ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread

ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread

Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Fri Apr 17th 2009 at 7:21am
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-17 7:21am
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
Hi and welcome to the newest version of our website, which has been developed over the winter based on feedback from active users.

We are also on a new web host, so everything should be much faster and more reliable now.

This thread is for the posting of feedback on the new site, but please keep your posts constructive.

Please read the v6 development thread before posting as the reasons behind certain many new features are explained in there.

The now defunct 'Relaunch' thread can still be found here

NB - do not post bugs in this thread - there is a bugs thread for that here

Thanks and have fun!
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Riven on Fri Apr 17th 2009 at 10:58pm
Riven
1640 posts
Posted 2009-04-17 10:58pm
Riven
Wuch ya look'n at?
super admin
1640 posts 1266 snarkmarks Registered: May 2nd 2005 Occupation: Architect Location: Austin, Texas, USA
Yahoo! Glad to have the site updated! -And FAST! Yay. Ok, first request, :P

-I don't currently see a way to be able to moderate user journals. That means anyone can post whatever they want said on the front page, and admins couldn't do anything about it. Perhaps a 'moderate' dropdown menu like for other user posts could be added in case we get some 'unwanted' material.

Looks like the site crossed over normally! -I hope it wasn't too strenuous on ya?
Blog: www.playingarchitecture.net
LinkedIn: Eric Lancon
Twitter:@Riven202
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by haymaker on Fri Apr 17th 2009 at 11:42pm
haymaker
439 posts
Posted 2009-04-17 11:42pm
haymaker
member
439 posts 921 snarkmarks Registered: Apr 1st 2007 Location: CAN
Loving the speed yes!

One of the gnarly things about the previous version was the search function, wasn't all that intuitive or effective. EG searching for a map by name, you MUST enter the exact name, which is a drag when you can't remember it exactly, just a keyword.

Can't sort map discussion forum by post date or name, just automatically when it was started. Makes sense for a regular forum but I find myself looking for links I remember seeing in certain threads.

Wierd loop here: http://www.snarkpit.net/index.php?s=forums&f=2&t=10179&tp=#175243

clicking on the link for the discussion thread gives an error, but not if I navigate the opposite way, from discussion thread to map page.http://www.snarkpit.net/index.php?s=maps&map=3091

Nice work so far! Thank you!
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Le Chief on Sat Apr 18th 2009 at 1:12am
Le Chief
2605 posts
Posted 2009-04-18 1:12am
Le Chief
member
2605 posts 937 snarkmarks Registered: Jul 28th 2006 Location: Sydney, Australia
Finally, it has arrived! :cowjump:

Love the new features and all the fixes and reorganization since the previous version! Great job Larchy and everybody else involved!
Aaron's Stuff
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Riven on Sat Apr 18th 2009 at 5:50am
Riven
1640 posts
Posted 2009-04-18 5:50am
Riven
Wuch ya look'n at?
super admin
1640 posts 1266 snarkmarks Registered: May 2nd 2005 Occupation: Architect Location: Austin, Texas, USA
Perhaps for Journal entries also, you should limit only a character limit of 250 or something, because extremely long journals might push the page down quite a bit and make it look all weird. -Then make the titles linkable to their respective pages so users can read the whole thing (like newspaper articles!)
Blog: www.playingarchitecture.net
LinkedIn: Eric Lancon
Twitter:@Riven202
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Sat Apr 18th 2009 at 7:37am
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-18 7:37am
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
Yeah good idea, will do!
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Gwil on Sat Apr 18th 2009 at 11:08am
Gwil
2864 posts
Posted 2009-04-18 11:08am
Gwil
super admin
2864 posts 315 snarkmarks Registered: Oct 13th 2001 Occupation: Student Location: Derbyshire, UK
Uber props to the larch, he has worked and continues to work extremely hard for us mere minions. When I visit the grim north i'll be sure to buy him a beer/coffee/kitty food on the behalf of all our members.

Big thanks to all who donated to pay for our new hosting too, your contributions are greatly appreciated. Thanks also to the old master Leperous who transferred our domain with no quibbles or qualms.

Good job all :wcc:
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Sun Apr 19th 2009 at 9:54am
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-19 9:54am
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
haymaker said:
Wierd loop here: http://www.snarkpit.net/index.php?s=forums&f=2&t=10179&tp=#175243
Haha! oh dear, big apologies, bit of a daft error in the script that handled creating all the map threads... quite a few of the links to the actual maps would have been b0rked.

Just ran a script to clean things up, so all the affected links should be fixed now.

Bugs thread for future problems though else I might not see the post! thanks!
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Le Chief on Sun Apr 19th 2009 at 1:14pm
Le Chief
2605 posts
Posted 2009-04-19 1:14pm
Le Chief
member
2605 posts 937 snarkmarks Registered: Jul 28th 2006 Location: Sydney, Australia
Is there a way to have multiple images in the same line in the forum signature? If you check out my signature I want those three images to be in the same line but it seems to automatically add them to another line. ;(
Aaron's Stuff
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by RedWood on Sun Apr 19th 2009 at 4:52pm
RedWood
719 posts
Posted 2009-04-19 4:52pm
RedWood
member
719 posts 652 snarkmarks Registered: Sep 13th 2006
Does anyone ells hear think that the signatures should have a limit height of about 130 pixels including text. I'd kill myself if the Pit became this.

http://www.tnbgaming.net/forums/showthread.php?t=11280

Sorry Aaron.
Reality has become a commodity.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Riven on Sun Apr 19th 2009 at 5:09pm
Riven
1640 posts
Posted 2009-04-19 5:09pm
Riven
Wuch ya look'n at?
super admin
1640 posts 1266 snarkmarks Registered: May 2nd 2005 Occupation: Architect Location: Austin, Texas, USA
Whoa, That's crazy! I don't 'get' that at all. What's the point of having a sig if they have to make it so huge?
Blog: www.playingarchitecture.net
LinkedIn: Eric Lancon
Twitter:@Riven202
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by G4MER on Sun Apr 19th 2009 at 8:51pm
G4MER
2460 posts
Posted 2009-04-19 8:51pm
G4MER
floaty snark rage
member
2460 posts 360 snarkmarks Registered: Sep 6th 2003 Location: USA
First off..

The page does not render at all on the OPERA BROWSER.

Second the WELCOME NAME is pushed far right and overlaps the MAPPING RESOURCE image on the header in IE 8.0.

As for Signatures, I think they should be limited as well in the following manner:

1: 1 image signature no taller than 200 pixels, X what ever length the message area default is.

2: 1 line of text no longer than the text area can provide for 2 lines to cover favorite quotes.

3: No Adult themed ( Porno ) signatures should be allowed.

Other than that, I think we can address signatures as we go along.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Le Chief on Mon Apr 20th 2009 at 12:14am
Le Chief
2605 posts
Posted 2009-04-20 12:14am
Le Chief
member
2605 posts 937 snarkmarks Registered: Jul 28th 2006 Location: Sydney, Australia
I agree also, signatures shouldn't be too big. I actually wanted to have those three images in one line (hence my previous post in this thread).

Yeah that site is pretty crazy :-o
Aaron's Stuff
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by RedWood on Mon Apr 20th 2009 at 3:51pm
RedWood
719 posts
Posted 2009-04-20 3:51pm
RedWood
member
719 posts 652 snarkmarks Registered: Sep 13th 2006
Looks good Aaron. I read it but it didn't proses fully before i posted...
Reality has become a commodity.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by RedWood on Mon Apr 20th 2009 at 4:07pm
RedWood
719 posts
Posted 2009-04-20 4:07pm
RedWood
member
719 posts 652 snarkmarks Registered: Sep 13th 2006
Its good people actually care about the snark marks. They should be effective in spurring participation.

Maybe we should try to think of more things we could ern buy gaining points.

I just thought of this:
What if we used the snark marks as a form of currency. The total points you have collected would still be shown below your name but you could use your marks to purchase abilitys on the site. Such as the ability to use the more unusual and fun smileys. ( :wcc: :flail: :cowjump: :scared: :sherlock: ~o) ect). Even if this was implemented some things could (probably should) be left purely to the total amount of points accumulated (pits). There could even be a little store set up in the control panel.

What do u guys think? Does this strike anyone as fashist? I like the idea my self.
Reality has become a commodity.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by RedWood on Mon Apr 20th 2009 at 4:09pm
RedWood
719 posts
Posted 2009-04-20 4:09pm
RedWood
member
719 posts 652 snarkmarks Registered: Sep 13th 2006
When we open the extend smillies list could it be made so that clicking on one would selected and put in the post instead of having to copy past it?

EDIT:
Wow, triple post. my bad.
Reality has become a commodity.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Mon Apr 20th 2009 at 4:31pm
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-20 4:31pm
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
You know, I've been meaning to do that for ages and it keeps slipping my mind! Done!
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Fjorn on Tue Apr 21st 2009 at 3:27am
Fjorn
250 posts
Posted 2009-04-21 3:27am
Fjorn
member
250 posts 25 snarkmarks Registered: Jun 5th 2004 Occupation: Student/Amateur Writer Location: California - USA
I love you
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by reaper47 on Tue Apr 21st 2009 at 12:31pm
reaper47
2827 posts
Posted 2009-04-21 12:31pm
reaper47
member
2827 posts 1921 snarkmarks Registered: Feb 16th 2005 Location: Austria
Ahhh... great news. New site is fantastic. Love the new features.

Awesome job, larchy! :clap:
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by reaper47 on Tue Apr 21st 2009 at 1:51pm
reaper47
2827 posts
Posted 2009-04-21 1:51pm
reaper47
member
2827 posts 1921 snarkmarks Registered: Feb 16th 2005 Location: Austria
Quick question: Is it... "impolite" to actually use SnarkPit's new file hosting for maps instead of providing an external mirror? I mean regarding bandwidth or available storage. I don't mind either way, it just seems very convenient to use the on-site hosting now. :D
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Riven on Tue Apr 21st 2009 at 11:18pm
Riven
1640 posts
Posted 2009-04-21 11:18pm
Riven
Wuch ya look'n at?
super admin
1640 posts 1266 snarkmarks Registered: May 2nd 2005 Occupation: Architect Location: Austin, Texas, USA
No, not at all! -If anything we should have some text that encourages users to upload their maps to our server. If we can get more maps onto our server, then we can ensure they'll be around for a long time!

-Hey, nice to see you back again reaper! :)
Blog: www.playingarchitecture.net
LinkedIn: Eric Lancon
Twitter:@Riven202
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by **Dedi** on Thu Apr 23rd 2009 at 10:08am
**Dedi**
284 posts
Posted 2009-04-23 10:08am
**Dedi**
member
284 posts 39 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 21st 2004 Location: Melbourne, Australia
Oh Wow!! Beautiful work larchy... and everyone else that has been involved! And another thing, I am very impressed by the speed, and the ability to post maps to the server..going to make things much easier. Hopefully one day in the next few years, when I'm not too busy with university, I can get back into mapping and finish some of my material that I deserted due to bugs, and finally have some maps to my name.

Great work everyone! :beer:

ps. wow I never knew about the number hilarious smileys available...or is that new too?

:fart: :azelito:
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Thu Apr 23rd 2009 at 1:36pm
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-23 1:36pm
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
reaper47 said:
Quick question: Is it... "impolite" to actually use SnarkPit's new file hosting for maps instead of providing an external mirror?
We've got 'unlimited' bandwidth and disk space, but exactly how 'unlimited' they are I'm not sure :p I think the best thing is probably just to see how it goes... but tbh the site in general is image-heavy and uses quite a lot of bandwidth before even thinking about downloads. This may be something that we need to discuss and have a good think about.

I've got the sort of background level bandwidth down to about ~160MB per day with the new code (was 300-400), but even that is fairly hefty! There is a bit more stuff I intend to do but there ain't really much scope for reducing that without hacking away a load of the graphics...
I have today added a system for logged in users to report dead links on maps. There is a little triangle next to each download link, and a backend system for admins to sort things out when you've reported a bad link.

Also, you get snarkmarks for reporting bad links (once the admin has dealt with it)
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Le Chief on Thu Apr 23rd 2009 at 2:43pm
Le Chief
2605 posts
Posted 2009-04-23 2:43pm
Le Chief
member
2605 posts 937 snarkmarks Registered: Jul 28th 2006 Location: Sydney, Australia
reaper47 said:
Quick question: Is it... "impolite" to actually use SnarkPit's new file hosting for maps instead of providing an external mirror? I mean regarding bandwidth or available storage. I don't mind either way, it just seems very convenient to use the on-site hosting now. :D
Haha, I've thought about this before, I even used to avoid hosting my level images on Snarkpit because I thought it was "impolite".

But I think it is polite, they wouldn't implement a feature if they didn't want us to use it and also, by hosting your stuff on Snarkpit, your ensuring that maps/images won't be lost or deleted and whatnot, which makes it easier for the admins I guess because they don't have to deal with missing content and makes the Snarkpit as a whole, more "reliable.".
Aaron's Stuff
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Thu Apr 23rd 2009 at 2:54pm
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-23 2:54pm
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
Riven said:
I don't currently see a way to be able to moderate user journals.
'edit' link added to each entry on both the front page and on a user's profile page.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Riven on Tue Apr 28th 2009 at 11:32pm
Riven
1640 posts
Posted 2009-04-28 11:32pm
Riven
Wuch ya look'n at?
super admin
1640 posts 1266 snarkmarks Registered: May 2nd 2005 Occupation: Architect Location: Austin, Texas, USA
Everything seems to be running fine capt'n! Having been using the site, I've noticed I have been taking advantage of a lot of the new features and find that they are missing little things that would help to make them that much better. I've been waiting to post this until I had some substance to it.
  • For the Map's page, can you either add another 'drop down list box OR three checkboxes that allow users to search through any of the first categories, but with conditions such as: Completed Maps; Beta Maps; and or Abandoned Maps. -This would help to alleviate some searching woes of mine :hee:
  • When browsing a particularly long thread, some users I've received feedback on personally, talked about how they felt it was a bit annoying to have to scroll all the way down or up to remind them what topic they were reading (i.e. searching for the thread title), or to differentiate from separate tabs of the SnarkPit open in their browser. Is it possible to add thread titles to the header so that they appear in the page's tab?
  • To re-iterate on the snarkmarks, (now that we have them in play), One user suggested we iterate a scalar value based on the NUMBER of ratings for a particular map; article; download. And not just the fluctuating rating for it. Because a map with the same rating as another one, may not be as POPULAR as that map because it doesn't have the same number of votes as it does. -Adding this value would have to affect the snarkmark count a bit I imagine. In terms of the more feedback you receive, the more demanding the expectations of you are. -And thus the snarkmark rating system can reflect that a bit better.
  • -For users who have reached well beyond 200 snarkmarks, do we have the 'custom title' feature in place yet? I have seen no evidence of it yet? -(and have been asked about it).
  • I've thought about it some, and realized that new members coming to the site may not know what we're really all about. Sure we have an 'about' page that talks about the history of us and how we came spawned into the world, but other than the subtitle on the header of every page, people stumbling here via a Google search or through some other website, have no way to quickly identify why we're different from everyone else. There's no Introduction explaining who we are and what we're about. And what kind of expectations we have or systems we use. I'm sure it can be a bit overwhelming. I think we need a separate page identifying these key elements and making it easily accessible to new users (no login required) and a link on the front page. It would let users know who the current admins are (in case they have questions) and answer questions like "is it impolite to upload to the Pit?" and really kind of present ourselves to newcomers to help give them an explanation about why we're still around and looking to help others improve their mapping skills. -Just a thought. question is: Where would it fit on the front page; do people agree with this or not? ( I might make a poll thread about it...) -What is the general consensus?
  • -larchy, I'm currently working on a new set of forum icons to send to you for uploading. (in order to fit with the theme of the site a bit more) Right now I'm trying to get an animated flaming snark working for the hot topic threads :P The issue is, they are modified from the original site, meaning they are: 32x32 px in size; -will that be too big to fit in the current layout?
-I have more but these are the 'refined' features I have for immediate disposal.
p.s. Thanks for adding that edit feature for journal entries. Should help to alleviate my woes about porn entry additions :P BTW, how many are allowed to appear on the front page?
Blog: www.playingarchitecture.net
LinkedIn: Eric Lancon
Twitter:@Riven202
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Le Chief on Wed Apr 29th 2009 at 2:25am
Le Chief
2605 posts
Posted 2009-04-29 2:25am
Le Chief
member
2605 posts 937 snarkmarks Registered: Jul 28th 2006 Location: Sydney, Australia
I very much so agree with what you said about listing the forum topic in between each post, but as for the popularity of maps.

I think its a bit silly to give more snarkmarks to people with "more popular maps", its starting to sound like a competition, but I think it has its benefits such as it encourages people to rate maps and want their maps to be rated and whatnot. I think this needs to be balanced with the marks awarded for higher rated maps also so that a person with a 5/5 map rating is likely to receive more points than a person with a 1/5 map that is popular.

As for the "L" next to people's name, I think that should be removed or changed. It gets to me a little bit that Haymaker has an "L" next to his name, what exactly is the factor that decides who is and isn't an "L"? I sure hope it isn't number of forum posts or number of maps etc. I think it should be a time period of say 30 days instead.
Aaron's Stuff
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by **Dedi** on Wed Apr 29th 2009 at 4:59am
**Dedi**
284 posts
Posted 2009-04-29 4:59am
**Dedi**
member
284 posts 39 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 21st 2004 Location: Melbourne, Australia
aaron_da_killa said:
As for the "L" next to people's name, I think that should be removed or changed. It gets to me a little bit that Haymaker has an "L" next to his name, what exactly is the factor that decides who is and isn't an "L"? I sure hope it isn't number of forum posts or number of maps etc. I think it should be a time period of say 30 days instead.
Agreed.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Wed Apr 29th 2009 at 7:36am
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-29 7:36am
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
L plates are removed when you get 50 snarkmarks.

There is no custom titles feature just yet.

The forum thread title does appear in the web browser title bar. Because it is preceded by 'The Snarkpit - <forum name> - ' the actual thread title is probably being pushed off the small space you have on a tab. I can reverse the order to fix this issue.

Map page search filters - no prob.

Snarkmark calculations - down to you lot really, I'll just the change the calculation to whatever people want. It's based off the average rating currently. I don't really like the idea of getting more snarkmarks just because a map/download/article is more popular and I think we talked about this on the Alpha site. Still, whatever you guys decide!

We could just add a faq page for all the introduction stuff. We could have a link to it... oo, I dunno... amongst the footer links (about.donate/contact etc)? Probably link in the control panel too... an auto-pm with a 'welcome to snakrpit, read the faq' message for newly registered users?

Icon sizes shouldn't be a problem because I'll just...er... resize them :P

The current ones are 14x14, so you'll probably be making each line bigger to accomodate 32 height. Bear in mind they have to stack alongside each other for new&old/sticky/locked/hot etc. the bugs thread at the top of the forum has three icons for example - 66px is a lot of space for icons! I mean... take a screenie of the forums and 'shop yours into place, see how it looks, have a play about. There'll be a way of making them work!

Oh, and I was thinking about reducing the number of front page journal entries... three or four maybe? It might be 6 currently.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by reaper47 on Wed Apr 29th 2009 at 4:25pm
reaper47
2827 posts
Posted 2009-04-29 4:25pm
reaper47
member
2827 posts 1921 snarkmarks Registered: Feb 16th 2005 Location: Austria
Riven, I guess your suggestion goes a little beyond that, but I always liked the "Hello, new users!" message on the front page for non-registered members. I don't know if that still exists? I guess the main challenge is to explain the Snarkpit in 2 sentences of text. :)
larchy said:
Snarkmark calculations - down to you lot really, I'll just the change the calculation to whatever people want. It's based off the average rating currently. I don't really like the idea of getting more snarkmarks just because a map/download/article is more popular and I think we talked about this on the Alpha site. Still, whatever you guys decide!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Movie_Database#Ranking :D

PS: How about outo-linking http adresses?
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Riven on Wed Apr 29th 2009 at 10:28pm
Riven
1640 posts
Posted 2009-04-29 10:28pm
Riven
Wuch ya look'n at?
super admin
1640 posts 1266 snarkmarks Registered: May 2nd 2005 Occupation: Architect Location: Austin, Texas, USA
One other immediate feature request:
  • -We need to return the BBcode help button and page to the reply sections.
aaron_da_killa said:
"I very much so agree with what you said about listing the forum topic in between each post, but as for the popularity of maps."
I didn't say 'between each post' I said in the header of pages.
larchy said:
"the actual thread title is probably being pushed off the small space you have on a tab. I can reverse the order to fix this issue."
-Sounds good. Crono will be happy :p
aaron_da_killa said:
"I think its a bit silly to give more snarkmarks to people with "more popular maps", its starting to sound like a competition, but I think it has its benefits such as it encourages people to rate maps and want their maps to be rated and whatnot. I think this needs to be balanced with the marks awarded for higher rated maps also so that a person with a 5/5 map rating is likely to receive more points than a person with a 1/5 map that is popular."
Aaron, I think you misunderstood me. Let me clarify: The more votes a map receives the more weight those ratings get. But the weighted points shouldn't out-do a map with fewer votes and higher ratings. Maybe it isn't necessary, but I feel this makes more sense, -which is why I bring it up. I haven't thought out the math involved or anything, but I think it could come into play after a map here has received more than 10 votes, then the more votes it gets, the more points (snarkmarks) an average rating of 5/5 stars or #/5 stars tributes to the author. That is to say, (I guess I'm gonna have to think about the math now :lookup: ) maps can receive a max of 50 snarkmarks right now if they have 5/5 stars. Let's say a map has an average rating of 4/5 stars which would tribute the author with 40 $SM. Now once that map has received 11 votes each vote over 10 could add +1 $SM to the total tribute of $SM for the author. So the user [in this example] would get 41$SM for his 4/5 star rated map with 11 votes.
-Now, I'm adding the +1 $SM to make it easy on myself. Doing that wouldn't actually weight the score for the maps, it simply tributes more points for maps with more votes. I hope that gets the point across a little better? -And yes I remember talking about this before; I bring it up again because I feel I have a better understanding of it now, and have received requests for it...
larchy said:
"We could just add a faq page for all the introduction stuff. We could have a link to it... oo, I dunno... amongst the footer links (about.donate/contact etc)? Probably link in the control panel too... an auto-pm with a 'welcome to snakrpit, read the faq' message for newly registered users?"
Sounds splendid. Yea, we can call it an 'FAQ' and I'm good for locating it down at the bottom. The welcome message sounds like a good idea too. It can link to the FAQ and let users know who to contact with direct questions. And be very brief. -Like you said reaper, describe the SnarkPit in two sentences or less. Although, to direct new users further to read their 1st PM, I suggest some kind of extra layer that could appear as a word balloon or bright arrow pointing to the 'messages' link. Just to let them know they have a brand new message that is very important for them to read. (or we could include it on the confirmation page after they log-in for the first time. Now we need to settle on what actually should be said for new users. If you have time reaper, would you like to write up a short draft? -Or perhaps come up with a draft for the 2-sentence description? I'll write a draft when I get the time (and patience) to do so. We can start a separate thread or talk about it in here, whoever gets to it first, or posts in here first; I don't care.
larchy said:
"Icon sizes shouldn't be a problem because I'll just...er... resize them :P"
-Sounds easy enough :lol:
larchy said:
"take a screenie of the forums and 'shop yours into place, see how it looks, have a play about. There'll be a way of making them work!"
-Working on it!

Number of Journal entries for the front page? -4 I think would be fine.

-Speaking of auto archiving, I recall on the old pit an archive for front page posts and user 'journals' (although they weren't called journals then). Instead of having to sift through the pages of front-page posts, perhaps we can create an 'archive' page that keeps a list of everyone's journal entries, and front page news, and spotlights (about archived spotlights> it would record when they were added, and when they were removed [not the order in which they appeared on the front page or anything]).

I know you said it may not be necessary to archive general banter, but can we make that a function for when we are ready to do so?

-And last but not least, the link to the IMDB rating system sounds somewhat like what I'm thinking in terms of weighted ratings.

-Whew, typing that turned out to take a lot longer than I thought! :-&
Blog: www.playingarchitecture.net
LinkedIn: Eric Lancon
Twitter:@Riven202
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by reaper47 on Wed Apr 29th 2009 at 10:41pm
reaper47
2827 posts
Posted 2009-04-29 10:41pm
reaper47
member
2827 posts 1921 snarkmarks Registered: Feb 16th 2005 Location: Austria
Very minor gripe: Youtube links should recognize the whole "http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KmkVWuP_sO0" and not just "KmkVWuP_sO0". Shouldn't be so hard to parse that out?
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Thu Apr 30th 2009 at 8:01am
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-30 8:01am
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
The tags are made to be the same as phpBB3 so we don't end up confusing people with bbcode that works differently from everywhere else.

Because of the way phpBB3 parses their tags it is very difficult/impossible to match the full link, so the vast majority of forums use the way I've done it here.

I can add some code to match the full URI in addition to the existing tags for us tho!
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Thu Apr 30th 2009 at 12:19pm
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-30 12:19pm
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
Riven said:
For users who have reached well beyond 200 snarkmarks, do we have the 'custom title' feature in place yet? I have seen no evidence of it yet? -(and have been asked about it).
ahem :lookup:
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Thu Apr 30th 2009 at 8:48pm
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-04-30 8:48pm
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
aaron:

I've disabled your signature because the imageshack image links were taking around 45s to load, your two posts on this page making the page take over 90s to load.

I need to code a fix to handle situations like this, but until then can you possibly not use a crappy host :D thanks

Here is your sig code if you need it again:
[center][img]http://img207.imageshack.us/img207/5706/rightwalk.gif[/img][img]http://img245.imageshack.us/img245/9739/sigspacer.gif[/img][url=http://aarondakilla.freehostia.com/index.html][img]http://img515.imageshack.us/img515/4464/sigaaronsstuff.gif[/img][/url][img]http://img245.imageshack.us/img245/9739/sigspacer.gif[/img][img]http://img525.imageshack.us/img525/294/leftwalk.gif[/img][/center]
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Le Chief on Fri May 1st 2009 at 6:32am
Le Chief
2605 posts
Posted 2009-05-01 6:32am
Le Chief
member
2605 posts 937 snarkmarks Registered: Jul 28th 2006 Location: Sydney, Australia
larchy said:
aaron:

I've disabled your signature because the imageshack image links were taking around 45s to load, your two posts on this page making the page take over 90s to load.
No worries, I'm actually really disappointed with imageshack and don't recommend it to people anymore. I've found that a small array of images, different everytime, can be unavailable for days, probably due to server issues. I've also permanently lost some images, mainly older ones I've uploaded 1 or 2 years ago.

In regards to the "L" plates, 50 snark marks? That strikes me as a bit much. I think it should be a 30 day time period as I mentioned before or 30 posts or something. I mean sure, people with less than 50 snark marks could probably not be considered "regulars" but for a member to have been here for 5 years and occasionally visit, I am ofcourse talking about Dedi, having "L" plates next to their name is a bit unfair. Not to mention Haymaker who has been around here for longer than I have for memory, and I'm sure all active members know him, but also has "L" plates.
Aaron's Stuff
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Gwil on Fri May 1st 2009 at 10:15am
Gwil
2864 posts
Posted 2009-05-01 10:15am
Gwil
super admin
2864 posts 315 snarkmarks Registered: Oct 13th 2001 Occupation: Student Location: Derbyshire, UK
Use photobucket you crazy pirate!
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by ffjakebrake on Tue May 12th 2009 at 9:21pm
ffjakebrake
16 posts
Posted 2009-05-12 9:21pm
16 posts 2 snarkmarks Registered: May 12th 2009 Location: Lake Tahoe, California
Well, like I said in another post, this version release refreshes my faith in the Snarkpit staff! This brings me back to the "good ol' days" when navigation and feature array made sense! Great job!
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by G4MER on Wed May 13th 2009 at 10:45am
G4MER
2460 posts
Posted 2009-05-13 10:45am
G4MER
floaty snark rage
member
2460 posts 360 snarkmarks Registered: Sep 6th 2003 Location: USA
Yeah the site really does rock again! Great job People!

HAS FLED.. funny you son of a.... :cowjump:
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Niborius on Mon May 18th 2009 at 5:20am
Niborius
1007 posts
Posted 2009-05-18 5:20am
Niborius
member
1007 posts 1116 snarkmarks Registered: Mar 23rd 2009 Location: The Netherlands
A feature where topics that you've seen will turn grey, and new topics with a new post will turn yellow or green or anything alike would be very nice.
Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/Nibgames
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Wed May 20th 2009 at 7:52am
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-05-20 7:52am
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
That's what the icons are for.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Wed May 20th 2009 at 4:25pm
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-05-20 4:25pm
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
There is now a favourites system.

Look for the little heart icon in the info for maps, articles and downloads. You can add and remove these items to and from your favourites list with a simple click.

Your list of favourite items will appear on the front control panel page, allowing you to keep track of your favourite content across the site.

The number of people who have added a submission as a favourite is shown amongst that item's info, and clicking the link will open a popup window listing each user.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Yak_Fighter on Wed May 20th 2009 at 8:03pm
Yak_Fighter
1832 posts
Posted 2009-05-20 8:03pm
1832 posts 742 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 30th 2001 Occupation: College Student/Slacker Location: Indianapolis, IN
When clicking on my profile the default section that displays on the right is 'downloads' instead of 'maps', which is what I would prefer. Is there no way to choose which one is the default?
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Wed May 20th 2009 at 8:12pm
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-05-20 8:12pm
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
It defaults to whatever section has the most content, but I'll have a look into letting you override it.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by tnkqwe on Wed May 27th 2009 at 2:09pm
tnkqwe
560 posts
Posted 2009-05-27 2:09pm
tnkqwe
member
560 posts 684 snarkmarks Registered: Mar 31st 2007 Occupation: High school student Location: Bulgaria
go-mod for half life is 1.0 is ready for playing,so the Pit should have a go-mod maps section
Never think about bad things!
TNKqwe:The New Killer qwe
[img]http://images.quiz.wegame.com/production/personalities/22/badge.jpg[/img]
I am Engineer - Play Free Online Games
[img]http://media.moddb.com/images/global/moddb_88x31_v12.png[/img]
Citizen Arms
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Riven on Wed May 27th 2009 at 4:03pm
Riven
1640 posts
Posted 2009-05-27 4:03pm
Riven
Wuch ya look'n at?
super admin
1640 posts 1266 snarkmarks Registered: May 2nd 2005 Occupation: Architect Location: Austin, Texas, USA
I'll add it, but it doesn't have a personal icon?

-I'll use this time now to make a request...

I think for our maps section, people may not know what all the games listed are all about, or where to go find them. I think each game added to the database deserves an info page of some sort that has links to where it can be found and images of the game itself, as well as a section at the bottom showcasing some of the content we have for it in our database (like the randomly generating featured maps list).

Here's a simple idea of what I think the page could look like:
User posted image
Imagine at the bottom there are links to a mix or articles, maps and downloads (instead of the featured maps :p ). Once a game is selected on the left, the content at the bottom would reflect just that game's content. But if it's on the "Welcome to the Content Database" page, then it can be purely random content of any sort from any game. I imagine for a Game's Info page, there would be the Game's banner, then an almost article style layout. (you could use the same article paginating bbcode to allow for extra long descriptions if needed). Allow the admin making the game info page to upload images for that page and reference them. -You could add it to the "edit" page for games in the super admin cp.

Now, in order to link to it, I think people could find it by visiting any of these pages: (also note some of the other feature requests within the images)
User posted image
User posted image
User posted image
-Similar links could be had at the top of the download and article pages.

Clicking on icons of a game like the ones boxed out on the images, would bring you directly to that game's info page section. BTW, the list on the left of the page would remain there regardless of which game is selected.

There's more to it, but I think you get the jist of it. :hee:
Blog: www.playingarchitecture.net
LinkedIn: Eric Lancon
Twitter:@Riven202
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Niborius on Wed May 27th 2009 at 7:04pm
Niborius
1007 posts
Posted 2009-05-27 7:04pm
Niborius
member
1007 posts 1116 snarkmarks Registered: Mar 23rd 2009 Location: The Netherlands
larchy said:
That's what the icons are for.
Oh, I didn't see those. Thanks
But when I am at the main forum page, there is no way I can see if a new post has been made but looking at the date and time.
Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/Nibgames
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by Yak_Fighter on Fri May 29th 2009 at 6:45am
Yak_Fighter
1832 posts
Posted 2009-05-29 6:45am
1832 posts 742 snarkmarks Registered: Dec 30th 2001 Occupation: College Student/Slacker Location: Indianapolis, IN
Riven said:
I think for our maps section, people may not know what all the games listed are all about, or where to go find them. I think each game added to the database deserves an info page of some sort that has links to where it can be found and images of the game itself, as well as a section at the bottom showcasing some of the content we have for it in our database (like the randomly generating featured maps list).
I think this is a really good idea, especially if it were expanded to include things like links to quick start guides, console command lists, important editing files, level editing guides, bots, etc.

I recently got on this Quake 1 kick which involved getting a new client, a bunch of editing tools, bots, and a ton of deathmatch maps. In addition I had to dig around to find console commands and stuff like 'what's appropriate r_speeds for a Quake 1 map' or player dimensions and movement distances. This involved scouring thirty or so sites in a community I have no experience with, and it involved alot of broken links, archives, and webpages long lost. If this could have been found on one reliable page it would have been so much easier.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Fri May 29th 2009 at 7:08am
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-05-29 7:08am
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
More game/mod info would be excellent. I have (I think) a better idea of where to put it all though... I don't like that big long text list of all the games :p Lemme work some stuff up.
Re: ARCHIVE: Snarkpit v6 Feedback Thread Posted by larchy on Fri May 29th 2009 at 10:06am
larchy
496 posts
Posted 2009-05-29 10:06am
larchy
fluffy teim
super admin
496 posts 87 snarkmarks Registered: Jan 14th 2008 Occupation: kitten fluffer Location: UK
Take a look at http://www.snarkpit.net/index.php?s=maps&game=4

Notice the new 'game info' icon on the top left.

Clicky! :D

:teach: This new info pane will only appear if a game has a description - all the admin stuff is there to edit this info Riven :) It's just on the normal edit game page.

I haven't missed the other little things you've pointed out... will add them as I go :cowjump:

Edit:

I think instead of having a separate 'game' landing page it would be better just to have that inline infopane. It could be added to the articles and downloads sections in the same way, and the stats box info for "maps: x number, articles: x number, downloads: x number" etc could be links to the maps/articles/dl sections for that game.

At the moment I'm not sure how well will work for the dl/article sections though since all the existing content from the old system is just lumped together into "HL" or "HL2" games...

I mean... we could have a full complete page for each game with loads of bits of content from all the site sections randomly pulled together. I guess I just thought the way I've done it was a bit more elgant.

Maybe the info pane could be expanded to have a load of small thumbnails running along the bottom with random content?

ooo

/larchy gets busy