I finally got around playing Rock24 and found it indeed to be the best SP experience since Minerva. There is a great love for detail, interesting twists and a steady flow. I'd even like to write a more extensive review sometime. For now all I can say is: Keep it coming! The HL2 community can need more SP projects of this calibre!

I'm glad you guys liked it, i know there were many issues where things weren't instantly obvious but as Mint explained, there were a lot fo factors against us. Our next mod will be a lot better... we promise

Yes, I agree that part could have perhaps been more obvious but there were problems with entities in that area. The sparks didn't work due to too many entities in the map. I tried to strip out as much as I could but ultimately had to create a balance. I REALLY wanted sparks coming off the elevator as it fell as well but alas they just wouldn't work there either. However, all the logic is there, including the spark entities so perhaps if Valve update the hard coded limit now that PCs are generally more capable, they will spring in to life in that area! It's mostly down to the dustmote brushes and sparks not liking each other.

I was going also to have Richard mention the electricity when he went over to the lifts to comment them being out of order but getting hold of our voice actor, redoing the face poser work etc I though would be too much work for such little benefit.

I did lower the water to try and convey you could go underneath but again, it wasn't too obvious. There were sparks on the lifts main power box to try and grab the players attention but they seemed to be a little tempremental so some times when compiled they wouldn't show up. :/

So anyway, I agree and sorry about that :P

I agree with 6th monkey that maybe the water's timed-electrocution could be a little more obvious.. I only really noticed it after looking for a moment and observing the pattern. I think a good way to indicate it might be to just take it up a notch: have showers of sparks and lighting beams when it is electrocuted and cut them off when it isn't.. that way it's a larger contrast between is-and-is-not electrocuted and people notice that more.

Mint_Sauce: You're welcome, and that's great, I'm truly looking forward to whatever else you have up your sleeves. I hope my review gets approved soon.. grumbles about Snarkpit review/tutorial/news approval process

Thanks midkay! Glad you enjoyed our mod, we will be starting on another in due time!

Wow never realised the water was on a timer

Maybe something could of made that more obvious so I didn't need to throw grenades around randomly to progress

edit Alright, I've submitted a review, it just needs to be approved.. sorry, I went kinda overboard on it - it's really long. I hope you find it useful. Here's an in-comments rating to reflect my review score, too, so that the score is put towards the overall rating:

6th monkey: Are you talking about with the electrocuted water? What I did was wait for it to become un-electrocuted (it electrocutes for a few seconds, every like 15 seconds) and swim through it to the other side where you can easily simply press the power button.

I agree that this was kind of a confusing place. I wandered around for like 10-15 minutes looking for where I should go before I realized the electrocution was on a timer and I could swim through.

I won't comment further yet because I'd prefer to write a review.. suffice to say that I played it all in one sitting and thought you did a great job

Good job guys this is well worth playing the 2nd best singleplayer hl2 mod I've played

Only a few problems here and there, like the lack of clip in some areas that makes some areas accesible that shouldn't be and an invisible box on one of the later levels next to the cross bow hut that kinda got in the way.

The only thing that could of been improved was the method of starting the elevator, I was running all over the place looking how to start that dam thing only to find I had to throw a grenade into a particular area which made little sense. Maybe there should of been a vent leading to that power switch

Anyhow good job, hope you continue map making, this was very fun

Wow, the screenshots seriously look GREAT. Original settings, very polished and good-looking. Hour and a half of play time broken into chapters? Man, I can't wait to play this. Getting it now but I won't have time to work through it for more than about 15 minutes until tonight.

If nobody beats me to the punch I'll be glad to review it.