 
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Forceflow on 
    Mon Jun 7th 2004 at 7:37pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            2420 posts
        451 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Nov 6th 2003
                    Occupation: Engineering Student (CS)
                            Location: Belgium
             
                
                        Maybe add some more lights to the big hall ? Looks kinda dark. Otherwise, impressive architecture, great work.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Skeletor on 
    Mon Jun 7th 2004 at 10:30pm
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-06-07 10:30pm
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            312 posts
        41 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Dec 28th 2003
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: California
             
                
                        In the 2nd screen, would the light really be coming in like that on both sides?
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by 7dk2h4md720ih on 
    Mon Jun 7th 2004 at 10:49pm
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-06-07 10:49pm
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            1976 posts
        198 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Oct 9th 2001
                     
                
                        The glass in the first screen sticks out like a sore thumb. I'm impressed with what you've done so far. I've never seen the Harry potter movies so I'm in no position to comment on any inaccuracies though.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Wed Jun 16th 2004 at 7:54pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        Soz for the long wait guys, i ws planning on updating today but i got some new fans for my case and i was overclocking a now a file in windows is corrupt, but no fear! ill probably have them tomoro!
[edit] found some lying around,the courtyard is nexct to the hall but will be moved because of r_speeds, the dark room with the fire is partly done.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by JFry on 
    Tue Jun 22nd 2004 at 7:35am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             JFry
                            JFry
            
                        member
     
            369 posts
        82 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Mar 9th 2004
                    Occupation: Scumbag
                            Location: USA
             
                
                        Its looking good so far.  Nice atmosphere all around and the connectivity is very good.  If the entire thing ends up looking like the dining hall then it should be a very good map.    I did find a couple wierd things tho...  The water in the fountain has some very high waves.  The fireplace is casting no light, right next to some torches on the wall which do cast light.  The windows in the room with the floating candles look kinda odd(not to mention the floating candles!).  I'd get rid of them or at least replace them with a different window texture.  Also I'm assuming you have a leak since the whole level was in a skybox.  If you haven't already fixed it I'd be happy to have a stab at it.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Ferret on 
    Sun Aug 1st 2004 at 8:01pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Ferret
                            Ferret
            
                        member
     
            427 posts
        478 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Jan 28th 2002
                    Occupation: Student
                     
                
                        pretty cool! I'd suggest more ceiling depth cause its kinda flat and vary your lighting a little bit by adding highlights. Its too murky atm. Swell job!
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Skeletor on 
    Sun Aug 1st 2004 at 9:12pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            312 posts
        41 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Dec 28th 2003
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: California
             
                
                        Looks good, but as I commented early on in the map profile, I don't
think the light in that hall would stream in through the windows on
both sides of the room.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by 7dk2h4md720ih on 
    Sun Aug 1st 2004 at 11:50pm
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-08-01 11:50pm
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            1976 posts
        198 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Oct 9th 2001
                     
                
                        The area with the fountain looks very square and boring. Vary the
height of the roofs and set up a light_environment so it casts some
nice shadows and also brightens the area up a bit.
Some more suitable lighting would improve the dungeon too.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Mon Aug 2nd 2004 at 6:05am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        Thanks for the comments guy's, i'll do some work on it today and change those things.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Mon Aug 2nd 2004 at 7:26am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        Do you guys think that the rotating stairs are OTT?
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by fraggard on 
    Mon Aug 2nd 2004 at 10:37am
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-08-02 10:37am
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            1110 posts
        220 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Jul 8th 2002
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: Bangalore, India
             
                
                        If you can pull them off properly, the rotating stairs should be good. It's really up to how you implement them.
You really need to work on lighting. Not on the amount of light, but on how you place your lights, how they cast shadows, What you can/can't see etc.  Except for the first shot, everything else looks pretty drab. Make them brighter, more contrasting. Maybe a few more sources. Up the shadows, fiddle around with the gamma settings on RAD, use coloured shadows, whatever. There's a lot of work needed on the lights. I can just barely make out some pretty good architecture all hidden in the darkness.
Detailing's also needed in the stairs room and the last shot. They all look quite bare and empty. Be careful in the stairs room though... steps generally add a lot of wpolies :/
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Mon Aug 2nd 2004 at 10:44am
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-08-02 10:44am
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        Thanks for that frag [ adds it to my to do list] The staits start out how they are in the first shot, then when you get to the top of the first set, a set moves into position so you can go to the next, and again for the second set.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by matt on 
    Mon Aug 2nd 2004 at 4:23pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             matt
                            matt
            
                        member
     
            1100 posts
        246 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Jun 26th 2002
                    Occupation: Student!
                            Location: Edinburgh
             
                
                        Some of the rooms feel a bit square, in the books they definately feel more circular.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Cassius on 
    Tue Aug 3rd 2004 at 6:26am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Cassius
                            Cassius
            
                        member
     
            1989 posts
        238 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 24th 2001
                     
                
                        I don't know about accuracy to the book/movie, but it looks okay.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Adam Hawkins on 
    Tue Aug 3rd 2004 at 3:29pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            858 posts
        333 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 25th 2002
                    Occupation: Specialty Systems Manager
                            Location: Chesterfield, UK
             
                
                        If you've got the wpolys to spare, i'm pretty sure the rotating stairway area could benefit from more paintings (in the film I distinctly remember there not being a bare space on the walls from paintings).
Couple of the rooms look a little empty...big areas with little or nothing in them.
The default 'green neon' light texture sticks out like a sore thumb in the dungeon. It just looks a little un-natural and too contrasting when put alongside the stone walls :smile:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Tue Aug 3rd 2004 at 4:08pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        Maybe some lower lighted yellowish lights? Just a quick change in the lights file.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by fishy on 
    Tue Aug 3rd 2004 at 4:26pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             fishy
                            fishy
            
                        member
     
            2623 posts
        1476 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Sep 7th 2003
                            Location: glasgow
             
                
                        i agree with Adam about the lack of paintings. i thought they were one of the more memorable aspects of the movie. (i've only seen the azkaban one) some animated paintings would be cool. :smile:
if you could spare the polys, maybe in some of the barer rooms, a couple of vaulted/arched roofs/alcoves would be cool too. i definately remember seeing lots of nice curvy hammer-hating architecture in the movie.
i liked the fountain area. it only needed a lip at the top to suggest a roof. :sad:
if this was for tfc, you could collect beans to buy passwords that let you use secret passages. :smile:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Tue Aug 3rd 2004 at 5:32pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        I might add a laugh into it, instead of paintings, i could have animated models of saddam lol and maybe a chicken.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Ferret on 
    Tue Aug 3rd 2004 at 10:51pm
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-08-03 10:51pm
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Ferret
                            Ferret
            
                        member
     
            427 posts
        478 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Jan 28th 2002
                    Occupation: Student
                     
                
                        It is a nice start but needs a lot of polishing. I can see where it was inspired by Harry Potter but it lacks the polish to make it really FEEL like Hogwarts.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Wed Aug 4th 2004 at 7:19am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        Oh thanks A_S Never seem to thought of downloading a max payne wad for harry potter textures lol.
Now I have to give jinx 2 credits [ i downloaded his sprite pack aswell]
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Ferret on 
    Wed Aug 4th 2004 at 2:55pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Ferret
                            Ferret
            
                        member
     
            427 posts
        478 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Jan 28th 2002
                    Occupation: Student
                     
                
                        anyluck finishing this up?
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Thu Aug 5th 2004 at 7:17pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        So, im on the final compile today, as I am busy the whole of tomorow and am going away on saturday, i've fixed bugs and have added in most of what people have said. Are we allowed to provide a download link in the map profile before the comp?
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Gwil on 
    Thu Aug 5th 2004 at 7:23pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Gwil
                            Gwil
            
                        super admin
     
            2864 posts
        315 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Oct 13th 2001
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: Derbyshire, UK
             
                
                        Yes $loth, as long as it's available and ready for before the end of Sunday (8/8/04) i'm sure it will be fine.
you might want to PM lep the details as well, to be sure he lists you as "entering the contest" :smile:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Thu Aug 5th 2004 at 7:27pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        I thought we had to email lep, meh, i'll do both. Thanks for the word of warning gwil :smile:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Gwil on 
    Thu Aug 5th 2004 at 7:49pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Gwil
                            Gwil
            
                        super admin
     
            2864 posts
        315 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Oct 13th 2001
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: Derbyshire, UK
             
                
                        to tell you the truth mate i'm not entirely sure without checking, best to read the instructions..
my mind has been reduced to gloop by an afternoon picking/packing dolls house parts :razz:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Tue Aug 10th 2004 at 7:26am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        Oppps, wrong chapter :sad:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by $loth on 
    Tue Aug 10th 2004 at 7:27am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             $loth
                            $loth
            
                        member
     
            2256 posts
        292 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 27th 2004
                    Occupation: Student
                            Location: South England
             
                
                        If any one wants to check out my map and add some critiques then plz post them in here!
I've got a download link if anyone wants to try it out :razz:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: dm_hogwarts
                        Posted by Andrei on 
    Sun Oct 24th 2004 at 8:22pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Andrei
                            Andrei
            
                        member
     
            2455 posts
        1248 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Sep 15th 2003
                            Location: Bucharest, Romania
             
                
                        It looks like a good start but you SERIOUSLY need to see the Harry Potter movies. You need a better set of textures (perhaps the piranessi wad). The windows in pic 4, for example , are really ugly.