Snarkpit Forum Index » Maps » Competition results
Competition results
1
Post Reply
Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Leperous on Sat Oct 11th at 3:36pm 2003

Well, I tried to pick up my old reviewing pen, but it's just not working, I can't get into a mood to review these for you. However, I'll write a few sentences on each one, and post up my thoughts along with the winner of the votes- I hardly think my out-of-touch sk1lz warrants me marking one of them the 'official' winner!



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by KoRnFlakes on Sat Oct 11th at 4:10pm 2003

/me waits patiently [addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Loco on Sat Oct 11th at 5:35pm 2003

/me waits with knowledge my map has blatantly come last!



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by KoRnFlakes on Sat Oct 11th at 5:40pm 2003

Although I would personaly like to see all of the maps in order I think lep will just post the winner/runner up. So youl never know who came last. [addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Leperous on Sat Oct 11th at 7:38pm 2003

I'll post the top 3 as they're all pretty close. And no your map didn't come last!



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Campaignjunkie on Sat Oct 11th at 8:37pm 2003

Bleh, I should have put more work into my entry; don't really feel comfortable releasing such a half-completed map... Lep, hurry up and post the results! I can't stand the suspense. [addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by KoRnFlakes on Sun Oct 12th at 8:27am 2003

n1 finger m8. Im a bit gutted I didnt get anywhere but I spus I was up against some much better entries. gj lads. [addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Gollum on Sun Oct 12th at 8:53am 2003

KoRn, you are indeed up against some of the very best in the community. But your map is still very good work and certainly holds its own in the competition



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Orpheus on Sun Oct 12th at 12:14pm 2003

? posted by KoRnFlakes
n1 finger m8. Im a bit gutted I didnt get anywhere but I spus I was up against some much better entries. gj lads.

korn, i think you were first in your devision bud.. your map looks great, i hope you aren't discouraged.. look at me, i was up against just as many and i have lots more experience than you, and i prolly didn't place as high in the last comp as you did in this one.

be proud... you did better than i could have

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by ReNo on Sun Oct 12th at 1:32pm 2003

I think Korn shoulda had third place instead of me personally, his is a proper map while mine is just a pretty picture. I personally think you will find yourself in 4th position Korn, although you might have a bit of trouble with CJ's entry competing for it.

Congratulations to Finger - its a great map and fully deserving of the victory. Also many kudos to Crackerjack and his lovely level - could perhaps use some changes for playability sakes (not that I'M one to talk!) but for looks it is a beauty. And of course well done to all who entered, it was a fun one

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Crackerjack on Sun Oct 12th at 2:25pm 2003

Korn you did great man i was really surprised by ur map. I hope to see more from you.

Great job Finger congrats man Deff a map that i can learn from. Also great job ReNo, always have been an inspiration for my work. And Thanks to all who helped me with this map, couldnt have done it with out the help of others. Also im going to be releasing a completed version in a week or two. Thanks

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Finger on Mon Oct 13th at 12:31am 2003

Whoa, I feel all tingly. What a nice way to cap the past few years of mapping for HL. Thanks to everyone who cast their vote my way.

I put alot of time into that map, and it was very rewarding to get so much positive feedback. Also, I'm super thankful to Orph for his critiques, or I probably woudn't have pushed it as far as I did. I feel like the rest of ya were mapping with one arm tied behind your back. I think that Korn, Campaign, Cracker, Reno, Adam(hope I'm not forgetting anyone) all had class maps, that if pushed to completion will be amazing. It was really nice to see newer mappers enter also...lots of potential there; keep pushing it, and you'll be knocking our socks off in no-time.

Can't wait for the first HL2 comp.





Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Dr Brasso on Mon Oct 13th at 1:30am 2003

Mr Finger, ya did good sir.....and i must say, this is quite a group of talented folks......did you say map pack Mr Lepper sir?... congratulations to all who participated....i believe the critiques to be nearly head on, and i am thoroughly impressed with all, and not sorry i didnt finish an entry.....

ah, but there will come a time.... hee hee...

Dr Brasso...

well done gentlemen!

btw, it took me a hella long time to get through these babies.....wow.....ya just stop and gawk!.....had to be tough there Lep.....im sure in most cases the votes were close...

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Adam Hawkins on Mon Oct 13th at 8:19am 2003

Many congrats to Finger, Crackerjack and ReNo. I was mightily impressed by Broken_Palace as I hadn't really seen much work by Finger before (I think there were one or two maps in AGMOD but I might be wrong). The atmosphere captured in it was spot on, and I especially liked the little broken bits of wood and wall scattered around. The little outside area was (walk the plank) was a nice touch too

Well done all!

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by ReNo on Mon Oct 13th at 10:11am 2003

Adam, I think yours probably plays the best out of the bunch, although I haven't actually had a playtest with Finger's, which is probably the closest rival. Think I might drag myself away from FFX for long enough to have a bit of HLDM action this evening

[addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by KoRnFlakes on Mon Oct 13th at 10:13am 2003

rampart plays well, But with lots of players. with few players its very quiet due to its size. [addsig]



Quote
 Re: Competition results
Posted by Adam Hawkins on Mon Oct 13th at 11:53am 2003

Heh Rampart was nowhere as big as that to begin with, it was just the two opposing castles with the staircases up to the bridge originally, but I decided that there were very few 'arena' style maps for lots of players (most cater for a much smaller player number). I guess I could always release a smaller version too dm_rampart_mini anyone? lol [addsig]




1
Post Reply