 
                                
                    
                        Re: Doom3: Comfortly Numb is done!
                        Posted by fishy on 
    Sun Dec 18th 2005 at 12:37pm
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2005-12-18 12:37pm
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             fishy
                            fishy
            
                        member
     
            2623 posts
        1476 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Sep 7th 2003
                            Location: glasgow
             
                
                        i dont know, maybe it's because i know the song too well, while never having played Doom, but the story in the song doesn't seem to fit too good for me.
good overall effort though.
a week earlier, and i could have used it in a machinima report that i wrote. :smile:
                                            
                        i eat paint
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Doom3: Comfortly Numb is done!
                        Posted by Myrk- on 
    Sun Dec 18th 2005 at 1:53pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Myrk-
                            Myrk-
            
                        member
     
            2299 posts
        604 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 12th 2002
                    Occupation: CAD & Graphics Technician
                            Location: Plymouth, UK
             
                
                        Kinda mellow for Doom 3 don't you think? Did you ever see that music video using G-man to sing it? That was good, learn from it.
                                            
                        -[Better to be Honest than Kind]-
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Doom3: Comfortly Numb is done!
                        Posted by rs6 on 
    Sun Dec 18th 2005 at 4:35pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             rs6
                            rs6
            
                        member
     
            640 posts
        94 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Dec 31st 2004
                    Occupation: koledge
                            Location: New Jersey, USA
             
                
                        I also think the song doesn't fit doom3, its too mellow as myrk said.
                                    
             
        
            
            
            
                
    
            3012 posts
        529 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 15th 2005
                     
                
                        I thought this was really well done actually. You did a great job of matching the video to the song.
Parts I particularly liked:
The shot of the guy struggling with the doctors while Pink Floyd sings "relax..."
The way you cut to the spacecraft when he's singing about "ships"
The part right after the explosive barrels explode and he sings
"pinprick" there's this scream in the song that you matched up
perfectly with the in game footage of the guy tied up.
Also -- the lip syncing parts were done pretty well.
I liked all the sweeping shots of the complex and the hallways in the beginning.
The only thing, you may want to correct the spelling of the title.  Its comfortably numb.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Doom3: Comfortly Numb is done!
                        Posted by Myrk- on 
    Sun Dec 18th 2005 at 11:59pm
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2005-12-18 11:59pm
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Myrk-
                            Myrk-
            
                        member
     
            2299 posts
        604 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 12th 2002
                    Occupation: CAD & Graphics Technician
                            Location: Plymouth, UK
             
                
                        I didn't say the song didn't fit as such, I merely said that Doom 3 is more of a heavy metal genre, based on the action. A game more suited to Pink Floyd would be perhaps System Shock, or some spacey game like Homeworld 2.
                                            
                        -[Better to be Honest than Kind]-
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Doom3: Comfortly Numb is done!
                        Posted by fishy on 
    Mon Dec 19th 2005 at 12:23am
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2005-12-19 12:23am
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             fishy
                            fishy
            
                        member
     
            2623 posts
        1476 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Sep 7th 2003
                            Location: glasgow
             
                
                        there have been a few covers, most notable, for all the wrong reasons, was the techno version.
i watched the vid twice more, and came to the conclusion that it's some sort of infection that's doing the rounds. if so, if would've been perfect if the guy talking at 45 seconds had a voice dubbed in, explaining a little bit about it. it would've gone perfectly with the line just before it, about needing just the basic information, which is probably why the guy happens to be there talking anyway. :smile:
                                            
                        i eat paint
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Doom3: Comfortly Numb is done!
                        Posted by Dr Brasso on 
    Mon Dec 19th 2005 at 3:42am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            1878 posts
        198 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 30th 2003
                    Occupation: cad drafter
                            Location: Omaha,NE
             
                
                        ive watched it a few more times since my last post....
im still enthralled. i see new nuances in it every time i watch it. well done half dude.....keep it up.
Doc Brasso... :dodgy:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Doom3: Comfortly Numb is done!
                        Posted by half-dude on 
    Mon Dec 19th 2005 at 4:25pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            580 posts
        76 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 30th 2003
                    Occupation: male
                            Location: WH
             
                
                        I just used the Windows movie maker program that came on my computer. I saw a guy using it on his laptop at school and I thought "Wow I should use that!"
PS. Im glad you like it Doc. B, Im glad that people want to watch it more then once. Reminds me of what I do when I see vids others have made. :smile:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Doom3: Comfortly Numb is done!
                        Posted by fishy on 
    Mon Dec 19th 2005 at 4:39pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             fishy
                            fishy
            
                        member
     
            2623 posts
        1476 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Sep 7th 2003
                            Location: glasgow
             
                
                        it made me think about making one with DoD, using floyd's 'when the tigers broke free', but i know for a fact that i'd never finish it.
                                            
                        i eat paint
                                    
             
        
            
            
            
                
    
            3012 posts
        529 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 15th 2005
                     
                
                        That'd be a good idea once they implement the cinematic effects...
You'd probably need a team though if you wanted to do any complicated sequences.  I'd be happy to help.
                                    
             
        
            
            
            
                
    
            3012 posts
        529 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Feb 15th 2005
                     
                
                        With only 2 people we could do an amusing short where a soldier falls
asleep in the heat of battle and wakes up to find himself all alone in
the map... it seems everyone changed maps and forgot to wake him. 
He runs around scared looking for people (kind of like a lost child in
a mall) and then finally... he wakes up again, or finds everyone was
just hiding from him and they start fragging once more... and all is
right in the world.  And we can end with him getting shot and
being glad to be back in the action.
Or that's just a terrible idea and I have no idea why I just typed it all out and pressed submit.