 
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Crono on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 11:20am
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-01-22 11:20am
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Crono
                            Crono
            
                        super admin
     
            6628 posts
        700 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Dec 19th 2003
                            Location: Oregon, USA
             
                
                        Yes, PNG is an excellent format. 
I always forget to use PNGs instead of JPGs though.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Leperous on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 11:54am
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-01-22 11:54am
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Leperous
                            Leperous
            
                            Creator of SnarkPit!
                member
     
            3382 posts
        1635 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 21st 2001
                    Occupation: Lazy student
                            Location: UK
             
                
                        Well I'd use it if it didn't stick a XAT logo in the corner :/
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Orpheus on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 12:55pm
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-01-22 12:55pm
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Orpheus
                            Orpheus
            
                        member
     
            13860 posts
        2024 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 26th 2001
                    Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
                            Location: Long Oklahoma - USA
             
                
                        I do NOT want to get caught promoting defective programs, here or at PFL, so if there is something that needs addressed lep, show me.
(yes i know the first pic was large, it was only posted for comparative purposes, i will remove it if its very important i do so)
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Leperous on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 12:56pm
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-01-22 12:56pm
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Leperous
                            Leperous
            
                            Creator of SnarkPit!
                member
     
            3382 posts
        1635 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 21st 2001
                    Occupation: Lazy student
                            Location: UK
             
                
                        Hmm, well before it put some small text saying 'xat.com' in the corner of my images- but it was the shareware version!
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by matt on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 1:00pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             matt
                            matt
            
                        member
     
            1100 posts
        246 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Jun 26th 2002
                    Occupation: Student!
                            Location: Edinburgh
             
                
                        Being the great guy I am, I just imprt images into Flash and then add text/effects as I please. Then export. Done.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Orpheus on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 1:07pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Orpheus
                            Orpheus
            
                        member
     
            13860 posts
        2024 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 26th 2001
                    Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
                            Location: Long Oklahoma - USA
             
                
                        Sadly Lep, you are correct.
the good news is, the caption is tiny, and can be cropped with PSP, but if you can do that then you have PSP and don't need this program... or do you? can someone verify that xat optimise's an image better than PSP?
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Dr Brasso on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 2:21pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            1878 posts
        198 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 30th 2003
                    Occupation: cad drafter
                            Location: Omaha,NE
             
                
                        i dont know what the image sizes are in Xat, but in PSP, an 800x600 jpg lands at around 45-55 kb for me, but then again, im special... :heee:
Doc B... :dodgy:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Jinx on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 7:19pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Jinx
                            Jinx
            
                        member
     
            874 posts
        692 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Nov 27th 2002
                            Location: Ohio
             
                
                        neat avatar, Brasso
I usually use 640x480, then run it once through the 'sharpen' filter in Photoshop and save at about 6-8 quality. I kinda like that, because it keeps the screenshot smaller but the sharpen helps retain detail and makes it look crisp. That's usually around 80-100k I think, though I am usually willing to sacrifice some filesize for quality if I'm showing something off.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Orpheus on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 8:24pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Orpheus
                            Orpheus
            
                        member
     
            13860 posts
        2024 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 26th 2001
                    Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
                            Location: Long Oklahoma - USA
             
                
                        my opinion is, whatever it takes to get a file size down to under 100k is mighty fine.
with that said, people usually don't even bother to experiment or even attempt a new program because... they either feel their expensive program already does it all, or the new one isn't expensive enough to bother with.
i have found that, PSP8 and PS7 are extremely similar and do almost the same thing in producing a smallish file size, but i have also found that xat produces a still smaller file size with high levels of quality, when you combine its magi-compression with the jpg optimizer, both found in the jpg optimizer program.. i have found little advantage to the image optimizer EXCEPT its ability to do more than jpg conversions and its text addition ability.
end results is what matters guys, i can have an 800x600 high quality image at extremely small files, while you are stuck with your 640x480 ones at the same file sizes as mine.
the choice seems easy, but.....
bottom line, i will notice images over 100k, and will point them out anytime i feel they are unwarranted, if you want to fight about it then, so be it, but I'd rather have harmony now about it.
be good
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Jinx on 
    Thu Jan 22nd 2004 at 9:03pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Jinx
                            Jinx
            
                        member
     
            874 posts
        692 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Nov 27th 2002
                            Location: Ohio
             
                
                        I think it depends on what you are doing images for, too. if I am showing a few pics of a map to show it off, I'll make sure they are really good quality even if the filesizes are slightly higher. If I am using a bunch of pics to show someone a bug in a map etc., I will use smaller images (320x240 even) and lower quality.
Anyway, as long as people aren't posting anything ridiculously huge, or too many at once, I don't think it's that big a deal...
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Dr Brasso on 
    Fri Jan 23rd 2004 at 1:26am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            1878 posts
        198 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 30th 2003
                    Occupation: cad drafter
                            Location: Omaha,NE
             
                
                        post summary.... :heee:
im hoping Leps got unlimited webspace, cause im thinkin' hes got one on the line here... :wink: his call on quality vs quality vs quantity....bottom line.
Doc B... :dodgy:
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Gorbachev on 
    Fri Jan 23rd 2004 at 6:38am
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            1569 posts
        264 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Dec 1st 2002
                            Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
             
                
                        PaintShop Pro is great for optimizing images. I usually use a combination of Photoshop and PSP because Photoshop likes to have huge files for no real reason, the quality is neglible. Oh well, I recommend a combo of the two.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by ReNo on 
    Fri Jan 23rd 2004 at 9:19pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             ReNo
                            ReNo
            
                        member
     
            5457 posts
        1991 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Aug 22nd 2001
                    Occupation: Level Designer
                            Location: Scotland
             
                
                        I think its bulls**t about sharpening being false advertising. Personally I find screenshots tend to be dull looking slightly blurry versions of the maps appearance in game, and as such I always resize, sharpen, and set the contrast to around 10, to try and return it to its original look.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Jinx on 
    Fri Jan 23rd 2004 at 9:31pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             Jinx
                            Jinx
            
                        member
     
            874 posts
        692 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Nov 27th 2002
                            Location: Ohio
             
                
                        Yeah, what Reno said. I RUN the game in higher res, so when I shrink it down I would like to restore some of the detail that's lost. and how HL looks in-game varies a lot on your video card and its detail settings. I think screenies etc. actually looked better on my old Voodoo 5 than this GF4. That card had great texture detail settings.
You maps will also look a lot more crisp if you use only textures with dimensions of 16, 32, 64, 128, & 256.
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by FoX1 on 
    Fri Jan 23rd 2004 at 9:37pm
                     
                    
                 
                
            
            
                
    
                    
                             FoX1
                            FoX1
            
                        member
     
            14 posts
        1 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Sep 23rd 2003
                    Occupation: Lead Enviornment Artist
                            Location: Michigan USA
             
                
                        You have to look at it from the other side of the coin as well.  When a modeller shows a nice pretty render they use programs like Brazil to enhance the post rendering process.   When I create textures for wads I don't add anything to the end process other then making the file size double of what it should be.  Mappers are just trying to show something that looks more appealing than the original.   HL was pretty in it's day but you just can't compete any longer with the new tech of today.
FoX1
                                    
             
        
            
            
                                     
                                
                    
                        Re: Image Editing
                        Posted by Forceflow on 
    Fri Jan 23rd 2004 at 11:08pm
                     
                    
                        
                        Posted 
    2004-01-23 11:08pm
                     
                 
                
            
            
                
    
            2420 posts
        451 snarkmarks
        Registered: 
    Nov 6th 2003
                    Occupation: Engineering Student (CS)
                            Location: Belgium
             
                
                        1 word: Gameplay
I think HL still can compete with lots of games these days.