Re: flf_lombardi:source
Posted by Gwil on
Sun Feb 27th 2005 at 3:59am
Gwil
super admin
2864 posts
315 snarkmarks
Registered:
Oct 13th 2001
Occupation: Student
Location: Derbyshire, UK
Yarr, Orph is right :smile: Think of them 56ker's :smile:
Nice shots, BTW - but as with what i've seen with DoD Source, I feel the maps could be scaled up and the world geometry edited a lot to reflect the capability of the Source engine.
Nothing wrong with a port, but a port with noticeable adaptations is MUCH better, IMO :smile:
Re: flf_lombardi:source
Posted by Devious on
Sun Feb 27th 2005 at 4:43am
25 posts
113 snarkmarks
Registered:
Oct 17th 2004
Occupation: CAD - strucural steel
Location: Bolton,UK
Sorry about the screenshot size , i will reduce them tomorrow.
I should have known , i read a forum thread about it when joined just before xmas.But with going elsewhere when snarkpit was down I got used to doing bad things
Sorry 56k'ers :rolleyes:
Re: flf_lombardi:source
Posted by Guessmyname on
Sun Feb 27th 2005 at 9:32am
342 posts
173 snarkmarks
Registered:
Dec 6th 2004
Odd, those links just give me
"Document contains no data"
warnings...
Re: flf_lombardi:source
Posted by keved on
Sun Feb 27th 2005 at 11:18am
Posted
2005-02-27 11:18am
252 posts
515 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jan 21st 2005
Occupation: Games designer, Rockstar Leeds
Location: Leeds, UK
Looking quite good so far. Like some of the others have said, there is scope to add more visual detail. Things like columns down the side of the wall in pic 1, trims around the pavement in pic 2, wherever you use textures containing window recesses build the recess with brushwork too, and so on.
Re: flf_lombardi:source
Posted by Leperous on
Sun Feb 27th 2005 at 1:01pm
Leperous
Creator of SnarkPit!
member
3382 posts
1635 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 21st 2001
Occupation: Lazy student
Location: UK
I 3rd/whatever that- check out the CS:S maps and see what sort of extra detail you can add and get away with.
Also, the lighting seems wrong- the sun is almost down, yet the lighting is that of midday (wrong shadows & general ambiance), and the street lights are on!
Re: flf_lombardi:source
Posted by ReNo on
Sun Feb 27th 2005 at 3:33pm
ReNo
member
5457 posts
1991 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 22nd 2001
Occupation: Level Designer
Location: Scotland
I agree with the consensus that there is room for more structural
detail, but from a convincing town point of view I think you've done a
great job. The buildings for the most part look unique and varied, and
the 3D skybox is one of the nicest I've seen so far. There are a few
niggles I'll point out...
Screen 1 - The ultra bumpy edge to the grass meeting the wall looks highly unrealistic.
Screen 2 - The curved pavement looks kinda awkward, and the trim
texture you have used on the side looks really dark in comparison to
the top material.
Screen 3 - The huge flat expanse of wall to the left of the archway looks really dull.
Screen 4/5 - I absolutely love the entire building line on the left of
screenshot 4, but if I'm brutally honest, the church at the back looks
kinda crappy. I think its down the textures used and the lack of light
variation on it rather than the structural design. The road just ending
when it hits that wall looks wrong to me as well, though I've no real
alternative to suggest.
Overall I think you're doing a good job with it, keep it up.
Re: flf_lombardi:source
Posted by Adam Hawkins on
Sun Feb 27th 2005 at 5:27pm
858 posts
333 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 25th 2002
Occupation: Specialty Systems Manager
Location: Chesterfield, UK
I like it so far :smile: Perhaps still a bit too much 'legacy' HL1 brushwork that could be spruced up - get rid of some more of the right-angles, and vary the height of the buildings more.
Nice to see FLF is still chugging along...you're almost making me feel guilty for not sticking around! :wink: I'll get myself back on IRC soon so we can have a chat.
Re: flf_lombardi:source
Posted by Devious on
Sun Feb 27th 2005 at 6:10pm
25 posts
113 snarkmarks
Registered:
Oct 17th 2004
Occupation: CAD - strucural steel
Location: Bolton,UK
Thats for all your comments guys, and I agree with nearly all of them especially the lighting & direction. Not a lot slips past you lot :smile:
I didn't want to scale the map up as bigger maps just dont play well on flf. I set out really to give the map a lick of paint and have mostly achieved this.
I will work on the points you have mentioned and update the shots.
p.s screenshots have been optimised.