it's ironic that someone so blind can be so concerned about colour.Wonderful ambivalence. :biggrin:
reaper47 said:Hence "One group worked hard to be on top of things"
The only reason people are mostly white in Europe and we have better tools and technology (that's all we have) is because we're the descendents of the people who moved from the warmer, and much more appropriate south to the cold and harsh north. Our skin became pale, most died in the cold, and only those with the best tools survived. Now we made a sport of creating bigger and better tools, resulting in weapons and means of transportation that are superior to those of most other civilisations.
one group against all others, now it seems like ALL groups against just one.That's the same goddamned thing. Insofar as anyone has a right to being proud in their heritage, a white man is allowed to be proud of his, and you were right on that point. Ironically, as you extended your argument to figure whites as the civillized superiors of "poorly-behaved" minorities capable only of "protest, riot, and generally act[ing] like they were back in their home jungles," you did cross the line between pride and supremacy - and that is absolutely inexcusable. Again: get banned. If the Snarkpit tolerates this, I don't tolerate the Snarkpit.
Cassius said:
I don't stand idiotic prejudices in any degree. I won't pretend that my leaving would threaten the forums - I would simply not be comfortable with remaining in a community that accepts racism as an "opinion" one is "entitled to."
Frederick Douglass said:
"Liberty is meaningless where the right to utter one?s thoughts and opinions has ceased to exist. That, of all rights, is the dread of tyrants. It is the right which they first of all strike down. They know its power. Thrones, dominions, principalities, and powers, founded in injustice and wrong, are sure to tremble, if men are allowed to reason?
There can be on right of speech where any man?[is] compelled to suppress his honest sentiments.
Equally clear is the right to hear. To suppress free speech is a double wrong. It violates the rights of the hearer as well as those of the speaker."
HOMER, The Iliad said:
"To speak his thoughts is every freeman's right, in peace and war, in council and in fight."
George Orwell said:
"If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear."
Salman Rushdie said:First, you are always getting onto me about being intolerant of things I don't like, and yet, when you don't like what I say, you are just as intolerant. When someone says they are uncomfortable in a community that allows gay marriage by respecting people's right to marry who they want, you you automatically write them off as "one of those." Now, you are just like them, whether that is a good thing or a bad thing to you. Fact is, people either HAVE a right, or they DON'T. That means everyone. If you are uncomfortable in a community that respects anyone's right to free speech, no matter what they say, then you are just like those people which protest gay marriage, abortion and any other of those rights that you stick up for.
"What is freedom of expression? Without the freedom to offend, it ceases to exist."
Nickelplate said:I have scanned this thread for days and found it very distasteful but, I was curious.
Also the fact that whites are the only ones that CANNOT celebrate their heritage, etc.
Also, German-Americans such as myself always get called "nazi" no matter WHAT we do at family reunions....Embrace it, Nazis aren't so bad.
I am intolerant, then, yes. I see the paradox and embrace it.wow. what a display of egocentrics.. you honestly see your hypocrisy as paradoxal. extreme intolerance of extreme interolerance is still extreme intolerance. you don't have some sort of moral highground here.
We see in Nickelplate's stance a new iteration of the complex. Many minority voices responded to past oppression with declarations of pride, which evidently have swelled to the point of making certain whites feel threatened.celebration of race is a perpetuation of racism. same is said for whites.
I'm beginning to think, as you say, that the process may be entirely destructive.
Nickelplate said:So why the emphasis on color? You have a point that our culture allows explicit discrimination against Caucasians. I don't think there is any other way to view affirmative action. However, that doesn't seem to be your main point. My perception is that you are specifically upset that it is less acceptable for you to "celebrate your heritage" than for others. Correct?
- Tracer, I agree. It's not really PRIDE, per se. It's more of an "I'm glad I'm exactly who I am no matter who doesn't like it" thing. And everyone should be judged for and take responsibility for thier own actions.
Nickelplate said:Are you sure you didn't quote your History of the West from someone? You don't seem to have read it. You haven't acknowledged roughly half its points since originally posting it - you've fallen back on the position of resisting reverse discrimination, and have shied from any mention of your assertion of minorities' uncivilized origins in jungles, exclusive population of inner cities, etc. This is what we've been discussing since reply number one. You still haven't answered for it.
DUDE I'M NOT A RACIST!
Dude... Seriously... You know that tables are turning if not already turned to equality.You have some effort ahead of you if you plan on convincing me that my position is comparable with your stereotyping of African-Americans or Bewbies' irrational distaste for Mexicans.[quote]how can one come to the conclusion that nickel implied they supported his argument on racism?[/quote]To further illustrate the contradiction, picture Neo-Nazis drawing on Spinoza in philosophical debate.
Cassius said:Are you sure you didn't quote your History of the West from someone? You don't seem to have read it. You haven't acknowledged roughly half its points since originally posting it - you've fallen back on the position of resisting reverse discrimination, and have shied from any mention of your assertion of minorities' uncivilized origins in jungles, exclusive population of inner cities, etc. This is what we've been discussing since reply number one. You still haven't answered for it.
<DIV class=quote>
<DIV class=quotetitle>? quoting Nickelplate</DIV>
<DIV class=quotetext>DUDE I'M NOT A RACIST!