from my forum post
I wasn't planning on revealing my votes, but I have to say this is most definately my choice for winner. Why? First, it carries out its theme visually with great success. The indoor/outdoor areas work great, the water works great, the textures are amazing. Finger even took time to superbly retexture the health/armor chargers. The lighting was fantastic. The flow was smooth, I found myself running all over the map. While the corridors at first seemed a little too similar looking, this quickly passed. Weapon placement was terrific, especially the egon which requires more than a little work. Seriously, what is not to like? Well, one thing - the paths in the zip aren't completely Steam compatible. Like it or not, Valve's spoiled brat of a program will be our bastard to worry about soon enough, and it does not include any folders named SIERRA. Similarly, people with CS retail are gonna have a tiny problem figuring out where the map goes. You may say, "but if they're not stupid they'll figure it out" - before you bring that argument up, let me remind you that they purchased CS retail. Anyway, so pathing from the half-life root on up woulda been nice but that's really the only thing I can possibly complain about.
