Re: Gentlemen, we've really got to stop.
Posted by Andrei on
Sun Dec 19th 2004 at 8:42pm
Andrei
member
2455 posts
1248 snarkmarks
Registered:
Sep 15th 2003
Location: Bucharest, Romania
(like multi_managers) :smile:
Re: Gentlemen, we've really got to stop.
Posted by kissmet on
Mon Dec 20th 2004 at 4:01am
kissmet
member
8 posts
1 snarkmarks
Registered:
Dec 20th 2004
Occupation: Fulltime WoW player.
Location: Norway
Prologue:
I started mapping back in the 90'ties when mapping meant connecting two or more vertexes and setting a floor and roof height. I've mapped for a long time, but releases over the last years have been few and scarce, my one time fame and honour has long faded since then.
Why did I post this? As a new user, but not quite a n00b, my point of view is that it is all about respect. In a fast growing community you often ending up having to earn it instead of getting it. Normally not getting respect means that you won't be treating anyone with it neither.
Somewhere it works great, other places not so good. In both cases you have to be a humble user.
As a new user I shouldn't go around correcting others, asking silly questions before reading the faqs, or post meaningless post. As a regular user you normally get the privilege of not having peoples second guessing you, sometimes it can make you forget your responsibilities (I've done this more than once). Other times new users just don't know when to stop and had it coming.
Anyhow, I'm glad I'm here and hopefully I'll get to help peoples without being stomped to much in the start ;-)
P.S. You are doing all doing great.
Re: Gentlemen, we've really got to stop.
Posted by Tracer Bullet on
Mon Dec 20th 2004 at 4:37am
2271 posts
445 snarkmarks
Registered:
May 22nd 2003
Occupation: Graduate Student (Ph.D)
Location: Seattle WA, USA
Kissmet, with that attitude, I don't expect you'll have any problems. :smile:
Orph, I don't quite see how you can classify yourself as a "n00b" just because there are things about mapping you don't know. To me, "n00b" implies not simply complete ignorance, but a demonstrated incapability or disinclination to find things out for yourself.
There are few mappers I would consider "great", ReNo, KFS, and Ferret come to mind. Most of the rest of us fall into a hazy category somewhere below their level. N00bism is an attitude, not a state of knowledge. There are some nameless souls who are permanent n00bs. No matter how long they hang around they will always be at the bottom of the food chain. However, there are others who never deserve, or indeed receive the label, however briefly they have been associated with the community. Basically, if you are smart, self-reliant, and reasonably humble, you can never be a true n00b. If you lack these characteristics, or are incapable of learning them, you are, and always will be one.
Re: Gentlemen, we've really got to stop.
Posted by Foxpup on
Mon Dec 20th 2004 at 4:40am
Foxpup
member
380 posts
38 snarkmarks
Registered:
Nov 26th 2004
Occupation: Student
Location: the Land of Oz
I'm inclined to agree with Tracer Bullet on this one.
Re: Gentlemen, we've really got to stop.
Posted by Andrei on
Mon Dec 20th 2004 at 12:22pm
Posted
2004-12-20 12:22pm
Andrei
member
2455 posts
1248 snarkmarks
Registered:
Sep 15th 2003
Location: Bucharest, Romania
I think a n00b is a simple new-comer who lacks knowledge and experience. Nothing more.
Re: Gentlemen, we've really got to stop.
Posted by Adam Hawkins on
Mon Dec 20th 2004 at 12:59pm
Posted
2004-12-20 12:59pm
858 posts
333 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 25th 2002
Occupation: Specialty Systems Manager
Location: Chesterfield, UK
I hadn't noticed that much flaming directed at new members - generally I think as a whole the more established members have been pretty darn accepting.
Oh, and were all newbies in certain areas. I certainly wouldn't consider myself top of my game - even after 'doing time' in the industry. There's always new things to learn, or things we just can't grasp no matter how hard we try.
My personal failing is map layouts - I create dozens of maps and only occasionally does one shine a little more than the others and reach completion.
Re: Gentlemen, we've really got to stop.
Posted by ribbz on
Mon Dec 20th 2004 at 1:00pm
10 posts
1 snarkmarks
Registered:
Dec 9th 2004
Occupation: Sole trader
Location: UK
As a new comer I have to admit it's best to keep it shut and learn before throwing yourself into the lions den by posting a s**t map!! :biggrin:
Re: Gentlemen, we've really got to stop.
Posted by Agent Smith on
Tue Dec 21st 2004 at 1:22am
803 posts
449 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 30th 2003
Occupation: Uni Student
Location: NSW, Australia
The only time I would ever flame anyone, particularly a n00b, is when they make comments on maps that aren't of any use to anyone, or act like they are the king of mapping and therefore have the right to tell people their work sucks, despite the fact they have no experience or work of their own.
I was, like everyone else, a n00b once (about 4 years ago). But, like most n00bs, I knew my place, graciously and gratefully accepting usefull advice and criticism because the people with experience generally knew more than me. It's only when they get too big for their briches that they get flamed.
To my knowledge I've only partially flamed one person on this site, and more than likely it will be the only person.
I think the best option in this case would be if you haven't got anything nice or constructive to say, don't say anything at all.