condemnation without Investigation is the Highest Form of Ignorance!



    Quote
    Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
    Posted by Juim on Sat Feb 10th at 5:16pm 2007


    Here is an actual documentary made by the New Jersey Port authority on the building of the world trade center. It's old, and a bit long but should answer some questions some of you may have.

    http://www.fugly.com/view_video.php?viewkey=a4f1de54d11ab6967e37

    So it seems that it was a new type of construction (for its day). Central steel pylons and the outer skin were the main supports for the building. (If I listened correctly).





    Quote
    Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
    Posted by Orpheus on Sat Feb 10th at 8:08pm 2007


    The good news is, other than Doc sending me a PM blaming me for all this..

    He managed to continue to debate this, without me and still didn't gain an inch.

    Now, was that because I was not necessary or....

    Anyway.. I said all I can about my belief as to how the towers fell. I do not really think its got much to do with politics, OR a conspiracy. Unless you count the fact that the design of the towers was supposed to endure such a calamity and failed to achieve its goals.

    If thats a conspiracy, perhaps its a New York one and as such, the people who approved the design should be investigated for neglect or bribery.

    Doc, do not send any more Pm's that blame me for your problems. You were tussling with Frenchy before I arrived. I did however defend MYSELF and my BELIEF.. Sadly, as far as you're concerned, thats picking a fight with you... Instead of just accepting that its in opposition of the statement you made.

    As far as this topic is concerned, my only regret is that Reaper backed me into a corner. Not how, but why. In defense of a worthless sack of s**t from Kansas.





    The best things in life, aren't things.



    Quote
    Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
    Posted by DocRock on Mon Feb 12th at 3:34pm 2007


    Since you brought the PM out into the open proves to me that you can't get over the rocky past we had here on the SP.

    That's your problem. I've gotten past it. You are the child who felt the need to tell on me in front of everyone else here just to prove.........................????? what exactly did you want to prove???

    You have the floor now. Cry. Cry about the past. Whine about how you hate me - the sack of s**t from Kansas -and how we battled back and forth and threw insults at one another years ago.

    Does it make you feel better to insult me on this forum? What do you gain from it other than a few snark marks? Maybe a boost to your pride? Well congratulations on gaining pride from forum thread.

    And Orph, 9/11 is not my problem. It's the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA'S problem. It's the whole friggin world's problem. It's a problem bigger than any one of us. It's bigger than your pride on an internet forum.

    I would have hoped that the information I brought here would have made someone research a bit and look for themselves. That's all I wanted. I didn't want an award or anything - just to help someone see a different angle. That's what I get for showing that I cared for you people - just to say 'hey, watch out for the boulder coming down the hill at us...and watch out.'




    Condemnation without Investigation is the Highest Form of Ignorance!



    Quote
    Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
    Posted by Orpheus on Mon Feb 12th at 3:54pm 2007


    *sighs*

    Go ahead. You cannot do any more damage than you already have.

    Next thing you know, you'll be discounting the moon landing or some other equally inane topic.

    Consider yourself lucky that we allow such members as yourself to remain. Be equally lucky that I don't have the power to alter that perceptibly because I'd press the evict button on you in a second for all the problems you've initiated over your stay here.

    Yup, I've cause my share of chaos, but my contributions to the positive far outstrip those.

    Doc, I promise you. If I ever get the chance, you'll be gone. That I swear.

    /discussion





    The best things in life, aren't things.



    Quote
    Re: A message frrom the great and wise John Cleese
    Posted by fishy on Mon Feb 12th at 5:06pm 2007


    as this is now a locked thread, please feel free to pm me for the last word.




    i eat paint




    locked