No they work wonderfully as two movies. Also, it helps give it that EPIC Revenge feel.
I actually like the Matrix sequels. Not as much as the original by any means, but they are good. Reloaded needs editing (Rave, CG parts of Burley Brawl, Zion scene arangement) Revolutions doesn't need touching up at all, I think people just had a chip on their shoulder from Reloaded.
But yes they are essentially one movie ... however, would have sat there for 5+ hours watching it? I doubt it. Also, they were both edited differently. Revolutions was edited (If I'm not mistaken) by the 'Brothers' and Reloaded was mostly left up to the studio (thus the editing it has). They also wanted Reloaded to be hyped and Revolutions to just come out. Revolutions is what had the importance of the three movies, really. Secondly, I don't think anyone really has a right to say they did anything 'wrong' since it was their creation and they played it out how they saw fit. And that last scene in Revolutions, the Super Bruly Brawl I believe they called it, is only something that would be created out of passion for the story as directors, animators, and actors. A studio would not want to produce something like that. Revolutions cost so much money, it's rediculous, they literally used everything at their disposal, and I'm not talking about the CG bulls**t.
Anyway, that's my take on it.
Secondly, I heard that they were going to re-edit Reloaded and Revolutions to put the film footage from Enter The Matrix in ... but I don't think I could handle Reloaded if it were longer
But to be honest it needs a little tweaking and it would be wonderful ...
As for Kill Bill, Volume 1 had little character development except for The Bride and Oren. In volume 2 everyone is fleshed out and has depth brought into them. You find youself "understanding" why certain choices were made. By far Volume 2 is not a light hearted film, or at least not as light hearted as volume 1 was. However, if you're looking for the same amount of action that was in Volume 1 you wont find it in Volume 2, because that's simply not what it's about. But believe me, it surpasses the first half of the story.
But dammit, I want to see those scenes with David Carradine fighting and stuff ... they're in the trailors but not the films. Weird ... anyway, I've writen way too much in this post.
[EDIT]
Yeah, Troy looks bad ass. I think the one thing I'm looking forward too the most is watching Orlando Bloom die!! because he's a terrible actor. And taking that the movie is based on The Iliad, he dies. Everyone dies, almost.
By the way, that hunk of crap "I, Robot" looks like such utter crap I can't even imagine how bad it is.
[/EDIT]