dm_station14

dm_station14

Re: dm_station14 Posted by Tarky on Mon Dec 13th 2004 at 7:42am
Tarky
12 posts
Posted 2004-12-13 7:42am
Tarky
member
12 posts 11 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 10th 2004 Location: Australia
Actually for a first time mapper you aren't doing too bad. It is good to see you have a grasp of the editor. But some advice. Use textures that are meant for certain surfaces. In one of those shots you appear to have something that was meant for a small trim or something assigned to the roof. Also take a look at real architecture and see how strength and reinforcement is needed in buildings. You have some very thin stuff in there and some rooms etc without supports.

Also curves come in handy :), HL2 engine is very powerful use it to your advantage and make some things detailed (but not in excess).
Re: dm_station14 Posted by 7dk2h4md720ih on Mon Dec 13th 2004 at 3:22pm
7dk2h4md720ih
1976 posts
Posted 2004-12-13 3:22pm
1976 posts 198 snarkmarks Registered: Oct 9th 2001
Tarky gave some great advice already, but I'd like to add that it's a bit empty and lacking in detail, especially the outside. Add a smattering of physics objects like drums and crates. The buildings would look far better with more details such as window frames etc. Look at how valve did their buildings in the single player game to get ideas. Excellent for a first map.
Re: dm_station14 Posted by ribbz on Mon Dec 13th 2004 at 5:57pm
ribbz
10 posts
Posted 2004-12-13 5:57pm
ribbz
member
10 posts 1 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 9th 2004 Occupation: Sole trader Location: UK
As a newbie I am enjoying your first creation, I can understand the lack of objects etc as you are trying to get to grips with the basics
Re: dm_station14 Posted by ReNo on Mon Dec 13th 2004 at 6:24pm
ReNo
5457 posts
Posted 2004-12-13 6:24pm
ReNo
member
5457 posts 1991 snarkmarks Registered: Aug 22nd 2001 Occupation: Level Designer Location: Scotland
Its a great start, certainly doesn't suck for a first timer! My main concern outside of what has already been said is that it doesn't feel like a train station. The textures you appear to have gone for are more reminiscent of an industrial area. Take a look at the City 17 train station for more ideas on how to give across a setting convincingly.
Re: dm_station14 Posted by G.Ballblue on Mon Dec 13th 2004 at 9:47pm
G.Ballblue
1511 posts
Posted 2004-12-13 9:47pm
1511 posts 211 snarkmarks Registered: May 16th 2004 Occupation: Student Location: A secret Nuclear Bunker on Mars
Well, maybe it's a freight train station :\
Not sure myself -- it's left up to the mapper! It looked good from my perspective, but something looks a little bland (empty) with the second screen.
Re: dm_station14 Posted by Lan on Mon Dec 13th 2004 at 10:40pm
Lan
30 posts
Posted 2004-12-13 10:40pm
Lan
member
30 posts 13 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 13th 2004 Occupation: evil genius Location: usa
Thx guys! yous are much great help. ill work right away.
Re: dm_station14 Posted by Lan on Mon Dec 13th 2004 at 11:05pm
Lan
30 posts
Posted 2004-12-13 11:05pm
Lan
member
30 posts 13 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 13th 2004 Occupation: evil genius Location: usa
Oh BTW i'm glad you didn't say its like stalkyard and crossfire put together. whew. (^^;)
Re: dm_station14 Posted by Tarky on Mon Dec 13th 2004 at 11:09pm
Tarky
12 posts
Posted 2004-12-13 11:09pm
Tarky
member
12 posts 11 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 10th 2004 Location: Australia
Btw it is like stalkyard and crossfire put together ;) j/k
Re: dm_station14 Posted by Lan on Tue Dec 14th 2004 at 12:09am
Lan
30 posts
Posted 2004-12-14 12:09am
Lan
member
30 posts 13 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 13th 2004 Occupation: evil genius Location: usa
which is a better setting...

a abandon semi-industrial train station which is used to handle crates and big boxes with stuff... (more like an outdoor scene)

or...

a train station people use for public transportation (more like an indoor scene)
Re: dm_station14 Posted by 7dk2h4md720ih on Tue Dec 14th 2004 at 1:06am
7dk2h4md720ih
1976 posts
Posted 2004-12-14 1:06am
1976 posts 198 snarkmarks Registered: Oct 9th 2001
Neither setting is better. Go with whichever you think you'll be most comfortable building.
Re: dm_station14 Posted by RabidMonkey777 on Tue Dec 14th 2004 at 1:52am
RabidMonkey777
207 posts
Posted 2004-12-14 1:52am
207 posts 603 snarkmarks Registered: Jul 9th 2004 Location: Denver, Colorado, USA
I have something for abandoned industrial complexes so my vote goes to that one.

At the same time, architecturally speaking, public areas are more interesting to map if you like lots of architectural detail.

You choose.