Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Orpheus on
Mon Nov 20th 2006 at 4:57pm
Orpheus
member
13860 posts
2024 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 26th 2001
Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA
Let it die gracefully.
The atmosphere that made this site what it originally was is now gone. All people like me do is reminisce about the good ol' days. Virtually every time I attempted to initiate a promotional idea, some asswipe either ruined it outright, or found some ulterior motive on my part which eventually ruined it.
I say, Let the old Snarkpit die.
If you want a new one with the same name, create one that doesn't constantly compare the past, with the future you want to build.
No site you can envision, will be that good, so you will always feel disappointed with it.
The best things in life, aren't things.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Bewbies on
Mon Nov 20th 2006 at 5:17pm
Bewbies
member
413 posts
41 snarkmarks
Registered:
Sep 10th 2003
Occupation: IT Dude
Location: US-of-A
or maybe we could all migrate to prefabland..? =D
the players tried to take the field
the marching band refused to yield
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by fishy on
Mon Nov 20th 2006 at 6:40pm
fishy
member
2623 posts
1476 snarkmarks
Registered:
Sep 7th 2003
Location: glasgow
maybe, if fewer people were made to feel alienated, there would be less need of recruitment drives.
i eat paint
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by SpiKeRs on
Mon Nov 20th 2006 at 7:17pm
193 posts
729 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jun 14th 2003
Community wise, at least regarding numbers, how does Snarkpit compare these days to other sites? As you've said yourself the modding community in general isnt what it was and Snarkpit (along with most other sites) is affected by that.
Hello there.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Dark Tree on
Mon Nov 20th 2006 at 7:30pm
646 posts
264 snarkmarks
Registered:
Apr 30th 2004
Occupation: DigiPen student
Location: USA
<span style="color: silver;">I fully intend on gathering lots and lots of new ppl to the SnarkPit with the new competition. I am just waiting on some other people right now for confirmation. It will be an injection of life and popularity to the SnarkPit I can guarantee.
So soon there should be some fresh new meat! :wink:
</span>
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Andrei on
Mon Nov 20th 2006 at 7:54pm
Andrei
member
2455 posts
1248 snarkmarks
Registered:
Sep 15th 2003
Location: Bucharest, Romania
K I WILL ESSEMLBE TEH MASSES!1 :biggrin:
(in a totally unrelated note, this is my 2000th spam post)
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Mr.INSANE on
Mon Nov 20th 2006 at 9:38pm
156 posts
86 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jan 29th 2006
Occupation: Student
Location: California,USA
It Would be nice if there was like a way to find out about the irc chan. I had to find it by searching old topics maybe a sticky with like IRC CHAN HERE ROFLS
Why Do we all have to wear these ridiculous ties
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Crono on
Mon Nov 20th 2006 at 10:02pm
Posted
2006-11-20 10:02pm
Crono
super admin
6628 posts
700 snarkmarks
Registered:
Dec 19th 2003
Location: Oregon, USA
The problem is, people are having a hard time with the learning curve of newer games. Something big happened to game industry since 1998 and people are either too busy playing the games, or just lost interest within a short about of time.
I think, since moding and mapping are much larger than they used to be, that people have grown into their own niche. You could snag new mappers, but generally, as has been seen, 9 out of 10 of them aren't people you'd want hanging around here due to irritation.
How do you fix this? It's difficult. One or two members doing something does fix s**t. The attitude of the community is what needs to change.
Being masters of HL1 editing doesn't mean nearly as much as it did a couple years ago and people don't want to let that go, it seems.
No more religious, political, racism threads or any topic that doesn't have an explicit warning that you may be offended by reading and 'debating' what is contained. The s**t-slinging really shows a poor light on the people who regular here. If people can be civil (those slim occasions), that's one thing, but that isn't what usually happens.
Generally, showing higher respect for other people's right to think however they wish would need to be shown, no matter how much you may be disgusted with their opinion. Chances are if you show that kind of respect (or ignore them) they wouldn't say it anyway.
If you get rid of that harsh edge, then more people would probably stick around.
As for editing, since this is predominantly a game editing site, get your f**king skills out of the toilet. Being able to create a masterpiece in HL1 is great, but old, tired, and ancient in the gaming realm.
Learn new engines. Develop inspiring new maps. New mods. New ANYTHING. Just anything that shows some sort of inspiration.
If that doesn't work: gear the site towards something else that people are interested in.
Give something other communities don't.
If you disagree: politely disagree or confirm what I'm saying.
I can't personally add anything right now because of school. But I will be working on some projects some time in the near future that I could display (primarily) here. The nice thing is, if I own it I'm not confined by NDAs.
Blame it on Microsoft, God does.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by smackintosh on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 12:32am
Posted
2006-11-21 12:32am
175 posts
38 snarkmarks
Registered:
Feb 12th 2006
I'm new here, and I don't know if I'm welcome here or not. I have not contributed anything (yet). Honestly, I don't know if I'm in the same league as far as mapping goes, but I'm trying. I'm currently working on several maps (hopefully post-worthy) to get feedback on.
This place is a great resource for tutorials and mapping help, I've learned alot here. Its a good place for creative people to show off their maps and get good insight and ideas about their creations, the do's and don'ts of mapping...
I generally ignore politically fueled conversations. On ANY site it seems to lead to flame wars and people belittling each other. So, I just don't post my religious or political beliefs, its got nothing to do with why I'm here, and I don't feel like arguing with anyone. Some of my best friends in life have completely opposite political views than me, but I still respect them.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Gorbachev on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 12:39am
Posted
2006-11-21 12:39am
1569 posts
264 snarkmarks
Registered:
Dec 1st 2002
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
There are plenty of newer people who've joined that have nothing beneficial to post nor anything of substance, they either bring typical BB drivel or threads or basically respond in an egotistical manner to just about anything someone says. Even if they were joking their sarcasm and way with words just plain sucks. I got turned off the site and mapping when the curve started bending towards either looks with no regard to efficiency or farcical gameplay such as killboxes for new engines.
It was once a place that abstained from this, but I hardly post now because anytime I read a thread I get angered from the brutally ignorant / intellectually insulting posts or I have nothing of worth to add (often because my viewpoints mimic Crono) and close the window after writing a partial rebuttal. I see many posts that I think the postee should have done the same.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Cassius on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 3:56am
Cassius
member
1989 posts
238 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 24th 2001
Our current condition is the product of the editing community's sudden decline compounded by our tendency towards keeping our circle small. There are no more greats for us to induct, no more strides in our understanding of our chosen engine - simply not much to talk about. HL2's release, for whatever reason, vacated nearly every editing circle, and those still interested in developing material cater to audiences that I doubt could even remember the fantastic production values of HL1 releases - developments in technique that vastly bettered the game's appearance. I count this as a fulfillment of my old prediction: when engines become too powerful, the value of the art they render diminishes.
I think most newcomers are unconcerned with General Banter's nuclear exchanges. Immediately to mind as another contributing factor is Lep's absence - masterfully, he designed a uniquely self-sustaining website, but without a head any body will die.
It occurs to me that chickens survive without heads. As Orpheus says, I prefer we preclude that end. No matter our way out, the site will stand as an impressive archive of knowledge regardless of whatever community haunts its boards.
[Im_invisible] "I would suck a man off, but only for sustenance."
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Mr.INSANE on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 4:01am
156 posts
86 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jan 29th 2006
Occupation: Student
Location: California,USA
Why would people want to join a dieing site? Comments like just let it die make me want to join other sites
Why Do we all have to wear these ridiculous ties
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Campaignjunkie on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 7:55am
1309 posts
329 snarkmarks
Registered:
Feb 12th 2002
Occupation: Student
Location: West Coast, USA
I think Lep is the biggest factor here - but honestly I don't think he's coming back.
I have a little hope though. The mapping style for Portal is very brush / gameplay focused and centered around challenges rather than epic adventures. I think it'll boost the HL2 design community when it comes out.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by SpiKeRs on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 10:17am
Posted
2006-11-21 10:17am
193 posts
729 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jun 14th 2003
I don't know if its been tried before at Snarkpit but how about doing regular news updates about games, mods, steam updates etc like Interlopers, PHL, HL2.net, it seems to encourage more activity on the forum (I wont comment on some of the quality of it, thats another issue :smile: ).
Hello there.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Gwil on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 3:46pm
Gwil
super admin
2864 posts
315 snarkmarks
Registered:
Oct 13th 2001
Occupation: Student
Location: Derbyshire, UK
It's being worked on, don't worry. I was hoping to do something this
evening regarding getting the competition up but it could be a push - I
have an extra shift to work, and in between that im on duty tidying the
house and making some tea!
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Orpheus on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 3:58pm
Orpheus
member
13860 posts
2024 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 26th 2001
Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA
Everyone has their viewpoint that's easy, whats harder to recognize is that everyone hasn't quite hit the nail on the head. Its, at least in my humble opinion, a conglomerate of everyones viewpoint and yet, not so.
People like Fishman had/have a good point but failed to express where and who was doing the damage. That's not wrong but its also a big missing and valid point. I am not trying to get him to go that extra inch either and commit himself to a definite position, that would be very very wrong of me. I only point it out because it too is valid.
People like Nickel, who somehow see me as giving up easily? Where the f**k have you been these last few YEARS? How can years be considered giving up easily? Worse are the people thinking the exact opposite of Nickel and think that I try to hard. This was a massive point between Morph and myself. I will not go into any details, but was very offencive in his viewpoint about my contributions here. The point is, you cannot win after a sentiment like these. There will always be those who think you try to little and those who think you try to hard. You are always branded an underachiever or an over achiever. :rolleyes:
There can be an argument that you should learn the newer engines. THIS is a valid point but the fact of the matter is that there are some communities who are still thriving with the older engines. My point here is, way to many people alienate those who only desire is to remain WITH THE OLDER ENGINES!!! There is always someone harping about why you should move on. Its creating an atmosphere of tension that could be avoided by simply accepting that some of us like the comfortableness of old and proven. This site could benefit 10 fold if people would just stop resorting to bitching. We spend an inordinate amount of time apologizing for needlessly caused grief.
Worse of all is the FALSE image of elitism's. In fact this site is one of the least likely to have such a viewpoint. The fact of the matter is, it is normally the ones who have caused themselves to be set apart who view Snarkpit AS AN ELITE WEBSITE. They themselves have been a nuisance and created the image through their actions and deeds.
Sadly, most of our newer arrivals have a blind spot where the older members are concerned. This site has a caste that's true enough, but very few of the older members actually demonstrate any tendency to resort to using it. The newer members never take the time to explore who they are about to offend. We have members here who have donated years to the betterment of this site, and we have those who have been here years and contributed little. The point is, each has a history and you are about to infringe upon it in some way that in most cases will not be forgiven easily.
Right this moment I feel that Crono and Gorby have come the closest to expressing what I would like to say is the closest to not only exposing our problems, but give some slight hope of resolving them as well.
Concentrate your thinking along their lines of thought and you will be well on the road to a solution.
IMO, this site is not dying because Lep or any of the green names are missing. Get over that part. We have missing members who rival their contributions who never had a green name. It would be nice to have some people we could count on more but it isn't essential. This site is declining for its atmosphere, not its leadership. And no, before you say it, the leaders do not in any significant way dictate how that atmosphere will develop. Unless you consider that they may stifle a certain direction. That unavoidable. They have their rights as well as anyone.
The best things in life, aren't things.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Gwil on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 6:28pm
Gwil
super admin
2864 posts
315 snarkmarks
Registered:
Oct 13th 2001
Occupation: Student
Location: Derbyshire, UK
This is broken too, hmm?
Edit: This is all my fault :razz: I'll try and fix it ASAP! Gotta go to work now though...
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by BlisTer on
Tue Nov 21st 2006 at 6:32pm
BlisTer
member
801 posts
1304 snarkmarks
Registered:
Jun 10th 2004
Location: Belgium
General banter is why i keep coming here. There have always been heated discussions, insults and the ever-returning freedom of opinion question. This is not the reason for the general feeling of Snarkpit's decline. The feeling of decline is mainly due to the fact that Snarkpit is only general banter anymore, no added value of mapping etc. We all came here as mappers, now we have nothing here that reflects that aspect. Brave attempts have been made in the last 1,5 years to bring events that would hopefully motivate us to get the mapping engine running again.
The coming of HL2 was too big a hurdle to motivate us for 2005's whole-map compo. Opening it up to HL1 again, and making it a one-room compo improved things, but we didnt reach critical mass. IMO we need an accessible event/project that can captivate us enough to reach a critical mass of entrants. Once we have critical mass it will be something on which all eyes are fixed, and the everyday discussions will be regarded far more trivial than they seem now. And once we have critical mass, idle members will be incited to join in, simply seeing beautiful creations and saying "wow. how did he do that.. i can do that too.. i can do it better". That's how most of my maps got started anyway. Imo this is also the way to tease ppl into mapping for HL2. Like Orph said, you can't force ppl into a new engine. i think you can tease them into it though.
So far i might have given hope, but i'm not at all that optimistic. Simply because this project may not exist. A Snarkpit mod? we talked about it, we don't have the coders. This Map-a-trap compo? hopefully. i have my hope set on Dark Tree, but it's not all up to him. Maybe Crono's secret project, or a revived Mosaic project? who knows :wink:
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by smackintosh on
Wed Nov 22nd 2006 at 5:49pm
175 posts
38 snarkmarks
Registered:
Feb 12th 2006
I will have to work on some more then, thanks.
I'll try to post them in a new thread as I finish them
for approval. If anyone else want to make them too,
go ahead. I'll stick to garry's mod, because I can't draw.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Naklajat on
Thu Nov 23rd 2006 at 12:41am
Posted
2006-11-23 12:41am
1137 posts
384 snarkmarks
Registered:
Nov 15th 2004
Occupation: Baron
Location: Austin, Texas
Capt. P I think I love you for those links.
o
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by Orpheus on
Thu Nov 23rd 2006 at 11:05am
Posted
2006-11-23 11:05am
Orpheus
member
13860 posts
2024 snarkmarks
Registered:
Aug 26th 2001
Occupation: Long Haul Trucking
Location: Long Oklahoma - USA
The General portion of any site I have ever visited has always dominated the flow of the site. People just naturally tend to have more news to share that is non-specific to the sites design.
However, where each differ is how the site is governed. Dictatorships tend to be leaner, and meaner. Democracies tend to be more open, but flame ridden. The deciding factor isn't so much the leaders, but the leadership.
There is a tough lesson for newly elevated leaders, that few ever seem to grasp well. There are bosses, and there are simply bossy people. The old adage that leaders are born is for the most part true enough but in a setting where the people are very unlikely to ever meet, this ideal fails to materialize.
Leaders in a setting such as a forum are much more difficult to recognize. IE, Snarkpit has green names do designate leaders, but few if any of us would turn to one of them just because they were in the upper echelon. Most here would more likely approach a lesser member first.
Why?
There are some here who are going to disagree with this view, but that will not alter the perception much. Its still true, from a certain perspective and arguing it just makes it more obvious.
Anyway, one of the smaller issues with the decline of Snarkpit is its cadre. Not just the green ones, but everyone here who influences the direction of how things are accepted/argued.
Think on that a while.
The best things in life, aren't things.
Re: Promoting Snarkpit
Posted by fishy on
Thu Nov 23rd 2006 at 2:19pm
fishy
member
2623 posts
1476 snarkmarks
Registered:
Sep 7th 2003
Location: glasgow
i could have made a couple of connecting rooms in the time that it took you to write that.
as for one of your previous points, if i was to point a finger at anyone for stirring up unnecessary trouble or strife, it would, as you suggested, be pointed squarely at you.
"There are some here who are going to disagree with this view, but that will not alter the perception much. Its still true, from a certain perspective, and arguing against me just makes it more obvious."
c'est la vie.
i eat paint