Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Wild Card on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 6:59pm
2321 posts
391 snarkmarks
Registered:
May 20th 2002
Occupation: IT Consultant
Location: Ontario, Canada
Many people blame the games. Is why some games (like Max Payne) have put in some parental locks. Still, people who blame games are morons, the movie industry is as bad and no one blames them. Not that I do but still.
And parents should be more responsible. That I totaly agree on.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Leperous on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 7:02pm
Leperous
Creator of SnarkPit!
member
3382 posts
1635 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 21st 2001
Occupation: Lazy student
Location: UK
I suppose it's the game's fault they had shotguns, too...
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Gollum on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 7:23pm
Gollum
member
1268 posts
525 snarkmarks
Registered:
Oct 26th 2001
Occupation: Student
Location: Oxford, England
What a responsibility-dodge :rolleyes: I'm sure $256 million had something to do with the claim as well.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Campaignjunkie on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 7:24pm
1309 posts
329 snarkmarks
Registered:
Feb 12th 2002
Occupation: Student
Location: West Coast, USA
Oh well, we win in the long run. Pretty soon the generation that played games as kids will be in power; no more Lieberman or whatever to bitch and such.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by KoRnFlakes on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 7:28pm
1125 posts
511 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jul 3rd 2002
Occupation: Yus!
Location: Norfolk
Movies influence I suppose a sort of aggressive nature (very little) into me far more than games, But it would be stupid to say they make me do anything.
Shooting games, I dunno, Ive always treated it as strategy - Choosing which weapon is best here or here, I never actually think about it being a gun I spus.
I can honestly say I never really get into games heavily unless they are team based or one of the very few war games that actually realise that the english were involved.
Its moronic to blame games on acting out things as severe as this, Once you stop playing a game, It should just end there.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by R@lph VViggum on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 7:38pm
156 posts
211 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jun 11th 2003
Occupation: Level Designer
Location: Illinois
It's those dumbass kid's parents fault. There is no way they could have bought that game without an adult. Those parents won't win in court, because it's rated mature. Mature games can only be bought by those 18+ age. It's these dumbass retards and their idiotic parents who try and blame this stuff on others cause they are to stupid to accept the fact they suck at parenting and their childern are messed up in the head.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Orpheus on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 7:41pm
Orpheus
member
13860 posts
2024 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 26th 2001
Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA
a woman, bought some hot coffee from mikeyD's
put the cup between her legs when she drove out from the pickup window.. pressed the brakes, squashed the cup, burned the hell out of her genitalia, sued mcdonalds.. won lots of money..
strange s**t happens..
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Sim on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 7:42pm
Sim
member
257 posts
96 snarkmarks
Registered:
Sep 30th 2002
Occupation: Student
Location: UK
Myself I don't watch 18 films or play 16 rated games. I do blame parenting when 8-year-old kids watch things like South Park and play GTA. It's not dangerous, but it's downright reckless. I don't blame games or movies though for kid's actions. I've seen kids about 6 crossing the main road on their own, and also about 9 year olds staying out in the evening. I also blame parents for that. Two generations ago there were none of these problems, and kids were much better behaved.
(edit)I agree with Korn about games. I think of them as a strategy and not about the violence. However you could say this is bad. Maybe it will do kids good to go to the Holocaust museums and see what really happens in war.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Tracer Bullet on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 8:07pm
2271 posts
445 snarkmarks
Registered:
May 22nd 2003
Occupation: Graduate Student (Ph.D)
Location: Seattle WA, USA
It's absolutly correct to blame the parents. however, you can't claim that these games don't effect us. it's a statistical fact that people who play shooters are more capable of actualy shooting in real life. not that it makes them more likely to commit a crime, only that those who are imbalenced enough to do somthing like this are better at it from playing. that's why the military uses such things in training.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Orpheus on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 8:13pm
Orpheus
member
13860 posts
2024 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 26th 2001
Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA
your first mistake TB was saying the word "statistical" :biggrin:
personally, i doubt it, but see the potential.
i live in arkansas, i have butchered animals most my life, it still bothers me to sickness :sad:
i don't see games with fake blood removing that..
but, anything is possible :/
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Tracer Bullet on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 8:35pm
2271 posts
445 snarkmarks
Registered:
May 22nd 2003
Occupation: Graduate Student (Ph.D)
Location: Seattle WA, USA
I'm not talking about the violence per se. certainly not the blood. I personlay don't think I could handle skinnig a deer. the most I've ever done is gutted a fish. I would think hunting or sloughtering would have the effect of forceing home a realization of the consequences of your actions.
it's more the tactical aspects that the games teach, and the inherent detachment. Ammo conservation and such. What I've heard is that in training police and military personel, it is nessicary to train them not to simply keep shooting until the traget goes down. it's instinctive, but inefficent. Kids who grow up on these games, are pretrained in this way. I remember hearing alot after the thurston, and colombine incedents, about how strange it was that the kids would shoot someone once or twice and move on, rather than pumping a whole clip into one person, as years of experience in training militray personel had led them to expect.
note that this is all heresay, but it makes alot of sense.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by KungFuSquirrel on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 10:46pm
Posted
2003-10-26 10:46pm
751 posts
393 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 22nd 2001
Occupation: Game Design, LightBox Interactive
Location: Austin TX
I highly recommend reading "Killing Monsters" by Gerard Jones. I'm still pushing my way through it right now, but it's a very good piece on the subject.
Another thing to keep in mind is that, at this point, there is as much evidence linking violent behavior to violent media as there is evidence that would seem to disprove such a link - in fact, there are studies where children show greater aggressive tendency after watching Mr. Rogers neighborhood. That study also seemed to indicate that if there is any link between media and aggressive behavior, it's the amount of exposure to media in general rather than specific exposure to violent media - keep a healthy mix of social interaction with your media exposure and you're much better off than just being isolated away from the real world.
Numerous cases similar to this have been dismissed, and it seems that slowly but surely games are gaining respect. I think the key is (partially) teaching the general public how games can be so much more than simple mindless killfests, and that it is as legitimate an entertainment and storytelling art form as any other media. If the general public continues to believe that these are so evil, we'll just continue to see more attempts to point the blame at the "great satan" so to speak. shrug
Just remember that music and movies have been grilled the same way games are now, and came out solidly on top in the long run.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Orpheus on
Sun Oct 26th 2003 at 11:05pm
Posted
2003-10-26 11:05pm
Orpheus
member
13860 posts
2024 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 26th 2001
Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA
what bothers me the most is the peoples general selectiveness about stuff.
i know i am biased because i drive for a living, but cell phones harm-maim-kill more people every day, than ALL other distraction driving topics combined, it is the #1 cause of all driver related incidents on our roadways today, but people persist in seeing it benignly :sad:
i just cannot get over how people associate "what-cause's-what" anymore.
i despise certain kinds of music, but would never consider it a root cause of violent behavior, same with TV, and gaming.
as weird as most of you think i am, i just cannot grasp the "blame someone else" mentality..
if a child turns out violent, it can usually be traced back to their family structure, IF one looks hard enuff, with peer pressure a close second..
still i can believe the Mr.Rogers thing, they did an interview with him once, and you know what??? he hated children, and on several occasions, became very angry with child extras onset :/
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Tracer Bullet on
Mon Oct 27th 2003 at 6:21am
2271 posts
445 snarkmarks
Registered:
May 22nd 2003
Occupation: Graduate Student (Ph.D)
Location: Seattle WA, USA
Orph, it's all a preception issue. a car accident, while horrible, does not capture the public imagination the way a gunshot wound does. statistical fact has no bearing on the leaning of a society as a whole. it is unemotional, and therefore meaningless to the masses. people do not take their predudices to any sort of logical conclusion.
You may note that more people die in one year on the roads of america than did in the whole of the Vietnam War, but that didn't prevent your generation from going insane over it.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by KoRnFlakes on
Mon Oct 27th 2003 at 8:26am
1125 posts
511 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jul 3rd 2002
Occupation: Yus!
Location: Norfolk
mobiles = uber hefty fines over here now afaik. In the hundreds of pounds at a time.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by Gav on
Mon Oct 27th 2003 at 9:36am
71 posts
7 snarkmarks
Registered:
Sep 4th 2003
Occupation: Accountant
Location: UK
Parents, definately parents in my opinion!
Ever since the Jamie Bulger case, People can be prosecuted for supplying overage films/games to kids (Even their parents). A good move in my opinion. Makes it a bit harder, maybe not cut iit out but makes it harder.
YEah I like the mobile thing, thats a good move!
In my town currently you get an on the spot fine for littering. ?50 (us$75) per time, including Cigarette butts.
Re: While i was broke down..
Posted by matt on
Mon Oct 27th 2003 at 10:50am
Posted
2003-10-27 10:50am
matt
member
1100 posts
246 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jun 26th 2002
Occupation: Student!
Location: Edinburgh
Parents shouldn't take all the blame. If the kids are in the wrong, then they should take some/all of the blame. Parents, just like television and the media can be a bad influence on the young mind. But those parents who are sueing the company that made the game that they say made their kids go out and kill a load of people need their heads examined.
It seems to me that some people must just be born with a natural disposition towards violence. After all, you don't see people who play games going around mimicing everything the game does. If they did, then we'd all the in trouble.